The use of pseudo-causal narratives in EU policies: the case of the European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Standard

The use of pseudo-causal narratives in EU policies: the case of the European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa. / Zaun, Natascha; Nantermoz, Olivia.
in: Journal of European Public Policy, Jahrgang 29, Nr. 4, 2022, S. 510-529.

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{a45d7281641f47f0b87e4f66a10467c5,
title = "The use of pseudo-causal narratives in EU policies: the case of the European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa",
abstract = "The EUTF aims to address the {\textquoteleft}root causes of migration{\textquoteright} by providing development assistance to countries of origin and transit. While it is allegedly based on scientific evidence, scholarly consensus suggests that development assistance is ill-suited to address irregular migration–which is something that some of the actors who designed the EUTF were aware of. We advance a new framework for understanding the emergence and success of pseudo-causal narratives (i.e., narratives relying on unproven and/or disproven causal claims) in EU policymaking. Using frame analysis, we argue that the pseudo-causal {\textquoteleft}root causes{\textquoteright} narrative was adopted against better evidence because it was plausible, compelling and had been used in EU external migration policies before. Faced with the salience of migration and the urgency to act in late 2015, and due to the absence of any clear ideas of what other measures could work, EU actors adopted this narrative to demonstrate that they were actively responding to the {\textquoteleft}crisis{\textquoteright}. The narrative met little contestation, since it met the concerns of both those who were keen to stop migration and those who wanted to preserve the core of previous EU development policy.",
keywords = "development aid, EU external migration policy, European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa, evidence-based policymaking, framing, policy narratives, Politics",
author = "Natascha Zaun and Olivia Nantermoz",
note = "Funding Information: This paper is based on the research funded by the Norwegian Research Council (Project No. 288372). The authors would like to thank their interview partners for sharing their insights. Moreover, they would like to thank Andr{\'e} Bank, Ingunn Bj{\o}rkhaug, Kamel Dora{\"i}, Christiane Fr{\"o}hlich, Luicy Pedroza, Guri Tyldum, Karin Vaagland as well as three anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments on an earlier version of this paper. Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2021 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.",
year = "2022",
doi = "10.1080/13501763.2021.1881583",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
pages = "510--529",
journal = "Journal of European Public Policy",
issn = "1350-1763",
publisher = "Routledge Taylor & Francis Group",
number = "4",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - The use of pseudo-causal narratives in EU policies

T2 - the case of the European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa

AU - Zaun, Natascha

AU - Nantermoz, Olivia

N1 - Funding Information: This paper is based on the research funded by the Norwegian Research Council (Project No. 288372). The authors would like to thank their interview partners for sharing their insights. Moreover, they would like to thank André Bank, Ingunn Bjørkhaug, Kamel Doraï, Christiane Fröhlich, Luicy Pedroza, Guri Tyldum, Karin Vaagland as well as three anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments on an earlier version of this paper. Publisher Copyright: © 2021 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.

PY - 2022

Y1 - 2022

N2 - The EUTF aims to address the ‘root causes of migration’ by providing development assistance to countries of origin and transit. While it is allegedly based on scientific evidence, scholarly consensus suggests that development assistance is ill-suited to address irregular migration–which is something that some of the actors who designed the EUTF were aware of. We advance a new framework for understanding the emergence and success of pseudo-causal narratives (i.e., narratives relying on unproven and/or disproven causal claims) in EU policymaking. Using frame analysis, we argue that the pseudo-causal ‘root causes’ narrative was adopted against better evidence because it was plausible, compelling and had been used in EU external migration policies before. Faced with the salience of migration and the urgency to act in late 2015, and due to the absence of any clear ideas of what other measures could work, EU actors adopted this narrative to demonstrate that they were actively responding to the ‘crisis’. The narrative met little contestation, since it met the concerns of both those who were keen to stop migration and those who wanted to preserve the core of previous EU development policy.

AB - The EUTF aims to address the ‘root causes of migration’ by providing development assistance to countries of origin and transit. While it is allegedly based on scientific evidence, scholarly consensus suggests that development assistance is ill-suited to address irregular migration–which is something that some of the actors who designed the EUTF were aware of. We advance a new framework for understanding the emergence and success of pseudo-causal narratives (i.e., narratives relying on unproven and/or disproven causal claims) in EU policymaking. Using frame analysis, we argue that the pseudo-causal ‘root causes’ narrative was adopted against better evidence because it was plausible, compelling and had been used in EU external migration policies before. Faced with the salience of migration and the urgency to act in late 2015, and due to the absence of any clear ideas of what other measures could work, EU actors adopted this narrative to demonstrate that they were actively responding to the ‘crisis’. The narrative met little contestation, since it met the concerns of both those who were keen to stop migration and those who wanted to preserve the core of previous EU development policy.

KW - development aid

KW - EU external migration policy

KW - European Union Emergency Trust Fund for Africa

KW - evidence-based policymaking

KW - framing

KW - policy narratives

KW - Politics

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85101940000&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/13501763.2021.1881583

DO - 10.1080/13501763.2021.1881583

M3 - Journal articles

AN - SCOPUS:85101940000

VL - 29

SP - 510

EP - 529

JO - Journal of European Public Policy

JF - Journal of European Public Policy

SN - 1350-1763

IS - 4

ER -

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Developmentalities and donor-NGO relations
  2. Conclusions
  3. Hot deformation behavior of Mg-2Sn-2Ca alloy in as-cast condition and after homogenization
  4. Third International Mathematics and Science Study and Trends in Mathematics and Science Studies (TIMSS)
  5. Health and the intention to retire: exploring the moderating effects of human resources practices
  6. Emissions of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) in Zurich, Switzerland, determined by a combination of measurements and modeling
  7. Enhancing the transformative potential of interventions for the sustainable use of natural resources
  8. Schreiben digital
  9. Development of a magnesium secondary alloy system for mixed magnesium post-consumer scrap
  10. The First 50 Contributions to the Data Observer Series - An Overview
  11. Long-run economic determinants of asylum applications
  12. Physicochemical properties and biodegradability of organically functionalized colloidal silica particles in aqueous environment
  13. Key criteria for developing ecosystem service indicators to inform decision making
  14. Forms of theorising in entrepreneurship – The case of effectuation as a theory
  15. Influence of rhizobacterial volatiles on the root system architecture and the production and allocation of biomass in the model grass Brachypodium distachyon (L.) P. Beauv
  16. Back from the Deep
  17. Lung fibroblasts from patients with emphysema show markers of senescence in vitro
  18. Mapping water ecosystem services: Evaluating InVEST model predictions in data scarce regions
  19. Combination matters
  20. Impact of an Acceptance Facilitating Intervention on Patients’ Acceptance of Internet-based Pain Interventions
  21. A comparison of current practices in German manufacturing industries
  22. Mapping Urban Information as an Interdisciplinary Method for Geography, Art and Architecture Representations
  23. Ambient Assited Energy Management