Can measurement errors explain variance in the relationship between muscle- and tendon stiffness and range of motion?—a blinded reliability and objectivity study

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Konstantin Warneke
  • Julia Meder
  • Gerit Plöschberger
  • Manuel Oraže
  • Maximilian Zechner
  • Daniel Jochum
  • Stanislav D. Siegel
  • Andreas Konrad

Introduction: The relationship between range of motion (ROM) and underlying parameters such as stiffness (ST) remains controversial throughout the literature. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze the potential role of accumulated measurement errors and subjective influences through a comprehensive assessment of both systematic and random errors on the correlation between tissue ST and ROM. Methods: A total of 75 subjects participated in this double-blinded reliability evaluation. Besides muscle thickness assessments, lower legs’ ST in the calf muscle and Achilles tendon (shear-wave elastography [SWE] and viscoelastic parameters [MyotonPRO], respectively) were correlated with ankle dorsiflexion ROM (knee-to-wall test [KtW]). Results: Ultrasound image acquisition (i.e., muscle thickness and ST) and myotonometry showed intrasession reliability (ICC = 0.93–0.99 and 0.72–0.99, respectively) depending on the device. Only for MyotonPRO, there were meaningful systematic and random errors only for decrement (SEM = 0.002–10.629; MAE = 0.01–24.84). ROM showed ICC > 0.99, while for all parameters interday reliability declined (ICC = 0.395–0.88). Interrater objectivity showed ICC = 0.61–0.91 for ultrasound analysis and 0.66–0.96 for myotonometry. No agreement (ICC = 0–0.09) between different ST measurements was observed, while relationship between ST and ROM depended on the investigator (r = 0.21–0.26 versus r = − 0.02–−0.07). Discussion: While aligned with reliability and objectivity metrics from the literature, our results demonstrate that ST determination is device-dependent, and its relationship with ROM varies by measurement day and investigator. This underlines clinically relevant measurement errors in ST evaluation, calling for advance standardization to improve reliability and objectivity, while measurement errors quantified beyond the ICC must not be neglected in future studies.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of Applied Physiology
ISSN1439-6319
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 11.06.2025

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2025.

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. A statistical study of the spatial evolution of shock acceleration efficiency for 5 MeV protons and subsequent particle propagation
  2. Identification of conductive fiber parameters with transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation signal using RLS algorithm
  3. A Lyapunov based PI controller with an anti-windup scheme for a purification process of potable water
  4. Age effects on controlling tools with sensorimotor transformations
  5. A Study on the Performance of Adaptive Neural Networks for Haze Reduction with a Focus on Precision
  6. Towards an Interoperable Ecosystem of AI and LT Platforms: A Roadmap for the Implementation of Different Levels of Interoperability
  7. A PHENOMENOGRAPHICAL STUDY OF CHILDRENS’ SPATIAL THOUGHT WHILE USING MAPS IN REAL SPACES
  8. Practice and carryover effects when using small interaction devices
  9. Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases
  10. Evaluating structural and compositional canopy characteristics to predict the light-demand signature of the forest understorey in mixed, semi-natural temperate forests
  11. A cascade controller structure using an internal PID controller for a hybrid piezo-hydraulic actuator in camless internal combustion engines
  12. Continuous and Discrete Concepts for Detecting Transport Barriers in the Planar Circular Restricted Three Body Problem
  13. A Hermeneutic Interpretation of Concepts in a Cooperative Multicultural Working Project
  14. Neural relational inference for disaster multimedia retrieval
  15. The relationship between audit committees, external auditors, and internal control systems
  16. Automatic feature selection for anomaly detection
  17. Can measurement errors explain variance in the relationship between muscle- and tendon stiffness and range of motion?—a blinded reliability and objectivity study
  18. Performance incentives in activity-based management
  19. Detection of coherent oceanic structures via transfer operators
  20. Challenges and boundaries in implementing social return on investment
  21. Determination of 10 particle-associated multiclass polar and semi-polar pesticides from small streams using accelerated solvent extraction
  22. Cascade PID Controllers Applied on Level and Flow Systems in a SMAR Didactic Plant
  23. Use of Machine-Learning Algorithms Based on Text, Audio and Video Data in the Prediction of Anxiety and Post-Traumatic Stress in General and Clinical Populations