An-arche and Indifference: Between Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Derrida, and Reiner Schürmann

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

An-arche and Indifference: Between Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Derrida, and Reiner Schürmann. / Rauch, Malte Fabian.
In: Philosophy Today, Vol. 65, No. 3, 2021, p. 619-636.

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{7593e2e4fc594ff7aadf5b2f5d6a8e1a,
title = "An-arche and Indifference: Between Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Derrida, and Reiner Sch{\"u}rmann",
abstract = "This essay explores Giorgio Agamben{\textquoteright}s engagement with Reiner Sch{\"u}rmann, focusing in particular on their ontological understanding of anarchy. Setting out from the lacuna in the literature on this issue, it gives a close reading of the passages where Agamben addresses Sch{\"u}rmann, interrogates the role of of arche in Agamben{\textquoteright}s works and links his interest in Sch{\"u}rmann to his long-standing critique of Derrida. Tracing these issues through Agamben{\textquoteright}s and Sch{\"u}rmann{\textquoteright}s texts, it becomes apparent that both authors operate with a strikingly similar approach, while adumbrating different understandings of the rapport between arche, anarchy and difference. Specifically, the essay argues that Sch{\"u}rmann{\textquoteright}s work can be seen as an incisive reference point in Agamben{\textquoteright}s recent theory of “destituent potential” by focusing on the epilogue of The Use of Bodies. Here, arche and anarchy are positioned as the basic operative categories of the entire Homo Sacer project, while the concept of “true anarchy,” developed in critical dialogue with Sch{\"u}rmann, turns into its philosophical vanishing point. With and against Sch{\"u}rmann{\textquoteright}s attempt to think anarchy as an interruption of identity through difference, Agamben develops his notion of anarchy as as a suspension of difference, that is, as in-difference.",
keywords = "Philosophy, philosophy of difference, indifference, Inoperativity, political ontology, originary ethics, anti-foundationalism, deconstruction, ontological anarchy",
author = "Rauch, {Malte Fabian}",
year = "2021",
doi = "10.5840/philtoday2021520410",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "619--636",
journal = "Philosophy Today",
issn = "0031-8256",
publisher = "Philosophy Documentation Center",
number = "3",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - An-arche and Indifference

T2 - Between Giorgio Agamben, Jacques Derrida, and Reiner Schürmann

AU - Rauch, Malte Fabian

PY - 2021

Y1 - 2021

N2 - This essay explores Giorgio Agamben’s engagement with Reiner Schürmann, focusing in particular on their ontological understanding of anarchy. Setting out from the lacuna in the literature on this issue, it gives a close reading of the passages where Agamben addresses Schürmann, interrogates the role of of arche in Agamben’s works and links his interest in Schürmann to his long-standing critique of Derrida. Tracing these issues through Agamben’s and Schürmann’s texts, it becomes apparent that both authors operate with a strikingly similar approach, while adumbrating different understandings of the rapport between arche, anarchy and difference. Specifically, the essay argues that Schürmann’s work can be seen as an incisive reference point in Agamben’s recent theory of “destituent potential” by focusing on the epilogue of The Use of Bodies. Here, arche and anarchy are positioned as the basic operative categories of the entire Homo Sacer project, while the concept of “true anarchy,” developed in critical dialogue with Schürmann, turns into its philosophical vanishing point. With and against Schürmann’s attempt to think anarchy as an interruption of identity through difference, Agamben develops his notion of anarchy as as a suspension of difference, that is, as in-difference.

AB - This essay explores Giorgio Agamben’s engagement with Reiner Schürmann, focusing in particular on their ontological understanding of anarchy. Setting out from the lacuna in the literature on this issue, it gives a close reading of the passages where Agamben addresses Schürmann, interrogates the role of of arche in Agamben’s works and links his interest in Schürmann to his long-standing critique of Derrida. Tracing these issues through Agamben’s and Schürmann’s texts, it becomes apparent that both authors operate with a strikingly similar approach, while adumbrating different understandings of the rapport between arche, anarchy and difference. Specifically, the essay argues that Schürmann’s work can be seen as an incisive reference point in Agamben’s recent theory of “destituent potential” by focusing on the epilogue of The Use of Bodies. Here, arche and anarchy are positioned as the basic operative categories of the entire Homo Sacer project, while the concept of “true anarchy,” developed in critical dialogue with Schürmann, turns into its philosophical vanishing point. With and against Schürmann’s attempt to think anarchy as an interruption of identity through difference, Agamben develops his notion of anarchy as as a suspension of difference, that is, as in-difference.

KW - Philosophy

KW - philosophy of difference

KW - indifference

KW - Inoperativity

KW - political ontology

KW - originary ethics

KW - anti-foundationalism

KW - deconstruction

KW - ontological anarchy

UR - https://www.pdcnet.org/philtoday/onlinefirst

U2 - 10.5840/philtoday2021520410

DO - 10.5840/philtoday2021520410

M3 - Journal articles

VL - 65

SP - 619

EP - 636

JO - Philosophy Today

JF - Philosophy Today

SN - 0031-8256

IS - 3

ER -

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Stefania Animento

Publications

  1. The comparative study of governments and ministers
  2. Impacts of urban real-world labs: Insights from a co-evaluation process informed by structuration theory in Wuppertal-Mirke
  3. Development of a procedure for forming assisted thermal joining of tubes
  4. Global assessment of the non-equilibrium concept in rangelands
  5. "We're not like that!"
  6. Constructing Audiences, Defining Art
  7. Enterprise Architecture as a Tool for Managing Corporate Social Responsibility
  8. Forest Ecosystems: A functional and biodiversity perspective
  9. Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of a web-based and mobile stress-management intervention for employees
  10. Unpacking the Personal Initiative-Performance Relationship
  11. Demand Chain Management
  12. Ready biodegradability of trifluoromethylated phenothiazine drugs, structural elucidation of their aquatic transformation products, and identification of environmental risks studied by LC-MS( n ) and QSAR
  13. Econometric Studies with Integrated Micro-data from German Official Statistics
  14. Luhmann, the Non-trivial Machine and the Neocybernetic Regime of Truth
  15. What's so great about Finland? An introduction to comparative and international education.
  16. Internet- and App-Based Stress Intervention for Distance-Learning Students With Depressive Symptoms
  17. On the micro-structure of the German export boom
  18. A review of FEM code accuracy for reliable extrusion process analysis
  19. Polite rejections
  20. Umsatzsteigerung durch Nachhaltigkeit
  21. Vorwort
  22. Empowering women in STEM: An innovative study orientation program with a focus on new technologies to strengthen the creative potential and self-efficacy of women
  23. Between joint project, institutional bargaining and symbolic politics
  24. Some Ideological Foundations of Organizational Downsizing