Surveying Southern Mongolia: Application of multivariate classification methods in drylands with low diversity and long floristic gradients

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Question: How do standard multivariate classification algorithms perform for Mongolian dryland vegetation characterized by low diversity and very long floristic gradients? Location: Southern Mongolian Gobi. Methods: We compared several widely used classification methods based on 1231 relevés obtained with a similar sampling method. We applied agglomerative cluster algorithms (flexible beta/FLEX, average linkage/UPGMA, weighted linkage/WPGMA, complete linkage, Ward's clustering) and a divisive classification technique (TWINSPAN); data were reduced to presence/absence. We compared results against a published phytosociological classification (PHYTO), against environmental background data, and with respect to the presence of significant indicator species. Results: Complete linkage was inferior to other methods. TWINSPAN, UPGMA, flexible beta and WPGMA gave partly similar clusters, with FLEX and WARD showing the highest pair-wise similarity. Classifications of all methods except CL partly agreed with PHYTO classification. Clusters of all methods had significant indicator species, but Ward's method had the highest number of indicator species, followed by the PHYTO classification and FLEX, TWINSPAN, UPGMA and WPGMA. The latter four methods all yielded clusters that differed in terms of precipitation, but TWINSPAN, FLEX and Ward's method performed best under this criterion. PHYTO and CL ranked last in partitioning the precipitation gradient. Comparisons with ordinations indicated that classification algorithms capture the main floristic gradient but were less successful than the phytosociological approach to elucidate the finer structures. Conclusion: Performance of classification methods differed depending on the applied validation approach and we thus caution against uncritically adopting a single evaluation/validation criterion. Most numerical approaches can aid sorting of large data sets, while details of manual syntaxonomic classifications are not easily reproduced. Choice of the most appropriate classification and validation method thus clearly depends on the overall aim of a given study.
Original languageEnglish
JournalApplied Vegetation Science
Volume14
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)561-570
Number of pages10
ISSN1402-2001
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.10.2011

    Research areas

  • Ecosystems Research - Cluster analysis, Multivariate statistics, Steppes, Temperate deserts, Validation, Vegetation

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Kathrin Müller

Publications

  1. Fantasy about the future as friend and foe
  2. On the emergence of the in–out effect across trials
  3. Hot Extrusion Dies with Conformal Cooling Channels Produced by Additive Manufacturing
  4. Developing a Green Business Portfolio
  5. Parents’ Views of Video Games
  6. Migrationskontrolle durch Flüchtlingsschutz?
  7. Warrant price responses to credit spread changes
  8. Response diversity as a sustainability strategy
  9. Goldhagen-Debatte
  10. Cartel behaviour and efficient sanctioning by criminal sentences
  11. CorpusTracer
  12. Income distribution and willingness to pay for ecosystem services
  13. Playing for meaning
  14. Faktor Fünf
  15. Does money "buy" tolerance toward damage-causing wildlife?
  16. Introducing ‘cultures of rejection’
  17. Unmarked Graves: Yet Another Legacy of Canada's Residential School System
  18. Die Rolle der Lernsituation
  19. How to measure energy-efficiency of software
  20. Interkulturelles Lernen anhand von Bildnarrationen.
  21. Navigating cognition biases in the search of sustainability
  22. Consumer concerns about drinking water in an area with high levels of naturally occurring arsenic in groundwater, and the implications for managing health risks
  23. Predicting academic success with the big 5 rated from different points of view: Self-rated, other rated and faked
  24. Allele elimination recalculated
  25. Zwischen Erziehung und Unterhaltung
  26. Long-term degradation of Sahelian rangeland detected by 27 years of field study in Senegal
  27. Not Only the Miserable Receive Help
  28. Szenarien in der Unternehmensstrategie
  29. A leverage point perspective on serious games for sustainability transformation
  30. Der Sitz des Fahrers
  31. Reaction of Calcium Chloride and Magnesium Chloride and their Mixed Salts with Ethanol for Thermal Energy Storage
  32. Mathematik in Bewegung
  33. Lessons from Ethiopian coffee landscapes for global conservation in a post-wild world
  34. Kurze Pässe, lange Pässe
  35. Bremst das Schwerbehindertengesetz die Arbeitsplatzdynamik in Kleinbetrieben?
  36. National Ecosystem Assessments in Europe
  37. The insurance value of biodiversity in the provision of ecosystem services
  38. Sluts 'r' us
  39. Analyzing the social factors that influence willingness to pay for invasive alien species management under two different strategies
  40. Entwickler
  41. Germany
  42. Reichsstadt Frankfurt am Main
  43. Marina F. Bykova, Kenneth R. Westphal (Hrsg.) The Palgrave Hegel Handbook
  44. Miscounselling in the German Insurance Market-Utility-Orientated Implications for the Meaning of Miscounselling
  45. The German Bank Restructuring Act: An Economic Perspective