The Struggle for EU Legitimacy: Public Contestation, 1950-2005, by Claudia Schrag Sternberg

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenRezensionenForschung

Authors

The book explores ‘what legitimacy (and its lack) mean in the case of the EU’ (p. 1). In contrast to commonly used quantitative opinion surveys, with little insight into what legitimacy means to the respondents, the author opted for a qualitative cross-textual analysis. Claudia Schrag Sternberg analyses long-term patterns and critical shifts in the discourses within, mainly, the European Commission, Council, Parliament and Court of Justice through official documents, speeches and press conferences. In addition, she analyses short-term case studies in the national public sphere – namely France and Germany – based on newspapers and intellectual essays.

Schrag Sternberg's work highlights the shift from an output-oriented discourse on legitimacy in the EU to an input-oriented discourse. Integration cannot be seen as a Pareto sum game where everybody wins, as the early legitimacy strategies (harmony, consensus and the convergence of interests in a European common good, pursued on the basis of expert rationality) suggested, but one where input-related issues (such as identity and democracy) also become important. Schrag Sternberg has analysed the mainly elite-dominated discourse of the 1950s up until the 1970s, the first changes in the 1980s, and finally the French and German debates before and after Maastricht. Conclusions in each chapter make the work easily accessible.

The author describes her research design as being exploratory rather than explanatory, where ‘the history of discursive contests over EU legitimacy is not investigated as a dependent or an independent variable’ (p. 8), and she makes explicit that she does not aim to generate testable hypotheses for future research. It remains unclear where Schrag Sternberg defines the added value of her work, if her work is neither identifying causalities nor generating hypotheses. The author points out that she focuses on the terminology, the vocabulary and the semantics used in constructions of a legitimate order of society. The author claims not only to include ‘top-down legitimation discourses, but also their resonance, reception, and contestation in the discourse or their addressees: the member-state publics’ (p. 10). But limiting her analyses to the level of official documents and newspapers, the results are restricted to the elite's understanding of what legitimacy means in the EU. It would be interesting to explore not only the elite's perception, but also people's understanding of legitimacy in the EU. While Schrag Sternberg comments that the research design should go beyond survey research, she does not offer an alternative approach to overcome these limitations.

Keeping these limits in mind, The Struggle for EU Legitimacy is an excellent starting point for everyone interested in the EU's legitimacy, what legitimacy means for the people and how legitimate the EU is.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftPolitical Studies Review Journal
Jahrgang13
Ausgabenummer3
Seiten (von - bis)453-454
Anzahl der Seiten2
ISSN1478-9299
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 08.2015

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Increasing the accuracy and efficiency of wildlife census with unmanned aerial vehicles
  2. Grundsätzliches, Konträres und Verspieltes - Gedanken zur Netzwerkarbeit von BBS futur 2.0
  3. Partizipation in der Offenen Kinder- und Jugendarbeit zwischen Anspruch und Wirklichkeit
  4. Wie gut berücksichtigen Umwelterklärungen und -berichte zentrale umweltpolitische Themen?
  5. Training sessions fostering transdisciplinary collaboration for sustainable development
  6. Entstehung und Dynamiken von Konflikten bei Jugendlichen in unterschiedlichen Kontexten
  7. Effects Of Different Order Processing Strategies On Operating Curves Of Logistic Models
  8. Überlegungen zur personalen Dimension bei der Erziehung am anderen Ort - das Ortshandeln
  9. Universities as learning organizations for sustainability? The task of climate protection
  10. § 62a Nationales Aktionsprogramm zum Schutz von Gewässern vor Nitrateinträgen aus Anlagen
  11. Is innovative firm behavior correlated with age and gender composition of the workforce ?
  12. Die Berichterstattung über die Mordserie des NSU im Lichte journalistischer Selbstkritik
  13. Die Orientierungskraft des Lebenslangen Lernens bei Weiterbildnern und Grundschullehrern.
  14. Prolog und relationale Datenbanken als Grundlagen zur Implementierung einer NF2-Datenbank
  15. Diversity and specialization of host parasitoid interactions in an urban rural interface
  16. “Dann verfügen wir über Instrumente…”: Äußerungsbefugnisse von Mitgliedern der EU-Kommission
  17. Dispersal of vascular plants by game in northern Germany. Part II: Red deer (Cervus elaphus)
  18. Genese literaler Konzepte - Studien zur didaktischen Theorie schriftsprachlicher Prozesse
  19. Analysis of priority rule-based scheduling in dual-resource-constrained shop-floor scenarios
  20. Abiotic and biotic degradation of five aromatic organosilicon compounds in aqueous media
  21. Ausgewählte Suchtpräventionsprojekte für Kinder und Jugendliche in Deutschland seit 1985
  22. Going Green with Gamified Learning: Advancing Sustainability through Interactive Learning
  23. Release of monomers from four different composite materials after halogen and LED curing
  24. Scholarly Question Answering Using Large Language Models in the NFDI4DataScience Gateway
  25. Rural electrification efforts based on off-grid photovoltaic systems in the Andean Region
  26. The Effects of Altruism and Social Background in an Online-Based, Pay-What-You-Want Situation
  27. Efficiency and usability of industrial laser assistance systems in composite preforming
  28. Comparison of Friction Extrusion Processing from Bulk and Chips of Aluminum-Copper Alloys
  29. Nachhaltige Berufsbildungsforschung in Theorie und Praxis - Modellversuche unter der Lupe