The Deportation Gap as a Statistical Chimera: How Nonknowledge Informs Migration Policies

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Since the 2015 ‘migration crisis’, various measures have been introduced in Europe to enforce deportations. They include detention in prison-like facilities, unannounced executions of deportations at night-time and the scraping of legal safeguards like medical reasons prohibiting deportations. These evidently violent measures are justified with alarmist reports which suggest, supported by statistical knowledge, an ever-widening ‘deportation gap’. The term refers to the divergence between the number of migrants issued with a return order and the much smaller number of deportations. Illustrated through the case of Germany, this article combines insights from ignorance studies with a sociology of translation to show that the claim of a widening deportation gap is a statistical chimera that is based on various kinds and sources of nonknowledge. Contrary to actor-based approaches in ignorance studies, it is argued that this nonknowledge is not reducible to the production of ‘strategic ignorance’ (McGoey 2019) by policy actors seeking to advance their agenda. Rather, the production and circulation of nonknowledge appears to be dispersed and messy as it is facilitated by complex and fragile sociotechnical networks. In this way, a sociology of translation allows scholars to avoid the impression of entertaining a conspirational logic in the study of strategic ignorance and other forms of nonknowledge.

Original languageEnglish
JournalGeopolitics
Number of pages23
ISSN1465-0045
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 21.06.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Author(s). Published with license by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.

    Research areas

  • Politics - actor-network theory, critical data studies, deportation, ignorance studies, migration governance, migration statistics
  • Sociology

Documents

  • Download (Post-Print)

    354 KB, PDF document

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Emerging Contaminants versus Micro-pollutants
  2. Der Kindergarten als Ort elementarer Bildung
  3. The Domestication of Luxury in Social Theory
  4. Hermann Bahr - Studien zur Kritik der Moderne
  5. Pädagogische Liebe und emphatische Pädagogik
  6. Klimapolitik mit China und den USA nach 2012
  7. La leva del prezzo nel settore della cultura
  8. Museums, Transculturality, and the Nation-State
  9. Engaging citizens in sustainability research
  10. Writing Life, Writing Back, and Writing Through
  11. Bridging corporate and academic contributions
  12. Spanning Sustainability Management Boundaries
  13. Ökologische Nachhaltigkeit und Arbeitsmärkte
  14. Drawing a Picture of Citizen Entrepreneurship
  15. Narrating Sustainability through Storytelling
  16. Der ‚Sympathisanten’-Diskurs im Deutschen Herbst
  17. Challenges for postdocs in Germany and beyond:
  18. Internet gaming disorder in early adolescence
  19. Pollination of two oil-producing plant species
  20. Gase auf submikroskopischer Ebene untersuchen
  21. Biodiversity and Sustainability Communication
  22. Religion aus kultursoziologischer Perspektive
  23. Motive von Mädchen und Frauen in Sportspielen
  24. Property Meeting the Challenge of the Commons
  25. Zum mythischen Gehalt pädagogischer Ratgebung
  26. Warum haben Sie keinen Fernseher, Herr Luhmann?
  27. Studying Organizational Creativity as Process
  28. Possibilities of Place in Continental Thought
  29. Analyse menschlicher Fehlerursachen im OP-Saal
  30. Das Niedersächsische Umweltinformationsgesetz
  31. Zum Präventionsbegriff und dessen Dimensionen
  32. Misestimations as a barrier to climate action