Treating the nestedness temperature calculator as a "black box" can lead to false conclusions

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenÜbersichtsarbeitenForschung

Authors

We used the nestedness temperature calculator to examine patterns of nestedness in two datasets on birds in fragmented landscapes in southeastern Australia. During our initial analyses, we found that the nestedness calculator was susceptible to detect nestedness as an artifact of passive sampling. To examine this problem in more detail, we created random matrices that simulated a situation where nestedness did not occur, and we re-analysed two previously published datasets. Our results showed that the nestedness calculator may (1) overestimate the degree of nestedness and its statistical significance, and (2) consider some datasets which include both ubiquitous and rare species to be significantly nested although they are not. Our results highlight the danger of blindly relying on the p-values generated by analytical packages such as the nestedness calculator. We suggest that users of analytical packages (often field ecologists) will need to be more critical in future and familiarise themselves in more detail with the packages they use. In addition, the developers of analytical packages (often theoretical ecologists) will need to communicate more clearly the limitations and assumptions underlying analytical tools such as the nestedness calculator.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftOikos
Jahrgang99
Ausgabenummer1
Seiten (von - bis)193-199
Anzahl der Seiten7
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 01.10.2002
Extern publiziertJa

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Eroding Patriarchy
  2. Secret Agents
  3. Robust Current Decoupling in a Permanent Magnet Motor Combining a Geometric Method and SMC
  4. The Continuities of Twitter Strategies and Algorithmic Terror
  5. Albert Viethen
  6. A high power dye laser pumped by a crowbar mode flashlamp
  7. Unmarked Graves: Yet Another Legacy of Canada's Residential School System
  8. Steering for sustainable development
  9. Transdisciplinary learning as a key leverage for sustainability transformations
  10. On the way to greener ionic liquids
  11. Reading Marx
  12. Portfolio optimization in zonal energy markets
  13. Nanomechanical Analysis and Fractography of Extruded Mg-Dy-Nd Based Alloy Influenced by Solution Heat Treatment
  14. Thermomechanical characterization of Portevin-Le Châtelier bands in AlMg3 (AA5754) and modeling based on a modified Estrin-McCormick approach
  15. Copenhagen Diabetes Consensus (CODIAC) 2021
  16. Managing Interorganizational Relations
  17. "And in the end my street will not be the same"
  18. Digitale Geschäftsmodellinnovationen implementieren
  19. E-textile technology
  20. The Welcomers
  21. Sprache in Wissenschaft: Sprachliche Anforderungen wissenschaftlicher Texte
  22. Schreiben ist wie Jonglieren
  23. Controller als Partner im Nachhaltigkeits-Management
  24. Are levels of democracy affected by mass attitudes? Testing attainment and sustainment effects on democracy
  25. The Relationship between the Environmental and Economic Performance of Firms
  26. Climate Policy Cooperation Games between Developed and Developing Nations
  27. Einführende Überlegungen zur Allfinanz-Entwicklung
  28. Elections in Asia and the Pacific: a data handbook
  29. Öko-Investment