Balanced scorecard and controllability at the level of middle managers: The case of unintended breaches

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Purpose - This paper aims to analyse how the inherent design of the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) violates the controllability principle. The management control literature provides convincing examples of actors who breach controllability without intention. This discussion was extended by the example of the BSC. This paper focusses on the breaches that occur when actors lack the awareness or the skills to re-enforce controllability. Design/methodology/approach - Taking a pragmatic-constructivist position, analytical and empirical evidence was included on controllability to analyse the normative literature on the BSC. Findings - It was found that the BSC causes several unintended breaches of the controllability principle at the level of middle managers, both ex ante (control rationale) and ex post (fairness rationale). These breaches are not only situational or induced by how managers in the field design a BSC. They appear to be inherent in the BSC due to the way Kaplan and Norton have conceptualised it. Practical implications - Practitioners are alerted that the intuitive appeal of popular management fashions such as the BSC covers their conceptual flaws. It was also proposed that failed implementations and dysfunctional applications can be due to the inherent characteristics of the concepts themselves. Originality/value - This paper contributes by uncovering the unintended violations of the controllability principle by the inherent characteristics. The authors suggest using our conceptual contribution to conduct empirical research on the issues of controllability and management control systems in general. Thereby, the theory-based discussion on the BSC is advanced (Nørreklit, 2000, 2003; Nørreklit et al., 2012a).

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Accounting and Organizational Change
Volume10
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)516-539
Number of pages24
ISSN1832-5912
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 28.10.2014
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Accountability and responsibility, Balanced scorecards, Performance measurement, Pragmatic constructivism, Qualitative research methodology, Value drivers
  • Management studies

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. From GUI to No-UI
  2. Export diversification and income differences reconsidered
  3. Knowledge on global environmental change within social praxis: what do we know?
  4. Using Reading Strategy Training to Foster Students´ Mathematical Modelling Competencies
  5. From Allegiant to Assertive Citizens
  6. Sol-gel technology for greener and more sustainable antimicrobial textiles that use silica matrices with C, and Ag and ZnO as biocides
  7. Insights into an Action-Oriented Training Program to Promote Sustainable Entrepreneurship
  8. The effectiveness of nudging
  9. Work in Progres Work on Progress
  10. Minimum return guarantees, investment caps, and investment flexibility
  11. Open Access und Open Educational Resources
  12. Linking socio-technical transition studies and organisational change management
  13. Fettflecken untersuchen mit Graphical Analysis
  14. Does Board Composition Influence CSR Reporting?
  15. Linking concepts of change and ecosystem services research: A systematic review
  16. Integrating regional perceptions into climate change adaptation
  17. Where Tasks, Technology, and Textbooks Meet: An Exploratory Analysis of English Language Teachers’ Perceived Affordances of an Intelligent Language Tutoring System
  18. Knowledge acquisition and development in sustainability-oriented small and medium-sized enterprises
  19. An Integrative Framework of Environmental Management Accounting
  20. Burdens, Stresses, Resources and Needs of School Management and Teaching staff during the Corona Pandemic. Results of a qualitative Interview Study at primary and secondary Schools in Hesse
  21. Towards a Relational Materialism
  22. Group membership does not modulate automatic imitation
  23. What workers want: job satisfaction in the U.S.
  24. An Analysis of Methane Mitigation as a Response to Climate Change
  25. On-Board-Diagnose und On-Board-Measurement
  26. A Control-Value Theory Approach
  27. Development perspectives for the application of autonomous, unmanned aerial systems (UASs) in wildlife conservation
  28. How price path characteristics shape investment behavior

Press / Media

  1. Asset Backed Securities