Dichotomy or continuum? A global review of the interaction between autonomous and planned adaptations

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Gina Maskell
  • Roopam Shukla
  • Kripa Jagannathan
  • Katherine Browne
  • Nicola Ulibarri
  • Donovan Campbell
  • Christopher Paul Franz
  • Caitlin Grady
  • Elphin Tom Joe
  • Christine J. Kirchhoff
  • Mythili Madhavan
  • Lillian Michaud
  • Swarnika Sharma
  • Chandni Singh
  • Ben Orlove
  • Gabriela Nagle Alverio
  • Idowu Ajibade
  • Kathryn J. Bowen
  • Eranga K. Galappaththi
  • A. J. Hudson
  • Katharine J. Mach
  • Justice Issah Musah-Surugu
  • Jan Petzold
  • Diana Reckien
  • Bernhard Schauberger
  • Alcade C. Segnon
  • Bianca van Bavel
  • Christoph Gornott

Adaptation to climate change is often conceptualized as a dichotomy, with responses being either planned (formal and structured) or autonomous (organic and self-organized, often known as “everyday adaptation”). Recent literature on adaptation responses has highlighted the existence and importance of the interplay between autonomous and planned adaptation, but examination of this interaction has been limited to date. We use a global database of 1682 peer-reviewed articles on adaptation responses to systematically examine autonomous and planned adaptations, with an emphasis on how these types of adaptations interact with one another. We propose a third category, mixed adaptation, which demonstrates characteristics of both autonomous and planned types, and which recognizes nuances in how organization, external support, formality, and autonomy manifest in the fuzzy space between the two. We find that more than one-third of articles reporting on adaptation responses fall into this mixed category, with cases across sectors and world regions. We develop a qualitative typology of mixed adaptation that identifies nine ways that autonomous and planned adaptation interact and influence each other both positively and negatively. Based on these findings, we argue for more nuanced examinations of the interplay between autonomous and planned adaptation and for conceptualizing adaptation planning as a continuum between the two rather than a dichotomy. Exploring the patterns of interplay from a large database of adaptation responses offers new insights on the relative roles of both autonomous and planned adaptation for mobilizing adaptation pathways in locally relevant, scalable, effective, and equitable ways.

Original languageEnglish
Article number18
JournalEcology and Society
Volume30
Issue number1
Number of pages39
ISSN1708-3087
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 02.2025

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2025, Resilience Alliance. All rights reserved.

    Research areas

  • adaptation, autonomous, climate, everyday, governance, planned

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Handicaps in job assignment
  2. An integrative research framework for enabling transformative adaptation
  3. Metrics for Experimentation Programs: Categories, Benefits and Challenges
  4. The explanatory power of Carnegie Classification in predicting engagement indicators
  5. Effectiveness of Web- and Mobile-Based Treatment of Subthreshold Depression With Adherence-Focused Guidance
  6. Junior High School Students’ Length Estimation Skills and Use of Strategies for Making Estimations
  7. Mapping ecosystem services in Colombia
  8. Sustainable Development and Material Flows
  9. Data practices in apps from Brazil: What do privacy policies inform us about?
  10. Back to the future
  11. The Meaning of Higher-Order Factors in Reflective-Measurement Models
  12. Towards a socio-cognitive approach to knowledge transfer
  13. Variational Pragmatics
  14. The importance of product lifetime labelling for purchase decisions
  15. Foliar Endophytic Fungal Communities Are Driven by Leaf Traits—Evidence From a Temperate Tree Diversity Experiment
  16. Principals between exploitation and exploration
  17. Neuro-Symbolic Relation Extraction
  18. Establishment age and wages
  19. Tree and mycorrhizal fungal diversity drive intraspecific and intraindividual trait variation in temperate forests
  20. Mindfulness as an intervention to improve self-control
  21. Navigating (In)Visibility
  22. Analysis of Cognitively Activating Tasks in Vocational Education and Training of Nursing
  23. Aufgeschoben, nicht aufgehoben
  24. Composing with the terra fluida of interaction: new paths for CCO research as relational practice
  25. The conservation against development paradigm in protected areas
  26. Possible underestimations of risks for the environment due to unregulated emissions of biocides from households to wastewater
  27. Why Emergency? Reflections on the Practice and Rhetoric of Exceptionalism
  28. Powers of Abstraction
  29. Front, Field, Line, Plane
  30. A Kalman estimator for detecting repetitive disturbances
  31. Circularity in Automotive Electronics Design
  32. Effectiveness of an Internet- and App-Based Intervention for College Students With Elevated Stress