Monitoring the Monitor? Selective Responses to Human Rights Transgressions

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Sanctions are among the most frequently used foreign policy tools to address human rights violations, but they can be highly politicized. Since the early 2000s, human rights sanctions have been increasingly triggered by standardized rankings of states' performances. While research on economic statecraft suggests that coercive measures based on cross-national assessments may be less influenced by strategic considerations, scholarship on rankings highlights how standardized performance indicators can also be political. This paper investigates whether sanctions based on standardized human rights assessments are also influenced by senders' strategic political and economic interests. Empirically, we examine the case of United States human trafficking sanctions that combines universal rankings in the first stage and country-specific sanctions waivers in the second. The analysis leverages novel data on all Trafficking in Persons (TIP) rankings by the US State Department and presidential sanctions waivers from 2003 to 2018. Despite the TIP report's reputation as a reliable indicator, we find that both stages in the process of imposing human trafficking sanctions are driven by strategic attempts to minimize the economic and political costs of sanctions for the US. These findings have broader implications for the reputation and effectiveness of other human rights rankings by the US.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbersqad014
JournalInternational Studies Quarterly
Volume67
Issue number2
Number of pages16
ISSN0020-8833
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2023
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the International Studies Association.

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Performance decline in low-stakes educational assessments
  2. High temperature deformation of magnesium alloy TX32-0.4Al-0.8Si
  3. Cinephilia in transition
  4. Zootechnologien
  5. Tri‐trophic interaction networks along a tree diversity gradient of BEF‐China
  6. Cognitive load theory
  7. Predicting the interfacial heat transfer coefficient of cast Mg-Al alloys using Beck's inverse analysis
  8. Symmetry-aided computation of the detour matrix and the detour index
  9. Ergebnisse einer Sparkassen-Umfrage
  10. Secondary School Students’ Perceptions of Autonomy, Competence, and Relatedness in Digital Learning
  11. Artificial intelligence in sustainable development research
  12. Learning Soccer in Elementary School: Using Teaching Games for Understanding and Digital Media
  13. Piloting Citizen Science Methods to Measure Perceptions of Carbon Footprint and Energy Content of Food
  14. Ein gemeinsamer europäischer Referenzrahmen für Sprachen oder für Englisch?
  15. Reinventing the Politics of Knowledge Production in Migration Studies
  16. Policy schemes, operational strategies and system integration of residential co-generation fuel cells.
  17. Back for more
  18. Influence of Torsion on Precipitation and Hardening Effects during Aging of an Extruded AZ91 Alloy
  19. Hermann Bahr
  20. Ökofeminismus
  21. Temporary exports and characteristics of destination countries
  22. Karten und Pläne
  23. Integrating Ecosystem Services in Nature Conservation for Colombia
  24. Towards space traffic management
  25. Accounting for Eco-Efficiency
  26. Ecosystem services and sustainability: descriptive means, normative goals and societal transformations
  27. Werturteil II
  28. Self-Wiring Question Answering Systems