Understanding needs embodiment: A theory-guided reanalysis of the role of metaphors and analogies in understanding science

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Many authors stress the importance of basing teaching on students' prior knowledge. To build a bridge between students' everyday knowledge and scientific concepts, the role of metaphors and analogies came into the focus of the science education community during the past two decades. Approaches using metaphor-based teaching strategies often regard metaphors and analogies as teaching tools that can be adopted by a teacher. On the basis of the theoretical framework of experientialism, we argue that not only teaching but also thinking about and understanding science without metaphors and analogies is not possible. An analysis of studies dealing with metaphors and analogies in science education shows that instructional analogies and metaphors are often not understood as intended or not used by students in their own explanations. By reanalyzing 199 instructional metaphors and analogies on the basis of a metaphor analysis, we show that it takes more than making a connection to everyday life to communicate science fruitfully. We show that good instructional metaphors and analogies need embodied sources. These embodied sources are everyday experiences conceptualized in, for example, schemata such as containers, paths, balances, and up and down. For the analysis, we introduce the concept of conceptual metaphors for analyzing metaphors as well as analogies.
Original languageEnglish
JournalScience Education
Volume96
Issue number5
Pages (from-to)849-877
Number of pages29
ISSN0036-8326
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.09.2012

DOI

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. CfP Sektionstagung 2017
  2. Impact of Auditor and Audit Firm Rotation on Accounting and Audit Quality. A critical Analysis of the EC Regulation Draft
  3. Internationale Tagung Wirtschaftsinformatik - WI 2020
  4. The Century of Play: Keynote Lecture
  5. Internal Auditing for better Corporate Governance. An empirical study of the organization of internal auditing
  6. DFG-Kolleg-Forschergruppe MECS (Medienkulturen der Computersimulation) (Organisation)
  7. Leuphana Universität Lüneburg (Organisation)
  8. University-industry collaboration to stimulate learning in the context of sustainability-oriented innovations
  9. Journal of Applied Ecology (Zeitschrift)
  10. Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht Verlag (Verlag)
  11. Research and Teaching in the Field of Music and Auditory Culture from a Cultural Sciences Perspective
  12. Friction hysteresis compensation using phase correction of periodic trajectories
  13. ,,English Day'' an der Oberschule Jesteburg - 2020
  14. Place and placing in the Emergence of Start-ups and Start-up Culture: A dialectical Approach
  15. The Mediation of Business - 2013
  16. Fakultät Management und Technologie (Organisation)
  17. Grenzarbeit: Identität und Identifizierungsprozesse verstehen und verändern.
  18. Vom Nutzen enger Kanäle – Diskursverknappung als Methode - 2011
  19. From International Goodwill to Transnational Policy: The Demise of Trademark Property in Conflicts Doctrine
  20. Translating for children : what, for whom, how, and why.
  21. Technifizierte Theologie. Von der Muttergottes bis zu Wall-E
  22. Ringvorlesung "Maple Leaf & Stars and Stripes" WiSe 2011/2012
  23. Congress of Applied Psychology - IAAP 2006