Which Relationality? Whose Personhood? The Christian Understanding of the Person, 'After-Birth-Abortion' and Embryonic Stem Cell Research

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

This article argues that the concept of personhood is intrinsically relational and that a relational understanding of created personhood can be derived from divine personhood and understood systematically in relation to itself, the pre-personal world and to other persons. Insofar as this set of three relationships is understood to be dislocated by sinful self-enclosedness in the penultimate reality and standing in contradiction to the ultimate reality retrospectively constituting it, the article suggests that all created personhood at present could be called ‘potential’ personhood. The article then examines the concept of personhood maintained by Alberto Giubilini and Francesca Minerva in their recent paper on ‘after-birth abortion’ in comparison to Johannes Fischer’s discussion of embryonic stem cell research and personhood. In response to both, the article concludes that it is not possible at present for humans to make a concrete external identification of the divine relation that internally constitutes created personhood. As a result, the article proposes adopting a veil of ignorance with reference to the status of embryonic personhood, as it would be worse to deny the status of personhood to an actual person than to attribute personhood to a non-person.
Translated title of the contributionWelche Relationalität? Wessen Personsein?: Das christliche Personverständnis, "nachgeburtliche Abtreibung" und Stamzellenforschung
Original languageEnglish
JournalStudies in Christian ethics
Volume26
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)473–486
Number of pages13
ISSN0953-9468
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 11.2013

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Misconceptions of Measurement Equivalence
  2. Strategies in Sustainable Supply Chain Management
  3. From Ideation to Realization
  4. Enterprise Integration
  5. Application of Machine Learning on Transport Spot Rate Prediction In the Recycling Industry
  6. Ablauforganisation in Arztpraxen
  7. Electromagnetic Energy Harvester for Battery-Free IoT Solutions
  8. Stereotyp
  9. Restricted nonlinear approximation
  10. Die Erinnerung im Gepäck
  11. Strategic Spatial Planning
  12. Acquiring 'different strokes'.
  13. Long-term results of a web-based guided self-help intervention for employees with depressive symptoms
  14. Forest-specific diversity of vascular plants, bryophytes, and lichens
  15. Non-native tree species (Pseudotsuga menziesii) strongly decreases predator biomass and abundance in mixed-species plantations of a tree diversity experiment
  16. Pia und die Dinge
  17. Begleitung von Lehrenden bei der Implementierung von Forschendem Lernen
  18. Soil and tree species traits both shape soil microbial communities during early growth of Chinese subtropical forests
  19. Who are the workers who never joined a union?
  20. Kinetic Spectra of the Planar Multipole Resonance Probe
  21. 'Crawling Jurisdiction'
  22. Scale-dependent species–area and species–isolation relationships
  23. Factors affecting fruit set in Aizoaceae species of the Succulent Karoo
  24. Editors’ Conversation with German Art Historians Oona Lochner and Isabel Mehl: Writing Like a Feminist—In Dialogue with Carla Lonzi
  25. Quality factors for the evaluation of sustainable redevelopment of masonry buildings
  26. Highly Flexible Final Production Stages
  27. Steering for sustainable development
  28. Petrus