Balanced scorecard and controllability at the level of middle managers: The case of unintended breaches

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Purpose - This paper aims to analyse how the inherent design of the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) violates the controllability principle. The management control literature provides convincing examples of actors who breach controllability without intention. This discussion was extended by the example of the BSC. This paper focusses on the breaches that occur when actors lack the awareness or the skills to re-enforce controllability. Design/methodology/approach - Taking a pragmatic-constructivist position, analytical and empirical evidence was included on controllability to analyse the normative literature on the BSC. Findings - It was found that the BSC causes several unintended breaches of the controllability principle at the level of middle managers, both ex ante (control rationale) and ex post (fairness rationale). These breaches are not only situational or induced by how managers in the field design a BSC. They appear to be inherent in the BSC due to the way Kaplan and Norton have conceptualised it. Practical implications - Practitioners are alerted that the intuitive appeal of popular management fashions such as the BSC covers their conceptual flaws. It was also proposed that failed implementations and dysfunctional applications can be due to the inherent characteristics of the concepts themselves. Originality/value - This paper contributes by uncovering the unintended violations of the controllability principle by the inherent characteristics. The authors suggest using our conceptual contribution to conduct empirical research on the issues of controllability and management control systems in general. Thereby, the theory-based discussion on the BSC is advanced (Nørreklit, 2000, 2003; Nørreklit et al., 2012a).

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Accounting and Organizational Change
Volume10
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)516-539
Number of pages24
ISSN1832-5912
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 28.10.2014
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Accountability and responsibility, Balanced scorecards, Performance measurement, Pragmatic constructivism, Qualitative research methodology, Value drivers
  • Management studies

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The 1986 Principles Relating to Remote Sensing of the Earth from Outer Space (RS Princi­ples)
  2. Expert*inneninterview
  3. Import and export of ideas
  4. Design It!
  5. Effect of cascading of higher-lying states on a delayed 1 s-2 p transition after beam-foil excitation of 56 MeV hydrogen-like oxygen and fluorine
  6. Special Issue: Habitual Action, Automaticity, and Control
  7. Processes for green and sustainable software engineering
  8. Three steps to a solar system
  9. Environmental performance, carbon performance and earnings management
  10. Trade Dynamics, Trade Costs and Market Size: First Evidence from the Exporter and Importer Dynamics Database for Germany
  11. Strangely Familiar
  12. Landscape moderation of biodiversity patterns and processes - eight hypotheses
  13. Toward a Kaleidoscopic Understanding of Anonymity
  14. Influence of kinetic effects on the spectrum of a parallel electrode probe
  15. Portal als Experimentalsystem
  16. Learning pragmatic routines during study abroad
  17. A review of FEM code accuracy for reliable extrusion process analysis
  18. Salivary cues
  19. Enforcement
  20. Hoffnung Alter
  21. Aufgeschoben, nicht aufgehoben
  22. Introduction to The Psychology of Entrepreneurship
  23. Transforming knowledge systems for life on Earth
  24. The end of welfare as we know it?
  25. Leverage points for sustainability transformation
  26. The Ornament of Mass Customization
  27. Exports and Productivity Growth
  28. Useful synthetic reagents derived from 1-triisopropylsilylpropyne and 1,3bis-[triisopropylsilyl]propyne, direct, stereoselective synthesis of either Z or E enynes
  29. Determinants of international trade, production, and licensing - Results from econometric studies using firm level data from manufacturing industries in Lower Saxony, Germany
  30. Preliminary data on help‐seeking intentions and behaviors of individuals completing a widely available online screen for eating disorders in the United States
  31. Atmospheric mercury over sea ice during the OASIS-2009 campaign
  32. Das Anfertigen von Notizen als Lernstrategie beim mathematischen Modellieren
  33. European External Action Service
  34. Long-term trends in tree-ring width and isotope signatures (δ13C, δ15N) of Fagus sylvatica L. on soils with contrasting water supply
  35. Identifying governance gaps among interlinked sustainability challenges
  36. Kindergarten und Grundschule zwischen Differenzierung und Integration
  37. Mainstreaming biodiversity
  38. Correction to
  39. T&T Clark Handbook of Christian Eschatology
  40. Benign by design
  41. Digital health literacy and subjective wellbeing in the context of COVID-19
  42. So macht man Karriere
  43. Il Silver Workers Institute
  44. Metamorphic matrix breccia 79215