The importance of understanding the multiple dimensions of power in stakeholder participation for effective biodiversity conservation

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • Lou Lécuyer
  • Estelle V. Balian
  • J. R.A. Butler
  • Cécile Barnaud
  • Simon Calla
  • Bruno Locatelli
  • Jens Newig
  • Jethro Pettit
  • Diana Pound
  • Fabien F. Quétier
  • Valéria Salvatori
  • Yorck Von Korff
  • Juliette Claire Young

Biodiversity conservation are increasingly focused on involving stakeholder engagement, making power a key concept in understanding its success and failure. Power is often conceptualized as unidimensional and coercive, but a multidimensional view better reflects structural power, as well as its productive and enabling potential. This paper investigates how different dimensions of power in participatory processes affect biodiversity conservation objectives. Six case studies from Europe and Asia-Pacific were analysed using an adapted framework that explores the interlinkages between ‘power over’ and ‘transformative power’, looking at the scale and space in which power occurs, and analysing in which arenas of power and under which form of expression it appears. The framework distinguishes between the different ways to exert influence (‘power to’, ‘power with’, ‘power within’, ‘power for’), as well as the dynamics of domination and resistance observed in decision-making (visible power), hidden biases and exclusionary experiences (hidden power), and actions that either reinforce or resist social norms and beliefs (invisible and systematic power). Focusing on biodiversity, the different arenas of power allow us to go deeper than the surface issues and conflicting interests of diverse participants, regarding for example wildlife, to question underlying power dynamics. Different expressions of power, more specifically the ‘power for’ dimension, allow an understanding of how participants integrate nature and biodiversity in their aspirations. The different levels of power also highlight the need to focus not only on the local level but to analyse how participatory processes are embedded in national, or even international governance in a globalized world. Finally, they shed light on two challenges in participatory processes regarding biodiversity: the representation of non-human interests (designated here as ‘beyond-human’ voices), and the integration of multiple forms of knowledge systems. Synthesis and applications: Integrating power into biodiversity issues involves deconstructing normalized discourses that focus solely on certain more powerful human agents, their interests and scientific knowledge, and creating new narratives, knowledge and embodied practice of learning and action to encompass a wider diversity of voices and views. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.

Original languageEnglish
JournalPeople and Nature
Volume6
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)1407-1420
Number of pages14
ISSN2575-8314
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Author(s). People and Nature published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of British Ecological Society.

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Digital Transformation and Institutional Work: A Paradox View
  2. Corruption and Social Values
  3. Explicit Apologies in Fictional Telecinematic Discourse
  4. Introduction to the basics of life cycle sustainability assessment focusing on the UNEP/SETAC Life Cycle Initiative LCSA framework
  5. No-Code Platforms in Startups: Explaining Decisions for Adoption and Abandonment
  6. Finding the Best Match — a Case Study on the (Text‑) Feature and Model Choice in Digital Mental Health Interventions
  7. The Influence of Adjustment Costs on Labour Adjustment: An Analysis Using Panel Data for Manufacturing Establishments in Lower Saxony
  8. Top-down biological motion perception does not differ between adults scoring high versus low on autism traits
  9. Material system analysis
  10. Fast response of groundwater to heavy rainfall
  11. A Person-Centered Approach for Analyzing Multidimensional Integration in Collaboration Between Educational Researchers and Practitioners
  12. Effectiveness of a Web-Based Intervention in Reducing Depression and Sickness Absence
  13. Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors for Track Applications
  14. Fatigue crack propagation in AA5083 structures additively manufactured via multi-layer friction surfacing
  15. Unpacking the nonlinear effect of self-efficacy in entrepreneurship
  16. Kultur als Materialität oder Material – Diskurstheorie oder Diskursanalyse?
  17. Schulleistung in Diskussion
  18. Recognizing Guarantees and Assurances of Non-Repetition
  19. Mapping perceptions of energy transition pathways
  20. Die Bedeutung der Zeit
  21. Transcending the Locality of Grassroots Initiatives
  22. University-linked programmes for sustainable entrepreneurship and regional development