How do individual farmers’ objectives influence the evaluation of rangeland management strategies under a variable climate?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Summary: Management decisions by farmers are influenced by complex interrelations of ecological, economic and social factors. Of equal importance are the individual farmers' objectives. However, their relevance has been rarely considered in analyses of management decisions in farming systems. This study systematically analyses the role of farmers' objectives in their decision-making under various climatic conditions, with dryland grazing systems as a case study. We develop a generic ecological-economic simulation model to compare the performance of a range of fixed grazing strategies under two objectives: (i) maximizing expected utility under risk aversion and (ii) achieving stochastic viability ('safety first'). We investigate combined effects of several management components in rotational grazing systems and assess the robustness of the results under different climate scenarios. The two objectives considered have structurally different outcomes. The evaluation under the objective to maximize (risk averse) expected utility indicates a trade-off between mean income and income variability under which farmers would choose one individually optimal management strategy depending on their risk preferences. In contrast, a whole set of strategies is viable under the safety-first objective. Thus, it offers a solution space for decision support rather than selecting a single optimal strategy. Under both objectives, economically preferable strategies share common characteristics: short standing time, large paddock number and reasonably high stocking rate improve the efficiency of a farm enterprise in terms of higher mean income, lower variance, coverage of certain minimum income requirements while preserving pasture quality. Synthesis and applications. The outcomes of this study contribute to both management support at the farm scale and policy advice at the regional scale and beyond. An insight of practical relevance for individual farmers is that a strategy type with high-intensity, short-duration grazing management appears to be most robust under changing climate and economic conditions. Nevertheless, considering individual farmers' objectives is essential for determining the individually optimal strategy. Furthermore, for policymakers, we provide an approach to evaluate policy programmes governing farming activities in terms of effectiveness and implications (particularly side effects). The explicit consideration of the diversity of individual objectives is crucial for avoiding counterproductive incentives and improving sustainability of land-use policies.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Applied Ecology
Volume51
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)483-493
Number of pages11
ISSN0021-8901
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 04.2014

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Sustainable entrepreneurship: creating environmental solutions in light of planetary boundaries
  2. Lernprozesse bei Lean Production
  3. Critical evaluation of commonly used methods to determine the concordance between sonography and magnetic resonance imaging: A comparative study
  4. Notting Hill Gate 3 Basic
  5. Unexpected Expansion Behavior of Mg-Al Alloys During Isothermal Ageing
  6. Buchstaben-Salat oder Warum Generationen nicht fertig abgepackt durch die Zeit wandern
  7. Anmerkung zu BVerfG NJW 2005, 2289
  8. Steering for sustainable development
  9. Global Theories of Regionalism
  10. Attitudes towards computers and information technology at three universities in Germany, Belgium, and the U.S.
  11. Design and control of an electromagnetic valve actuator
  12. Modelling and simulation of dynamic microstructure evolution of aluminium alloys during thermomechanically coupled extrusion process
  13. Extension of Biodiesel Aging Mechanism–the Role and Influence of Methyl Oleate and the Contribution of Alcohols Through the Use of Solketal
  14. Can cross-group contact predict advantaged group member’s willingness to engage in costly solidarity-based actions? Yes, if the contact is politicized
  15. Innere Unruhe
  16. European governance and the deliberative challenge
  17. Coupling stakeholder assessments of ecosystem services with biophysical ecosystem properties reveals importance of social contexts
  18. Entrepreneurial actions
  19. Between Usability and Trustworthiness-The Potential of Information Transfer Using Digital Information Platforms for Refugees
  20. “We cannot escape this”
  21. Self-efficacy, self-regulation and mathematics performance of competitive junior rowers vs. regular students
  22. Careless product use in access-based services
  23. Integration of prosumer peer-to-peer trading decisions into energy community modelling
  24. Temporal changes in taxonomic and functional alpha and beta diversity across tree communities in subtropical Atlantic forests
  25. Kunstgewerbe und Nation
  26. Glen Mills Schools
  27. Australian Graziers value sparse trees in their pastures: A viewshed analysis of Photo-elicitation
  28. Die Todesmärsche von Buchenwald
  29. Data-driven analyses of electronic text books
  30. Special Issue: Embracing Contrarian Thinking
  31. The Global Mobility Divide
  32. Triggering root system plasticity in a changing environment with bacterial bioinoculants – Focus on plant P nutrition

Press / Media

  1. Abschied von den Alpen