Pre-startup planning sophistication and its impact an new venture performance in Germany

Publikation: Beiträge in SammelwerkenAufsätze in KonferenzbändenForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Strategic Management theory suggests effective business planning to be an important requirement for successful start ups. However, little research has been done referring to real business plans made by entrepreneurs. Prior research is based solely on interviews with persons who founded new ventures formerly and does not examine written business plans itself. Moreover, relatively few examinations focus on start ups. The vast majority of empirical work on the planning-performance-link targets established enterprises. All in all, the level of knowledge seems to be quite marginal. This may be caused by some deficiencies associated with prior research on initial business planning. Apart from survivorship bias, limited geographic or industry coverage and an accidental lack of empirical testing, an important deficiency is the interview bias: Performance studies on start ups necessarily depend on an individual recollection of past events when not designed longitudinally. When looking on the later performance of a newly founded enterprise, an interviews approach therefore apparently is biased by selective perception, selective answering, and selective recollection of the past planning behaviour. Those retrospective approaches are thus inappropriate. The objective of this study is to analyze the relationship of planning sophistication and performance of start ups in Germany referring to real business plans. The study investigates planning practices as a determinant of new venture performance. Utilizing files of a well established German start up panel it uses a survey that reduces the distorting effects of survivorship and interview bias. This research design avoids the numerous problems of retrospective approaches. The paper intends to present some findings of an examination of written business plans. It could be found that initial business planning sophistication has a very small impact on performance and is limited at most to the profit and loss planning depth. It finds that initial business planning is rather a hygiene factor than a determining issue concerning performance. Furthermore, one can see that profit and loss planning is the most elaborate area of initial business planning and is executed far more intensely than financial planning. Staff and marketing planning on the other hand are handled as very less important planning topics. Theory and some parts of the literature let assume that planning per se makes sense. Some studies confirmed that planners perform better than non-planners or that accurate planning outperforms less sophisticated planning activities. This study is not meant to doubt this interrelation. But concerning performance, we now can conclude that planning is rather a hygiene factor than a determining issue in a way that planning elaboration resp. raised planning depth could increase performance. In other words: Initial planning is an important requirement of success, but cannot lift it, until certain minimum constraints are met.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
TitelICSB World Conference 2007 : At the Crossroads of East and West : New Opportunities for Entrepreneurship and Small Business
Anzahl der Seiten21
ErscheinungsortTurku
VerlagInternational Council for Small Business
Erscheinungsdatum2007
Seiten295-315
ISBN (Print)9789515642639
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 2007
VeranstaltungICSB World Conference - ICSB 2007: At the Crossroads of East and West: New Opportunities for Entrepreneurship and Small Business. - Turku, Finnland
Dauer: 13.06.200715.06.2007
Konferenznummer: 52

Dokumente

Zuletzt angesehen

Forschende

  1. Simon Roloff

Publikationen

  1. Oliver E. Williamsons Transaktionskostenökonomik
  2. Environmental Value Added
  3. Rein oder nachhaltig rein? 
  4. Od Pacmana do Lary Croft. Jak badać postać w grach wideo?
  5. From a problem to a business opportunity-design of pharmaceuticals for environmental biodegradability
  6. Die Evaluationspraxis an Deutschen Schulen
  7. Von der Hörerpost zur Publikumsstatistik
  8. Vom Nutzen enger Kanäle – Diskursverknappung als Methode
  9. Digitale Möglichkeitsräume
  10. Dear neighbor: Trees with extrafloral nectaries facilitate defense and growth of adjacent undefended trees
  11. Inszenierungen – Present tense incarnate im Fremdsprachenunterricht
  12. Soziale Medien
  13. Gegen Engel kämpfen
  14. Exporte und Produktivität in mittelständischen Betrieben
  15. What's legit?
  16. Satan is Boring
  17. John Franklin's Expedition into the Arctic "Heart of Darkness"
  18. COVID-19-related fear, stress and depression in school principals
  19. Das Assessment auf der SCoRe-Lernplattform
  20. Die mosaische Unterscheidung oder der Preis des Monotheismus
  21. Forest Restoration
  22. Confliggere cooperando
  23. Handbuch Konstellationsanalyse
  24. A computable general equilibrium assessment of a developing country joining an Annex B emission permit market
  25. § 62 Bußgeldvorschriften
  26. The role of private litigation in market regulation
  27. Bildungsreise in digitale Welten
  28. Die Problematik Granels
  29. Collaborative epistemic writing and writing-to-learn in mathematics
  30. The Great Pacific Garbage Catch
  31. An Empirical Investigation of Terrorism-Induced Stress on Expatriate Attitudes and Performance
  32. Global Climate Protection
  33. Remote Sensing of Bush Encroachment on Commercial Cattle Farms in Semi-Arid Rangelands in Namibia
  34. What's legit?