Fossil Natural Gas Exit – A New Narrative for the European Energy Transformation towards Decarbonization

Publikation: Arbeits- oder Diskussionspapiere und BerichteArbeits- oder Diskussionspapiere

Authors

This paper discusses the potential role of fossil natural gas (and other gases) in the process of the energy transformation in Europe on its way to complete decarbonization. Mainstream conventional wisdom has it that natural gas, perhaps in combination with other gases, should maintain an important role in the energy mix, first, as a “bridge fuel”, and then through a gradual transition toward decarbonized gases. This is most comprehensively rolled out in three consecutive discussion papers by Jonathan Stern from the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies (2017b, 2017a, 2019). Based on an in- depth assessment of the ambitious climate targets of the EU and the subsequent need for far-reaching decarbonization, as well as on results from energy system modeling, a contrasting result emerges, where the disappearance of fossil natural gas and its corresponding infrastructure is the next logical step of the transformation process in Europe. The lack of an economic perspective for nuclear power and the absence of a plausible deployment of large-scale carbon-dioxide removal technologies (CDR) imply that natural gas has no “sweet spot” any longer in the decarbonization process. In other words: Fossil natural gas is no longer part of the solution to the challenge of climate change, but has become part of the problem. Over the last years, the phasing out of natural gas in Europe has already started, and will continue until its complete phase-out, most likely in the 2040s, i.e. only two decades from now. The decline of natural gas in Europe has implications for the short- and longer-term aggregate and sectoral energy mix, but also for the future of the lumpy infrastructure, that has been developed over the last decades for a growing market. Today, investments into natural gas infrastructure are likely to produce stranded assets, as we show in three concrete cases: The € 10 bn. investment into the North Stream 2 pipeline are not necessary to assure European supply security, nor to make a return on investment; projects of new LNG terminals on the shore of the German North Sea (Brunsbuettel, Stade, Wilhelmshaven) lack a business case; and new natural gas power plants are likely to be unprofitable. The paper proposes to replace the dominant narrative (“natural gas in decarbonizing European energy markets“) with what we consider a more coherent narrative in the context of decarbonization: Fossil natural gas exit.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ErscheinungsortBerlin
VerlagDeutsches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (DIW)
Anzahl der Seiten46
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 2020
Extern publiziertJa

Zuletzt angesehen

Aktivitäten

  1. Obscure girl of Italo: On the language use of ITALO DISCO MANIACS
  2. Violence and First Nations: Canadian Studies - Global Issues in Focus
  3. Responsivity as a transdisciplinary research principle
  4. Surveying Concepts of "Creative City", "Creative Industries" and Policies of Arts and Planning on Baltimore, MD
  5. Mediale Schrift und auditive Gestaltung - 2006
  6. Tagung der DVPW-Landesgruppe Bayern
  7. “Next Generation" Panel: Arts & Culture in the Pandemic - Taking on an International Perspective of Emerging Researchers and Young Cultural Managers to Foster Networks and Partnerships
  8. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Fremdsprachenforschung e.V. (Externe Organisation)
  9. Universität Wien (Externe Organisation)
  10. The genie is out of the bottle! Dialoguing as a cultural entrepreneurship practice in crowdfunding
  11. The Conjuncture of 'Cancel Culture': Relations of Gender and Sexuality in Times of Crisis
  12. Leuphana Universität Lüneburg (Organisation)
  13. Sprache und Kultur (Organisation)
  14. Institute of English Studies (Organisation)
  15. 1621: 400 Jahre Universität Rinteln
  16. Why do Firms Support Transnational Industrial Relations Arrangements? A Processual Lens
  17. Fakultät Bildung (Organisation)
  18. Violence against children in times of COVID-19 – A blind spot.
  19. Vortrag: Corporate Volunteering. Konzepte und Fallstricke
  20. The Politics of Love: Queer Debt
  21. 1st HELENA International Conference - GIEE 2011
  22. Führung, Innovation und Digital Literacy
  23. 5th International Conference on Engineerng Education in Sustainable Development - 2010
  24. Interdisziplinäre Tagung Institut für Zeitgeschichte - 2007
  25. The Future of Critical Art Institutions. The 'Kunstraum der Universität Lüneburg'