The Origins of Parliamentary Agenda Control: A Comparative Process Tracing Analysis

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

This paper aims to explain the origins of the rules of parliamentary agenda control, which can be regarded as the single most important institutional determinant of parliamentary power. Based on the premises of distributive bargaining, the paper develops a causal mechanism for the delegation of agenda control to the government majority. Given that only anti-system or anti-establishment parties strictly prefer to participate in plenary proceedings, these ‘anti’-parties potentially obstruct legislation. Such legislative obstruction by ‘anti’-parties causes establishment parties to commit themselves to procedural reform and thus triggers attempts to centralise agenda control. The delegation of parliamentary agenda powers is successful if opposition to procedural reform is confined to anti-system parties. The causal leverage of this mechanism is assessed in a process-tracing of three reform attempts in two most different cases: the initially ineffective, but then successful introduction of a closure procedure in the United Kingdom and the failed attempt to facilitate the closure in Germany.

Original languageEnglish
JournalWest European Politics
Volume38
Issue number5
Pages (from-to)1062-1085
Number of pages24
ISSN0140-2382
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.09.2015
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • agenda control, causal mechanism, distributive bargaining, Germany, process-tracing, United Kingdom
  • Politics

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Philipp René Schmidt

Publications

  1. Delineating the interplay between subjective safety and country image in influencing international tourists’ extrinsic travel motives
  2. Selbst is(s)t der Mann - Essen kochen in der Jugendarbeit
  3. Forschendes Lernen im Langzeitpraktikum
  4. Kooperationsverhalten niedergelassener Ärzte in Norddeutschland
  5. Regulierung von Stimmrechtsberatern nach ARUG II
  6. Selbstentdeckendes und problemorientiertes Lernen in Studiengängen Sozialer Arbeit
  7. Klangwesen
  8. Innovative IT-gestützte Ansätze zur Bewertung der Gesprächsqualität in Telefonverkaufsgesprächen
  9. Entropy
  10. Äußere Souveränität
  11. Die Privatisierung des Politischen bei Carl Schmitt
  12. Strategien für den Regierungswechsel
  13. Ambulantisierung der Jugendhilfe - Entwicklungsmöglichkeit oder Sackgasse
  14. Effects of orientations to happiness on vocational identity achievement.
  15. Ein unmöglicher Blick von außen
  16. Popular music in ex-Yugoslavia between global participation and provincial seclusion
  17. Degraded creep resistance induced by static precipitation strengthening in high-pressure die casting Mg-Al-Sm alloy
  18. Impact of land transformation, management and governance on subjective wellbeing across social–ecological systems
  19. Evaluation eines Emotionsregulationstrainings als zusätzliche Behandlungskomponente in KVT-basierter Depressionstherapie
  20. Entwicklung und (Kosten-)Effektivitätsanalyse eines internetbasierten Programms für Personen mit Diabetes mellitus und depressiven Symptomen
  21. Die Leuphana Universität Lüneburg und die transkulturelle Wissenschaft