How mobile app design impacts user responses to mixed self-tracking outcomes: Randomized online experiment to explore the role of spatial distance for hedonic editing

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Background: Goal setting is among the most common behavioral change techniques employed in contemporary self-tracking apps. For these techniques to be effective, it is relevant to understand how the visual presentation of goal-related outcomes employed in the app design affects users’ responses to their self-tracking outcomes. Objective: This study examined whether a spatially close (vs distant) presentation of mixed positive and negative self-tracking outcomes from multiple domains (ie, activity, diet) on a digital device’s screen can provide users the opportunity to hedonically edit their self-tracking outcome profile (ie, to view their mixed self-tracking outcomes in the most positive light). Further, this study examined how the opportunity to hedonically edit one’s self-tracking outcome profile relates to users’ future health behavior intentions. Methods: To assess users’ responses to a spatially close (vs distant) presentation of a mixed-gain (vs mixed-loss) self-tracking outcome profile, a randomized 2×2 between-subjects online experiment with a final sample of 397 participants (mean age 27.4, SD 7.2 years; 71.5%, 284/397 female) was conducted in Germany. The experiment started with a cover story about a fictitious self-tracking app. Thereafter, participants saw one of four manipulated self-tracking outcome profiles. Variables of interest measured were health behavior intentions, compensatory health beliefs, health motivation, and recall of the outcome profile. We analyzed data using chi-square tests (SPSS version 23) and moderated mediation analyses with the PROCESS macro 2.16.1. Results: Spatial distance facilitated hedonic editing, which was indicated by systematic memory biases in users’ recall of positive and negative self-tracking outcomes. In the case of a mixed-gain outcome profile, a spatially close (vs distant) presentation tended to increase the underestimation of the negative outcome (P=.06). In the case of a mixed-loss outcome profile, a spatially distant (vs close) presentation facilitated the exact recognition of the positive outcome (P=.04). When the presentation of self-tracking outcomes provided the opportunity for hedonic editing, users with a low (vs high) health motivation produced compensatory health beliefs, which led to lower health behavior intentions (index of moderated mediation=0.0352, 95% CI 0.0011-0.0923). Conclusions: When spatial distance between the presentations of mixed self-tracking outcomes provided the opportunity to hedonically edit one’s self-tracking outcome profile, users recalled their self-tracking outcomes in a more positive light. Especially for users with lower health motivation, the opportunity to hedonically edit one’s mixed self-tracking outcome profile led to reduced health behavior intentions. To prevent the occurrence of hedonic editing in users’ responses to visually presented self-tracking outcome profiles, further research is necessary to determine the ideal distance that should be employed in the app design for the presentation of mixed self-tracking outcomes on a digital device’s screen.

OriginalspracheEnglisch
Aufsatznummere81
ZeitschriftJMIR mHealth and uHealth
Jahrgang6
Ausgabenummer4
Anzahl der Seiten13
ISSN2291-5222
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 11.04.2018
Extern publiziertJa

Bibliographische Notiz

Publisher Copyright:
© Monika Imschloss, Jana Lorenz.

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Aktivitäten

  1. Time and Income Poverty Dynamics - An Interdependent Multidimensional Approach with German Time Use Data
  2. Workshop: The conceptualization of sound within a studio environment 2011
  3. Are Self-Employed Time and Money Poor? Dynamics of Interpendent Multidimensional Poverty with German Time Use Diary Data
  4. Student Consumer Learning in Schools‘ „Cultures of Consumption“: Results of an Empirical Study
  5. Legitimizing Digital Transformation within an Incumbent: How Unaccepted Leaders Can Initiate Strategic Changes
  6. Automatic Detection and Classification of State Heads and Common People?
  7. The power and peril of precise numbers
  8. Measurement of Mental Models of Climate Change. Cross-Linked Thinking through Scenario Analysis
  9. Paper: The Multilevel Governance of Deportation – is Access to local Membership possible?
  10. Comparative Perspectives on Social Values and Modernization - 2011
  11. Karlstad Universität
  12. The Ethics of Memory - 2009
  13. Picasso and AI: analysing and questioning the technology that overwhelms us
  14. Who does take part in which kind of teacher professional development?
  15. Wien Depot: Podiumsdiskussion
  16. PhD Workshop on Theories in Information Systems Science
  17. Spas in the New Länder: A Transformation with an Uncertain Outcome.
  18. Interdisziplinarität in kuratorischen Netzwerken
  19. CHANGE Expertenworkshop 2008
  20. Education for Sustainable Development – Experiences from Theory and Practice
  21. Stimmtraining - 2009
  22. Towards a New Aesthetic Paradigm
  23. HyperKult XXIII – Bring your own... 2014
  24. Karlstad Universität
  25. Begriffliche Probleme lyrischer Subjektivität
  26. Conference "FICTION AND SIMULATION: Theories, Methods, Practices" - 2015
  27. Exploring organizational processes:A tension-based view
  28. Inherent constraints and the logic of 'There is no alternative': A political Anamnesis
  29. Non-expert AI Educators in Higher Education: How can OER support AI Teaching Practices?

Presse / Medien

  1. Performance unter Hypnose