Beyond stereotypes: Prejudice as an important missing force explaining group disparities

Research output: Journal contributionsComments / Debate / ReportsResearch

Authors

This article questions the widespread use of experimental social psychology to understand real-world group disparities. Standard experimental practice is to design studies in which participants make judgments of targets who vary only on the social categories to which they belong. This is typically done under simplified decision landscapes and with untrained decision-makers. For example, to understand racial disparities in police shootings, researchers show pictures of armed and unarmed Black and White men to undergraduates and have them press shoot and don't shoot buttons. Having demonstrated categorical bias under these conditions, researchers then use such findings to claim that real-world disparities are also due to decision-maker bias. I describe three flaws inherent in this approach, flaws which undermine any direct contribution of experimental studies to explaining group disparities. First, the decision landscapes used in experimental studies lack crucial components present in actual decisions (missing information flaw). Second, categorical effects in experimental studies are not interpreted in light of other effects on outcomes, including behavioral differences across groups (missing forces flaw). Third, there is no systematic testing of whether the contingencies required to produce experimental effects are present in real-world decisions (missing contingencies flaw). I apply this analysis to three research topics to illustrate the scope of the problem. I discuss how this research tradition has skewed our understanding of the human mind within and beyond the discipline and how results from experimental studies of bias are generally misunderstood. I conclude by arguing that the current research tradition should be abandoned.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere74
JournalBehavioral and Brain Sciences
Volume45
Number of pages3
ISSN0140-525X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 05.2022

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2021 The Author(s).

    Research areas

  • discrimination, disparate outcomes, implicit bias, racial bias, school discipline, shooter bias, social psychology, stereotyping

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The role of human resource practices for including persons with disabilities in the workforce
  2. Minimal conditions of motor inductions of approach-avoidance states
  3. Temporary organizing and acceleration
  4. Frank Fischer/Herbert Gottweis (Hg.) The Argumentative Turn Revisited.
  5. Pathways of Conflict: Lessons from the Cultivation of MON810 in Germany in 2005–2008 for Emerging Conflicts over New Breeding Techniques
  6. Introduction: Higher Education for Sustainability
  7. Who guards the guards with AI-driven robots? The ethicalness and cognitive neutralization of police violence following AI-robot advice
  8. Standortvorteil Nachhaltigkeit
  9. THE “CONSULTING DETECTIVE" NITHAN THONG-IN BY KING VAJIRAVUDH
  10. Algae Cultivation as Measure for the Sanitation of Organic Waste—A Case Study Based on the Alga Galdieria sulphuraria Grown on Food Waste Hydrolysate in a Continuous Flow Culture
  11. Connections matter
  12. Organizational Decline and Innovation in Manufacturing
  13. Mechanisms of short-term soil carbon storage in experimental grasslands
  14. Reasons to leave shiftwork and psychological and psychosomatic complaints of former shiftworkers
  15. RSE, management responsable et isomorphisme institutionnel : une analyse à partir des résultats d’une enquête internationale
  16. Steigert das Product-Service System Cloud-Computing die Ökoeffizienz?
  17. Soziale Tatsachen
  18. Promoting Subjective Well-Being and a Sustainable Lifestyle in Children and Youth by Strengthening Their Personal Psychological Resources
  19. Migration als Ausnahme?
  20. Daniela Giannetti and Kenneth Benoit (eds.) (2009). Intra-Party Politics and Coalition Governments (Abingdon: Routledge)
  21. Evaluation of an organizational health intervention for low-skilled workers and immigrants
  22. Jean Piaget zur Einführung
  23. Biodiversität im unternehmerischen Nachhaltigkeitsmanagement
  24. Multisensory Design of Retail Environments
  25. Loan managers’ trust and credit access for SMEs
  26. Poetik der Assimilation
  27. Forecasting European interest rates in times of financial crisis – What insights do we get from international survey forecasts?
  28. Schulleitungsmonitor Schweiz 2021 - Kurzbericht