Cross-Fertilizing Qualitative Perspectives on Effects of a Mindfulness-Based Intervention: An Empirical Comparison of Four Methodical Approaches

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Objectives

Qualitative methods come along with specific methodological backgrounds and related empirical strengths and weaknesses. Research is lacking addressing the question of what it precisely means to study mindfulness practices from a particular methodological point of view. The aim of this paper is to shed light on what qualities of mindfulness different qualitative methods can elucidate.
Methods

Based on interviews stemming from participants of a consumer-focused mindfulness training (BiNKA), we undertook a comparison of four different analyses, namely content analysis (CA), grounded theory (GT), interpretative-phenomenological analysis (IPA), and discourse analysis (DA).
Results

Independently applying the four methods on our data material led to the following findings: CA demonstrated that the training had effects on self-awareness, well-being, and the development of ethical qualities and influenced pre-consumptive stages of participants; GT revealed the complex set of conditions determining whether and how the mindfulness training influenced the attendees; IPA highlighted the subjectivity of the mindfulness experience, suggesting that (1) different training elements have varying effects on participants and (2) it is often not the meditation practice, but other course elements that cause the effects experienced by the attendees; DA demonstrated that the course experience was influenced by subjective theories held by the participants. In particular, they showed typical strategies of rationalizing their consumption.
Conclusions

A pluralistic qualitative research assists in identifying blind spots and limitations of a single method, increases the self-reflexivity, and helps to arrive at a more comprehensive understanding of mindfulness practice or other processes of covert lived experience.
Original languageEnglish
JournalMindfulness
Volume10
Issue number11
Pages (from-to)2452–2467
Number of pages16
ISSN1868-8527
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.11.2019

    Research areas

  • Sustainability Science - Mindfulness, Qualitative, Pluralistic qualitative research, Reflexive methodology, Sustainable Consumption

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Environmental fate of S-metolachlor in its pure form and as a part of commercial product - Mercantor Gold®: biodegradation and sorption onto sediment
  2. Assessment of the biodegradability and ecotoxicity of the anticancer drug Imatinib Mesylate after UV and simulated sunlight irradiation treatments
  3. Effekte von Klassenwiederholungen auf die Entwicklung kognitiver und non-kognitiver Lernergebnisse – Befunde aus der PISA 2012 Messwederholungsstudie
  4. “Visual Rhetoric as a three-dimensional practice. Theorizing the interconnections between the visual rhetorical objects and the process of spectatorship”
  5. Summer School, Curating Art and Nature, The Knowledge of the Curator III – Department of History of Art, Architecture, and Landscape, University of Groningen
  6. Berufsbildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung in der Kommunalverwaltung: Akteursanalyse und Kompetenzmodellierung zur Berufsausbildung im öffentlichen Dienst.
  7. Schreibt das Hochschulrahmengesetz die landesrechtliche Umsetzung der Funktionsgruppe „Oberassistenten“ zwingend vor?: Gutachten, verfasst zusammen mit Heide Pfarr
  8. Emotion sells? Eine vergleichende Fallstudie zum aktuellen Bildermarkt journalistischer Onlineangebote am Beispiel von „Der Spiegel“ und „Spiegel Online (mit Kathrin Döveling)
  9. Forschendes Lernen zum Whole School Approach als doppelter Lernanlass von Studierenden und schulischem Berufsbildungspersonal – Konzeption und Umsetzung eines universitären Seminars
  10. Inter-institutional development teams at the ZZL-Netzwerk. Initial teacher education at the Leuphana University of Lüneburg and the university school partnership model at the ZZL-Netzwerk.
  11. „Whole School Approach" als Anspruch einer ganzheitlichen Berufsbildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung im Lernort berufsbildende Schule – Theoretische Konzeptionen und empirische Explorationen
  12. Nachhaltigkeitspolitik als dialektische Verantwortungszerstreuungsmaschine. Die Skalierung von globaler Verantwortung in den Sustainable Development Goals, dem Pariser Abkommen und der Papstenzyklika von 2015
  13. Anpassung der Müllgebühren an die Ziele der ökologischen Abfallwirtschaft - Vorschläge für Gebührenanreiz- und Sammelmodelle: Gutachten. zusammen mit Ulrike Donat, Carola v. Paczensky, Annette Pieper und Ingo Reichenbecher

Publications

  1. Modeling and simulation of deformation behavior, orientation gradient development and heterogeneous hardening in thin sheets with coarse texture
  2. Pearce, Robert D.: The Crowth and Evolution of Multinational Enterprise, Aldershot, UK/Brookfield, USA: Edward Elgar, 1993. 176 pp. f 35.00. ISBN 1-85278-396-6
  3. National stereotypes as literary device. Traditions and uses of stereotypes of Germans in British and the English in German children's literature
  4. Wood species identity alters dominant factors driving fine wood decomposition along a tree diversity gradient in subtropical plantation forests
  5. Influence of laser shock peening on the residual stresses in additively manufactured 316L by Laser Powder Bed Fusion: A combined experimental-numerical study
  6. The role of organized publics in articulating the exnovation of fossil-fuel technologies for intra- and intergenerational energy justice in energy transitions
  7. Acs, Zoltan J. and Audretsch, David B. (eds.): Small Firms and Entrepreneurship: An East-West Perspective, Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993.240 pp. E 30.00. ISBN 0-52143115-8.
  8. Polachek, Solomon W. and Siebert, W. Stanley: The Economics of Earnings, Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993.367 pp. E 40.00 (hard). ISBN 0-521-36476-0. E 15.95 (paper). ISBN 0-521-36728-X.
  9. Rezension: Vico Leuchte (2011). Landkommunen in Ostdeutschland. Lebensgeschichten, Identitätsentfaltung und Sozialwelt.Opladen & Farmington Hills: Verlag Barbara Budrich; 515 Seiten; ISBN 978-3-86649-401-5
  10. Philipp-Alexander Hirsch: Freiheit und Staatlichkeit bei Kant. Die autonomietheoretische Begründung von Recht und Staat und das Widerstandsproblem. De Gruyter, Kantstudien-Ergänzungshefte, Band 194, Berlin/Boston 2017