The classification systems of the EQ-5D, the HUI II and the SF-6D: What do they have in common?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearch

Authors

Purpose: EQ-5D, HUI II and SF-6D often produce very different valuations for the same health state. This paper aims at clarifying to what extent this might be caused by differences between the multi-attribute classification systems belonging to these instruments. Methods: Subjects were 264 patients of rehabilitation clinics in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania (44.3% female; mean age 49.1) who completed the EQ-5D, the HUI II and the SF-36 (the basis of the SF-6D). After scaling with principal component analyses for categorical data, each attribute of each classification system was regressed on the classification systems of the other two instruments, and all attributes together were subjected to ordinary principal component analysis with varimax rotation. Results: Adjusted multiple R 2 for regression analyses ranged from 0.01 to 0.57. The HUI II attribute 'sensation' and the SF-6D attribute 'role limitation' are virtually unrelated to the remainder. All other attributes of all three instruments can be predicted by each other. EQ-5D and HUI II focus distinctly more on physical functioning than SF-6D. Conclusion: Although all three classification systems have a lot in common, they differ so much that EQ-5D, HUI II and SF-6D would produce different valuations even if these valuations were determined according to the same principle.

Original languageEnglish
JournalQuality of Life Research
Volume18
Issue number9
Pages (from-to)1249-1261
Number of pages13
ISSN0962-9343
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.11.2009
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Health sciences
  • Classification, Health, Measurement, Quality of life

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Paul Silas Peterson

Publications

  1. A review of ecosystem service benefits from wild bees across social contexts
  2. Modern Micropolitics of Antipopulism
  3. The hidden power of language
  4. Variation revisited: A corpus analysis of offers in Irish English and British English
  5. Community-based Entrepreneurship and Rural Development
  6. On the microstructure of the German export boom: Evidence from establishment panel data, 1995-2002
  7. Mathematik 1
  8. Audit quality and materiality disclosure quality in integrated reporting
  9. Communication management of start-ups: an empirical analysis of entrepreneurs’ communication and networking success on Facebook
  10. Früherkennung als Problem der Unternehmensführung in virtuellen Organisationen
  11. Specific SBR population behaviour as revealed by comparative dynamic simulation analysis of three full-scale municipal SBR wastewater treatment plants
  12. Spatial variation in human disturbances and their effects on forest structure and biodiversity across an Afromontane forest
  13. Gathering Voices, Feeling Relations
  14. The attenuating effect of mortality salience on dishonest behavior
  15. Activity-based start-up simulations in entrepreneurship education at the German universities
  16. Tree Species Traits but Not Diversity Mitigate Stem Breakage in a Subtropical Forest following a Rare and Extreme Ice Storm
  17. Identity affirmation and social movement support
  18. Top-down social modulation of perception-action coupling
  19. Lernkarten Bibelkunde
  20. Is Export Diversification good for Productivity? First Evidence for Manufacturing Enterprises in Germany
  21. Spatial characterization of coastal marine social-ecological systems
  22. Constructing The European Space Policy
  23. Implications of financial transaction costs on the real economy
  24. Reducing aquatic micropollutants – Increasing the focus on input prevention and integrated emission management
  25. “Normality” Revisited: Fieldwork and Family
  26. Anchoring and Sleep Inertia
  27. Continental-scale ecology versus landscape-scale case studies
  28. What do we know about Antibiotics in the Environment?
  29. Größen bauen auf Längen
  30. Time sensitivity
  31. The impact of digitisation and big data analysis on the sustainable development of tourism and its environmental impact
  32. Consumer Preferences and Their Willingness to Pay for Local Products (by Means of Consumer Ethnocentrism)
  33. Metaphern und ihre Bedeutung für das mathematische Tätigsein
  34. Sustainability process assessment on transformative potentials
  35. Erfolgreich enttäuschend
  36. The global perspective of education for sustainable development
  37. Lebens-Formen
  38. Plasma arcing during contact separation of HVDC relays
  39. The Post-entry Performance of Cohorts of Export Starters in German Manufacturing Industries
  40. Special Section: Pragmatic Development and Stay Abroad
  41. The Maternal in Drag
  42. Worldwide distribution of Persistent Organic Pollutants in air, including results of air monitoring by passive air sampling in five continents
  43. Berufsorientierte Schreibkompetenz mithilfe von SRSD fördern
  44. Frömmigkeit der Theologie, zur Logik der offenen Theodizeefrage