A bait-and-switch model of corporate social responsibility

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

The notion that transparency forces organizations to eschew decoupling and embrace substantive adoption represents an important assumption in the corporate social responsibility (CSR) literature. Conversely, research on learning and social control has considered opacity-understood as a lack of transparency-to be conducive to substantive CSR adoption. These opposing viewpoints highlight a fundamental tension: Is transparency good or bad for substantive adoption? This paper resolves this tension by asking an alternative question: When is transparency good or bad, and why? We advance a dynamic perspective that conceives transparency and opacity as transitory phenomena, and we specify the boundary conditions for which either enduring or transitory forms of transparency and opacity further the substantive adoption of CSR. Our analyses reveal that, for circumstances under which the motivation of ceremonial adoption is hypocritical (rather than opportunistic) and where both substantive adoption and practice abandonment are difficult, the former can be maximized by first allowing organizations to adopt a CSR practice ceremonially under opacity ("bait"), and then prompting ceremonial adopters to become substantive adopters through a shift to transparency ("switch"). Specifying this bait-and-switch mechanism and its underlying contingencies reveals a hitherto unexplored, and potentially effective, pathway toward the institutionalization of CSR.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAcademy of Management Review
Volume46
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)440-464
Number of pages25
ISSN0363-7425
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 07.2021

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
We thank Associate Editor Heli Wang and three anonymous reviewers for their guidance and developmental feedback during the review process. We furthermore received, based on previous drafts, valuable comments and suggestions by Blagoy Blagoev, Itziar Castello, Lars Thøger Christensen, Andy Crane, Peer Fiss, Mikkel Flyverbom, Mike Lounsbury, Jim March, Mette Morsing, Andreas Rasche, Anna Sto€ber, and Klaus Weber. We are also grateful for the helpful feedback from participants at the Academy of Management Annual Meeting 2015, as well as in research seminars at the Universities of Lausanne, Stanford, and Zurich. This research has been supported through the Governing Responsible Business (GRB) cluster at Copenhagen Business School.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 Academy of Management. All rights reserved.

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The Right to Consular Assistance Under International Law
  2. Interkultureller Musikunterricht, hrsg. von Matthias Kruse
  3. Friedrich Kittler
  4. Musik Computer Tanz
  5. PROVENCE - An Eight Issue Magazine Dedicated to Hobbies
  6. Welcome to the (label) jungle? Analyzing how consumers deal with intra-sustainability label trade-offs on food
  7. Kultur-Evolution: Partizipation und Nachhaltigkeit
  8. Prozessmanagement als Instrument für KMU
  9. Multiple anthropogenic pressures challenge the effectiveness of protected areas in western Tanzania
  10. Internal markets or hierachies
  11. Kollaboratives Problemlösen in PISA 2015
  12. Umweltorientiertes Markenmanagement
  13. Unterrichtsdiagnostik als Voraussetzung für Unterrichtsentwicklung
  14. The impact of climate change on aquatic risk from agricultural pesticides in the US
  15. Der Landschaftsbegriff in der Geographie
  16. Zweitalphabetisierung
  17. Die Alpen
  18. Lernkarten Bibelkunde
  19. Lehrerprofessionalität zwischen Theorie und Praxis
  20. § 291 Prozesszinsen
  21. Eine Frage von Genauigkeit?
  22. Ökonomien des Elends
  23. Inter- und transdisziplinäre Lehrforschung
  24. Regulating Exceptions for Research and Exploratory Fishing in Southern Ocean Marine Protected Areas
  25. ‘You can't be green if you're in the red’
  26. Mapping the European Commission Today
  27. Hazard assessment of fluorinated alternatives to long-chain perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) and their precursors
  28. Die Hamburger Verfassung im europäischen Kontext
  29. Gott und die Götter
  30. Rationale Irrationalität oder „Warum lehnen die Intellektuellen den Kapitalismus ab?“
  31. Das ‚hybride Subjekt’
  32. Digital Religious Communication and the Facilitation of Social Resilience
  33. Works councils in Germany
  34. Ein unglaubliches Schriftbild, von Rechtschreibung oder Interpunktion ganz zu schweigen
  35. Der Grundsatz der Subsidiarität der Verfassungsbeschwerde auf dem Prüfstand des Unionsrechts