Stressing the Relevance of Differentiating between Systematic and Random Measurement Errors in Ultrasound Muscle Thickness Diagnostics

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Background: The majority of studies that explore changes in musculature following resistance training interventions or examine atrophy due to immobilization or sarcopenia use ultrasound imaging. While most studies assume acceptable to excellent reliability, there seems to be unawareness of the existing absolute measurement errors. As early as 1998, methodological research addressed a collective unawareness of the random measurement error and its practical indications. Referring to available methodological approaches, within this work, we point out the limited value of focusing on relative, correlation-based reliability indices for the interpretability in scientific research but also for clinical application by assessing 1,512 muscle thickness values from more than 400 ultrasound images. To account for intra- and inter-day repeatability, data were collected on two consecutive days within four testing sessions. Commonly-stated reliability values (ICC, CV, SEM and MDC) were calculated, while evidence-based agreement analyses were applied to provide the accompanied systematic and random measurement error. Results: While ICCs in the range of 0.832 to 0.998 are in accordance with the available literature, the mean absolute percentage error ranges from 1.34 to 20.38% and the mean systematic bias from 0.78 to 4.01 mm (all p ≤ 0.013), depending on the measurement time points chosen for data processing. Conclusions: In accordance with prior literature, a more cautious interpretation of relative reliability values should be based on included systematic and random absolute measurement scattering. Lastly, this paper discusses the rationale for including different measurement error statistics when determining the validity of pre-post changes, thus, accounting for the certainty of evidence.

Original languageEnglish
Article number89
JournalSports Medicine - Open
Volume10
Issue number1
Number of pages11
ISSN2199-1170
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024.

    Research areas

  • Expected effect, Mean absolute percentage error, Reliability, Training intervention studies, Ultrasound
  • Physical education and sports

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Understanding Context Collapse for Social Media Users
  2. Application of design of experiments for laser shock peening process optimization
  3. Parameterized Synthetic Image Data Set for Fisheye Lens
  4. Modeling Individual Differences in Children’s Information Integration During Pragmatic Word Learning
  5. Photodegradation of micropollutants using V-UV/UV-C processes
  6. Parametric finite element model and mechanical characterisation of electrospun materials for biomedical applications
  7. Data Practices
  8. Creating Value from in-Vehicle Data
  9. Traffic Life: Temporal Dynamics and Regulatory Dimensions in Agent-Based Transport Simulations
  10. Shepherds’ local knowledge and scientific data on the scavenging ecosystem service
  11. Agile Portfolio Management Patterns
  12. Automatic feature selection for anomaly detection
  13. (How) Can didactic research find its way into the classroom? Results from a questionnaire survey on the lesson preparation and continuing professional development of German teachers
  14. A slow-fast trait continuum at the whole community level in relation to land-use intensification
  15. Non-acceptances in context
  16. Temporal Dynamics of Ecosystem Services
  17. Combining sense of place theory with the ecosystem services concept: empirical insights and reflections from a participatory mapping study
  18. Project and Design of a Catamaran Prototype with Aerial Propulsion System
  19. Identification of Parameters and States in PMSMs
  20. The Augmented Theorist - Toward Automated Knowledge Extraction from Conceptual Models
  21. Differences in the sophistication of Value-based Management
  22. In situ synchrotron diffraction of the solidification of Mg4Y3Nd
  23. Machine Learning and Data Mining for Sports Analytics
  24. The use of pseudo-causal narratives in EU policies
  25. Knowledge Spaces of Globalization
  26. Desynchronization of the Public and the Private
  27. Global fern and lycophyte richness explained: How regional and local factors shape plot richness
  28. Recontextualizing Anthropomorphic Metaphors in Organization Studies