Complex problem solving and intelligence: A meta-analysis

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Matthias Stadler
  • Nicolas Becker
  • Markus Gödker
  • Detlev Leutner
  • Samuel Greiff

The purpose of this meta-analysis is to examine the nature and magnitude of the relation between complex problem- solving skills (CPS) and intelligence, a topic that has been widely discussed and that has instigated a vast array of partially contradicting findings in the past. Theoretically, researchers have hypothesized the two constructs to be everything from completely separate to identical. Over the course of almost four decades, empirical studies yielded results in support of both arguments. Our meta-analysis of 47 studies containing 60 independent samples and a total sample size of 13,740 participants revealed a substantial correlation of CPS and intelligence with an average effect size of M(g) = .433. In addition, we investigated whether the operationalization of CPS and intelligence moderated this correlation. Whereas there were no significant correlation differences considering the operationalization of intelligence, the approach used to measure CPS moderated the correlation of CPS and intelligence. Especially the most recent approach towards the assessment of CPS yielded the strongest associations between the two constructs. Implications for existing theories and future research are discussed.

Original languageEnglish
JournalIntelligence
Volume53
Pages (from-to)92-101
Number of pages10
ISSN0160-2896
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2015
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Complex problem-solving, Dynamic decision making, Intelligence, Meta-analysis, Multiple complex systems
  • Psychology

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Capitalizing on value dynamics
  2. Explaining primary school teachers’ usage of digital learning data: A mixed method study
  3. Frame-based Matrix Factorizations
  4. Efficient Replay Formats in Chat-Based CSCL for Re-Learning
  5. Beyond Gamification: From Problem-solving to Problem-making
  6. EvoLang XIII
  7. Reflexive Multi-Criteria Evaluation as a Tool to Integrate Multiple Values of Scientists and Stakeholders
  8. Improving the quality of selecting applicants for university student programs
  9. Teaching the machine how to assess grammar skills. Modelling verb-tense exercise characteristics as a basis for an adaptive E-learning system
  10. Performance resource depletion influence on performance: Advancing concepts and findings
  11. Keep It Simple, Make It Fast! Conference - KISMIF 2015
  12. Transdisciplinary Evaluation of Alternative Adaptation Strategies Value-Tree Method as a Tool to Integrate Multiple Values of Science, Practice and the General Public into Decision-Making
  13. Material Migrations I Online Lecture Series
  14. It's how, not what we use that matters - Communications Modes in the Internet
  15. Uncertainty and Subjectivity in Provenance Linked Open Data
  16. Using the Multiple Streams Framework and the Multi-Level Perspective to Explain Policy Transformation: The Case of the German Energiewende
  17. Seed dispersal and predation: Interactions, ecosystem functions and services
  18. Continuous Innovation through Modular Upgradeability: How Software Upgrades Affect Consumer Product Valuations
  19. Swarming. Science Fact and Science Fiction of Distributed Intelligence
  20. Validation of school inspection frameworks and methods

Publications

  1. XOperator - An extensible semantic agent for instant messaging networks
  2. Exploring Price Elasticity to Optimize Posted Prices in e-Commerce
  3. Introducing a multivariate model for predicting driving performance
  4. Situated multiplying in primary school
  5. Using Local and Global Self-Evaluations to Predict Students' Problem Solving Behaviour
  6. Validation of an open source, remote web-based eye-tracking method (WebGazer) for research in early childhood
  7. Should learners use their hands for learning? Results from an eye-tracking study
  8. Stepwise-based optimizing approaches for arrangements of loudspeaker in multi-zone sound field reproduction
  9. The role of spatial ability in learning from instructional animations - Evidence for an ability-as-compensator hypothesis
  10. Development and validation of a method for the determination of trace alkylphenols and phthalates in the atmosphere
  11. Backstepping-based Input-Output Linearization of a Peltier Element for Ice Clamping using an Unscented Kalman Filter
  12. A simple nonlinear PD control for faster and high-precision positioning of servomechanisms with actuator saturation
  13. The role of learners’ memory in app-based language instruction: the case of Duolingo.
  14. Towards a spatial understanding of identity play
  15. Empowering materials processing and performance from data and AI
  16. Intellectual property issues in the use and distribution of remote sensing data
  17. Explaining and controlling for the psychometric properties of computer-generated figural matrix items
  18. Metaphors and Paradigms of the Language Animal—or—The Advantage of seeing “Time Is a Resource” as a Paradigm
  19. Text Comprehension as a Mediator in Solving Mathematical Reality-Based Tasks
  20. Use of Machine-Learning Algorithms Based on Text, Audio and Video Data in the Prediction of Anxiety and Post-Traumatic Stress in General and Clinical Populations
  21. What would Colin say?
  22. Teachers’ use of data from digital learning platforms for instructional design
  23. How Much Home Office is Ideal? A Multi-Perspective Algorithm
  24. Dimension estimates for certain sets of infinite complex continued fractions