Systematic learning in water governance: insights from five local adaptive management projects for water quality innovation

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Adaptive management has been proliferating since the 1970s as a policy approach for dealing with uncertainty in environmental governance through learning. Learning takes place through a cyclical approach of experimentation and (possible) adjustment. However, few empirical studies exist that cover full iterations of adaptive management cycles. We report on five adaptive management projects on water quality enhancement, of which four led to innovations in the small-scale management of waterways in northern Germany. We trace processes as well as outcomes, to identify factors affecting learning, environmental improvement, and the successful delivery of a project throughout a management cycle.
Our findings point to a key difference between two kinds of uncertainty in the studied processes: ecological uncertainty (whether and how interventions will be effective in improving water quality) and what we term “social uncertainty” (how stakeholders will respond to interventions). We find that those managers performed better who addressed both kinds of uncertainty. Factors for dealing with social uncertainties were usually rather different than the ones linked to knowledge gain for the results in the rivers, and their acknowledgment was decisive for successful project delivery. On a conceptual level, our findings suggest that the model of a dual feedback cycle, including both types of uncertainties, allows for more clear-cut conceptual differentiation and empirical outcome measurement of adaptive management processes.
Original languageEnglish
Article number22
JournalEcology and Society
Volume26
Issue number1
Number of pages13
ISSN1708-3087
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.2021

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 by the author(s). Published here under license by the Resilience Alliance.

    Research areas

  • Environmental Governance - comparative research, environmental governance, implementation, public participation, Water Framework Directive

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Health and the intention to retire: exploring the moderating effects of human resources practices
  2. Integrating a piezoelectric actuator with mechanical and hydraulic devices to control camless engines
  3. Tree species identity, canopy structure and prey availability differentially affect canopy spider diversity and trophic composition
  4. Modeling of microstructural pattern formation in crystal plasticity
  5. Special Issue: A variational pragmatic approach to regional variation in language: Celebrating the work of Klaus P. Schneider
  6. Managing information in the case of opinion spamming
  7. Leading Knowledge Exploration and Exploitation in Schools
  8. Random year intercepts in mixed models help to assess uncertainties in insect population trends
  9. A Study on the Impact of Intradomain Finetuning of Deep Language Models for Legal Named Entity Recognition in Portuguese
  10. Categorizing urban tasks
  11. From theory to experience
  12. Managing Multiple Logics: The Role of Performance Measurement Systems in Social Enterprises
  13. Dynamische Mathematik
  14. Performance of the Chemcatcher ® passive sampler when used to monitor 10 polar and semi-polar pesticides in 16 Central European streams, and comparison with two other sampling methods
  15. Functions of Constitutions
  16. Comparison of Panel Cointegration Tests
  17. External State-Building and Why Norms Matter
  18. rSOESGOPE Method Applied to Four-Tank System Modeling
  19. Do Linguistic Features Influence Item Difficulty in Physics Assessments?
  20. History of Embryology: Visualizations Through Series and Animation
  21. Responsibility and environment
  22. Using the learner-generated drawing strategy
  23. Development and characterisation of a new interface for coupling capillary LC with collision-cell ICPMS and its application for phosphorylation profiling of tryptic protein digests
  24. Clashing Values
  25. Stabilisierung durch Implementieren, Sichern und Evaluieren
  26. Choice and quantity demand for improved and unimproved public water sources in rural areas
  27. Negotiation complexity
  28. Learning-related emotions in multimedia learning