The Role of Formalisation, Participation and Context in the Success of Public Involvement Mechanisms in Resource Management

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Jens Newig
  • Veronika Gaube
  • Karin Berkhoff
  • Kai Kaldrack
  • Britta Kastens
  • Juliana Lutz
  • Bianca Schlussmeier
  • Heidelinde Adensam
  • Helmut Haberl
In the face of complex and uncertain issues, one important goal of public participation in resource management and research is to foster communication and the inclusion of non-expert knowledge-thus the effective flow of information between project organisers and stakeholders. We compare different methods (instruments, tools) that were employed in the German-Austrian 'PartizipA' project to structure information flows in participatory processes. Depending on their goals and context, more or less 'formalised' and 'participatory' methods were applied, the most important being guided interviews, focus groups, agent-based modelling, nutrient modelling, cognitive mapping and group model building as well as the development of a common document. Two regional case studies, both concerned with European-induced institutional change, are portrayed in which the specific participatory methods were embedded. The Austrian case study involved the analysis and modelling of agricultural land use in the region of St. Pölten against the background of the reform of the Common Agricultural Policy, while the implementation of recent European water policy was the issue in the German agricultural region north of Osnabrück. Presenting both cases in their regional context, the applied methods are first described according to the logic of the entire respective process. Subsequently, the specific methods are systematically analysed and compared according to their objective, context and degrees of participation and formalisation. Finally, we evaluate all methods regarding their effectiveness in terms of goal attainment and their potential generalisation, seeking to respond to the question of when a particular method might best be used. © 2008 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC.
Original languageEnglish
JournalSystemic Practice and Action Research
Volume21
Issue number6
Pages (from-to)423-441
Number of pages19
ISSN1094-429X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2008

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. »CO2 causes a hole in the atmosphere« Using laypeople’s conceptions as a starting point to communicate climate change
  2. Influence of Dy in solid solution on the degradation behavior of binary Mg-Dy alloys in cell culture medium
  3. Socio-technical instruments in the field of Integrated Water Resources Management
  4. An Adaptive Resonance Regulator Design for Motion Control of Intake Valves in Camless Engine Systems
  5. De-Anonymizing Anonymous
  6. A Hybrid Hydraulic Piezo Actuator for Camless Internal Combustion Engines Controlled with an MPC and an Affine Feedforward Structure
  7. Non-acceptances in context
  8. Thanking and responding to thanks in American English: Language patterning and contextual appropriateness
  9. Applying the Rasch sampler to identify aberrant responding through person fit statistics under fixed nominal α-level.
  10. Planning for Sea Spaces I: Processes, Practices and Future Perspectives
  11. Dadadatadada: From Dada to Data and Back Again
  12. Understanding needs embodiment
  13. Diversity of Play
  14. Entangled – But How?
  15. A path to clean water
  16. Grain size statistics, composition and provenance of fragmental particles in some Apollo 14 breccias
  17. New Methods for the Analysis of Links between International Firm Activities and Firm Performance: A Practitioner’s Guide
  18. Curatorial Practices of the ‘Global’
  19. Organic Synthesis – Art or Science?
  20. Motion-decoupled internal force control in grasping with visco-elastic contacts
  21. Computational Swarming
  22. Maintaining the impact of action-oriented entrepreneurship training
  23. Points of cooperation: integrating cooperative learning into web-based courses
  24. Learning how to request using textbooks
  25. What drives the spatial distribution and dynamics of local species richness in tropical forest?
  26. Analyzing a transition to a sustainability-oriented science system in Germany
  27. Do children with deficits in basic cognitive functions profit from mixed age primary schools?
  28. A qualitative view on first year university students’ assessment preparation
  29. Exploring biocultural diversity
  30. Domain adaptation of POS taggers without handcrafted features
  31. Current and New Research Perspectives on Dynamic Facial Emotion Detection in Emotional Interface

Press / Media

  1. Cyber-Feminist Urbanism