Ecosystem Services as a Contested Concept: A Synthesis of Critique and Counter-Arguments

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • Matthias Schröter
  • Emma H. van der Zanden
  • Alexander P.E. van Oudenhoven
  • Roy P. Remme
  • Hector M. Serna-Chavez
  • Rudolf S. de Groot
  • Paul Opdam

We describe and reflect on seven recurring critiques of the concept of ecosystem services and respective counter-arguments. First, the concept is criticized for being anthropocentric, whereas others argue that it goes beyond instrumental values. Second, some argue that the concept promotes an exploitative human-nature relationship, whereas others state that it reconnects society to ecosystems, emphasizing humanity's dependence on nature. Third, concerns exist that the concept may conflict with biodiversity conservation objectives, whereas others emphasize complementarity. Fourth, the concept is questioned because of its supposed focus on economic valuation, whereas others argue that ecosystem services science includes many values. Fifth, the concept is criticized for promoting commodification of nature, whereas others point out that most ecosystem services are not connected to market-based instruments. Sixth, vagueness of definitions and classifications are stated to be a weakness, whereas others argue that vagueness enhances transdisciplinary collaboration. Seventh, some criticize the normative nature of the concept, implying that all outcomes of ecosystem processes are desirable. The normative nature is indeed typical for the concept, but should not be problematic when acknowledged. By disentangling and contrasting different arguments we hope to contribute to a more structured debate between opponents and proponents of the ecosystem services concept.

Original languageEnglish
JournalConservation Letters
Volume7
Issue number6
Pages (from-to)514-523
Number of pages10
ISSN1755-263X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.11.2014
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Boundary object, Classification, Economic valuation, environmental ethics, Payments for ecosystem services, Philosophy of science, Transdisciplinary research, Vagueness
  • Ecosystems Research

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The Use of Anti-Windup Techniques in Didactic Level Systems
  2. An Optimization Approach for Crew Rostering in Public Bus Transit
  3. A hybrid actuator modelling and hysteresis effect identification in camless internal combustion engines control
  4. Construal level theory
  5. Method of Artificial Vision in Guide Cane for Visually Impaired People
  6. Insights into adoption of farming practices through multiple lenses
  7. Special issue on Variational Pragmatics
  8. Appreciating ecological complexity
  9. Customer Orientation of Service Employees—Toward a Conceptual Framework of a Key Relationship Marketing Construct
  10. Performance Saga: Interview 05
  11. Mathematik als Fremdsprache?
  12. Mechanics of sheet-bulk indentation
  13. ›A moving picture of thought‹
  14. DSM-IV und DSM-5
  15. Wie partizipativ sind Bottom-up-Transformationen?
  16. Model Predictive Control for Energy Optimization in Generators/Motors as Well as Converters and Inverters for Futuristic Integrated Power Networks
  17. Natality ‒ Philosophical Rudiments concerning a Generative Phenomenology
  18. Exploring the Use of the Pronoun I in German Academic Texts with Machine Learning
  19. The State and Healthcare
  20. Hot deformation behavior and processing map of Mg-3Sn-2Ca-0.4Al-0.4Zn alloy
  21. What do we know about new venture investment time patterns?
  22. Analysis of the forming behaviour of in-situ drawn sandwich sheets
  23. Accounting for capacity and flow of ecosystem services
  24. Ecosystem functions as indicators for heathland responses to nitrogen fertilisation
  25. Open-flow mixing and transfer operators
  26. Conveying the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence in K–12 and Academia: A Systematic Review of Teaching Methods
  27. Pragmatics broadly viewed
  28. 11. Methoden-Muster
  29. Sustainable Statehood: Reflections on Critical (Pre-)Conditions, Requirements and Design Options
  30. Propagating Maximum Capacities for Recommendation
  31. Fehler und Versuch. Parteispenden und ihre Regulierung
  32. Non-acceptances in context
  33. "Das Zeugnis Jesu"
  34. Redemption Restored: The Star in the Context of Modernity
  35. Altruism and egoism of the social planner in a dynamic context
  36. Conditionality of EU funds: an instrument to enforce EU fundamental values?
  37. Timing, fragmentation of work and income inequality