Economie considerations regarding the mandatory insolvency petition under german law

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

The mandatory insolvency petition in German law represents an element of 'exit' liability in the law of stock corporations; it is a complement to the prohibition of payments, as regulated in § 64 (formerly Subsec. 2) GmbHG, §§ 92 Subsec. 2 (formerly Subsec. 3), 93 Subsec. 3 Nr. 6 AktG. The goal of pulling 'sick' companies from the market at the right time is economically appropriate; however, due to the inflexibility of the regulation in question, this goal is only partially realized. Of particular concern is the requirement of a mandatory insolvency petition even when there is a positive survival prognosis for the company; this prevents a successful restructuring while simultaneously triggering liquidation mechanisms. Furthermore, implementing the mandatory insolvency petition leads to high costs on the part of the operators of the debtor company. Therefore, it is preferable to withdraw the strict mandatory insolvency petition while simultaneously expanding prohibitions of payment (as already foreseen by the MoMiG) and also simplifying creditors' petition rights. A first, though only transitional step in this right direction was just recently taken in the FMStG. If, in the event of a positive survival prognosis for the company, one equips the stringent mandatory insolvency petition in accordance with the suggestions given here, not only will economic considerations be satisfied; moreover, convergence will be (re-)established with respect to European 'exit' liabilities in an important field. This would defuse problems arising in both European law and international private law vis-a-vis the applicability of German ,exit' liability to foreign companies; also, it would set a course for a Europe-wide harmonization of ,exit' liability. This shows that the development and petition of economic principles can make an important contribution toward solving problems of international law.
Original languageEnglish
JournalThe Journal of Interdisciplinary Economics (JIE)
Volume22
Issue number1-2
Pages (from-to)73-88
Number of pages16
ISSN0260-1079
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2010
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Law

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Mimicking and anticipating others’ actions is linked to social information processing
  2. A conceptual map of invasion biology: Integrating hypotheses into a consensus network
  3. sPlotOpen – An environmentally balanced, open-access, global dataset of vegetation plots
  4. How health message framing and targets affect distancing during the Covid-19 pandemic
  5. Sex differences in stretch-induced hypertrophy, maximal strength and flexibility gains
  6. Experteninterviews zur europäischen Reform der steuerlichen Gewinnermittlung (Teil II)
  7. Adapting livestock management to spatio-temporal heterogeneity in semi-arid rangelands
  8. The relationship between resilience and sustainability of ecological-economic systems
  9. Governance mit dem DQR zwischen neuer Instrumentenlogik und tradierter Strukturlogik
  10. A Geometric Approach to Decouple Robotino Motions and its Functional Controllability
  11. Prospects of wireless energy-aware sensors for smart factories in the industry 4.0 era
  12. Long-term efficacy of indicated prevention of depression in non-professional caregivers
  13. Waving goodbye to conflict of laws? Recent developments in European Union consumer law
  14. Low-intensity agricultural landscapes in Transylvania support high butterfly diversity
  15. UNESCO Biosphere Reserves: Supporting Biocultural Diversity, Sustainability and Society
  16. Resilience or vulnerability? Vegetation patterns of a Central Tibetan pastoral ecotone
  17. Predictive performance of plant species distribution models depends on species traits
  18. Multi-trophic guilds respond differently to changing elevation in a subtropical forest
  19. Trusting as a 'Leap of Faith': Trust-Building Practices in Client-Consultant Relationships
  20. A New Approach for Optimal Solving Cyclic and Non-Cyclic Bus Drvier Rostering Problems