Human Empowerment and Trust in Strangers: The Multilevel Evidence

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

For three decades, scholars have focused on generalized interpersonal trust as the key component of social capital and there is a wide consensus that trust in strangers is the prime indicator of people’s general trust in others. However, little work with a specific focus on trust in strangers has been conducted in a comparative multilevel framework. The few existing studies are inconclusive because of deficiencies in both conceptualization and test strategy. Filling this gap, this article examines the determinants of trust in strangers on the broadest country base ever used in the study of trust, drawing on global cross-cultural evidence from the fifth and sixth rounds of the World Values Surveys—the first international surveys to include a direct question on trust in strangers. Reaching beyond conventional wisdom about the sources of generalized trust, we demonstrate that human empowerment at the country level is a powerful moderator of well-known individual-level determinants of trust. Specifically, in countries with lagging human empowerment, institutional trust, trust in known people, and material satisfaction are the only individual-level characteristics that enhance trust in strangers. We also detect an unexpected negative effect of education where human empowerment is lagging. In sharp contrast, in countries with advanced human empowerment, a much broader set of individual-level characteristics increases trust in strangers. This set includes ethnic tolerance, membership in voluntary associations, social movement activity, emancipative values, subjective well-being, age, and education. These insights inform a multilevel theory of trust, showing that human empowerment operates as a contextual activator of individual trust promoters.

Original languageEnglish
JournalSocial Indicators Research
Volume139
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)923-962
Number of pages40
ISSN0303-8300
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.10.2018

    Research areas

  • Generalized trust, Human empowerment, Moderation effect, Multilevel modeling, Trust radius, Trust theories
  • Politics

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. 30. DGFF Kongress: „Paving New Ways for Student Mobility in Teacher Education – Students’ Perspectives on a Blended Intensive Programme”; co-presenter: Robert O’Dowd
  2. European Sociological Association (ESA) (Externe Organisation)
  3. Treffen des Netzwerks Jungewissenschaft Sozialdidaktik / Didaktik der Sozialpädagogik 2023 (Veranstaltung)
  4. BNE-Netzwerk der Region Lüneburg (Externe Organisation)
  5. Die (sub)politische Ethik des Beruflichen in der beruflichen Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung
  6. EUROCALL Conference: "Du hast eine Hand verloren.”, “Yeah that happened before.” – Investigating situated language in SVR; co-presenters: Breffni O'Rourke; Gillian Martin
  7. World Bank Conference "Female Entrepreneurship: Constrains and Opportunities"
  8. 7. General Conference of the European Consortium for Political Research - ECPR 2013
  9. Borderline Poetry: 20 years of German Unification as seen through Berlin literature
  10. Konsultation der Bundesweiten Koalition Kulturelle Vielfalt 2017
  11. Migration und soziale Arbeit (Fachzeitschrift)
  12. Fachtag des Arbeitskreises Migration Kreis Steinburg zum Thema AUSBILDUNG
  13. Jahresevent Alpen-Kulinarik 2011
  14. Fakultät Bildung (Organisation)
  15. „Also, das habe ich dann auch von mir heraus gemacht, und das mache ich auch ganz oft so, jetzt im Studium.“ Zwischen Distinktionsprofit und Defizitzuschreibung: Hybride Sprachpraxen an der Hochschule in der Perspektive Studierender
  16. 2. Österreichischer Tag der Politikwissenschaft 2012
  17. Kognitive Aktivierung im Hauptschulunterricht: erste Ergebnisse einer Video- und Fragebogenstudie
  18. Vortrag: Was ist eine gute Aufgabe?: Analyse und Weiterentwicklung der unterrichtlichen Aufgabenkultur.
  19. Sommerakademie der Studienstiftung des dt. Volkes, Weimar 2023
  20. Wie kann eine gerechte und dezentrale Energiewende gelingen?