Stressing the Relevance of Differentiating between Systematic and Random Measurement Errors in Ultrasound Muscle Thickness Diagnostics

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Background: The majority of studies that explore changes in musculature following resistance training interventions or examine atrophy due to immobilization or sarcopenia use ultrasound imaging. While most studies assume acceptable to excellent reliability, there seems to be unawareness of the existing absolute measurement errors. As early as 1998, methodological research addressed a collective unawareness of the random measurement error and its practical indications. Referring to available methodological approaches, within this work, we point out the limited value of focusing on relative, correlation-based reliability indices for the interpretability in scientific research but also for clinical application by assessing 1,512 muscle thickness values from more than 400 ultrasound images. To account for intra- and inter-day repeatability, data were collected on two consecutive days within four testing sessions. Commonly-stated reliability values (ICC, CV, SEM and MDC) were calculated, while evidence-based agreement analyses were applied to provide the accompanied systematic and random measurement error. Results: While ICCs in the range of 0.832 to 0.998 are in accordance with the available literature, the mean absolute percentage error ranges from 1.34 to 20.38% and the mean systematic bias from 0.78 to 4.01 mm (all p ≤ 0.013), depending on the measurement time points chosen for data processing. Conclusions: In accordance with prior literature, a more cautious interpretation of relative reliability values should be based on included systematic and random absolute measurement scattering. Lastly, this paper discusses the rationale for including different measurement error statistics when determining the validity of pre-post changes, thus, accounting for the certainty of evidence.

Original languageEnglish
Article number89
JournalSports Medicine - Open
Volume10
Issue number1
Number of pages11
ISSN2199-1170
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024.

    Research areas

  • Expected effect, Mean absolute percentage error, Reliability, Training intervention studies, Ultrasound
  • Physical education and sports

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Application of design of experiments for laser shock peening process optimization
  2. I&EC 18-Small particle size magnesium in one-pot Grignard-Zerewitinoff reactions: Kinetics of and practical application to reductive dechlorination of persistent organic pollutants
  3. Statistical precipitation bias correction of gridded model data using point measurements
  4. Analytic reproducibility in articles receiving open data badges at the journal Psychological Science
  5. Optimal trajectory generation for camless internal combustion engine valve control
  6. Integrating teacher and student workspaces in a technology-enhanced mathematics lecture
  7. rSOESGOPE Method Applied to Four-Tank System Modeling
  8. Increased auditor independence by external rotation and separating audit and non audit duties?
  9. Exploding Images
  10. Effect of internal defects on tensile properties of A356 casting alloys
  11. Article 11 Formal Validity
  12. The relationship between resilience and sustainable development of ecological-economic systems
  13. Enhancing the structural diversity between forest patches — A concept and real-world experiment to study biodiversity, multifunctionality and forest resilience across spatial scales
  14. Joint Proceedings of Scholarly QALD 2023 and SemREC 2023 co-located with 22nd International Semantic Web Conference ISWC 2023
  15. Repatriation, Public Programming, and the DEAI Toolkit
  16. Sustainability and management control. Exploring and theorizing control patterns in large European firms
  17. Magnesium recycling: State-of-the-Art developments, part II
  18. Taming a Wicked Problem
  19. Wavelet characterizations for anisotropic Besov spaces
  20. Robust and Optimal Control Designed for Autonomous Surface Vessel Prototypes
  21. Cognitive load and science text comprehension
  22. Modeling of cooperative tasks in business-IT management - A proposal for a domain-specific extension of BPMN 2.0
  23. Comparison of Panel Cointegration Tests
  24. Germination performance of native and non-native Ulmus pumila populations
  25. Detecting Various Road Damage Types in Global Countries Utilizing Faster R-CNN
  26. Impacts of offshore wind farms on sediment structure and the water column during construction, and changes in bottom topography during the operation phase
  27. Self-guided internet-based and mobile-based stress management for employees
  28. Intra-Individual Value Change in Adulthood
  29. Does ESG performance have an impact on financial performance?
  30. Scaffolding, software and scenarios
  31. Spatial Tests, Familiarity with the Surroundings, and Spatial Activity Experience
  32. Representation of Integration Profiles Using an Ontology
  33. Comparison of an Electrochemical and Luminescence-Based Oxygen Measuring System for Use in the Biodegradability Testing According to Closed Bottle Test (OECD 301D)