The expression of non-alignment in British and German political interviews: Preferred and dispreferred variants

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

Political interviews are defined as question- and answer sequences in which interviewers and interviewees negotiate validity claims. Looked upon from an interpersonal angle, the interviewer sets up a position and requests the interviewee to ratify their claim by expressing alignment or non-alignment. This contribution examines the expression of non-alignment in a corpus of 12 interviews between journalists and the losers of the general elections in Britain (1997) and Germany (1998). The data share identical external parameters, very similar contextual features and almost identical argumentation strategies. In spite of that, the expression of non-alignment differs significantly. This is primarily due to language-specific preferences for the realization of turn-initial positions and their functions as interpersonal, topical and textual themes. In the British data, multiple themes are more frequent for the expression of non-alignment and thus assigned the status of a preferred variant; their sequential organization adheres to the sequence [[textual theme] [interpersonal theme] [topical theme]], which indicates that a negotiation of meaning is intended. Single topical themes are less frequent and therefore assigned the status of a dispreferred variant indicating that a negotiation of meaning is not intended. In the German data, the sequential organization of multiple themes does not display that kind of preference pattern and multiple themes do not necessarily indicate that a negotiation of meaning is intended. Regarding possible perlocutionary effects, the expression of non-alignment in British English is more process-oriented and thus more dynamic, while its German counterpart is more product-oriented and thus more abrupt.

Original languageEnglish
JournalFunctions of Language
Volume15
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)35-63
Number of pages29
ISSN0929-998X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2008

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Öko-Controlling
  2. Does outcome expectancy predict outcomes in online depression prevention? Secondary analysis of randomised-controlled trials
  3. Autonomy of migration?
  4. Am Jenseits
  5. Bioremediation of Chlorinated Pesticides in Field-Contaminated Soils and Suitability of Tenax Solid-Phase Extraction as a Predictor of Its Effectiveness
  6. Why do students choose English as a medium of instruction?
  7. Der Hunger nach Liebe
  8. Indigenous and local knowledge in environmental management for human-nature connectedness
  9. Ballons
  10. Environmental factors and seasonal variation in density of mussel larvae (Mytilus edulis) in Danish waters
  11. Biodiversity on old permanent versus restored grassland is driven by small-scale land-use intensity and habitat connectivity
  12. Imagining is Not Observing
  13. Consolidation period in new ventures
  14. Evolution, Empowerment and Emancipation
  15. To Own or to Use
  16. Befremden in der Kunstvermittlung
  17. Developing sustainable business experimentation capability – A case study
  18. Totgesagte leben länger
  19. Introduction
  20. Entrepreneurship in conventions, place-making, and spaces of creativity
  21. Regulating High Frequency Trading
  22. Energizing marginal soils
  23. Projektorientiertes Lernen in einem anwendungsbezogenen Studienprojekt
  24. Contrastivity and comparability: Pragmatic variation across pluricentric varieties
  25. Environmental Accounting and Reporting
  26. Traditional and modern ageism as predictors of workplace discrimination
  27. On anisotropic tensile mechanical behavior of Al-Cu-Li AA2198 alloy under different ageing conditions
  28. Learning settings to face climate change
  29. Why Art Criticism? A Reader
  30. Beech forests and climate change