Debating accounting and sustainability: from incompatibility to rapprochement in the pursuit of corporate sustainability

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Purpose: This article explores and contrasts the views of two influential research projects within the social and environmental accounting space. Both projects advocate for sustainability. The first here referred to as the Critical Social and Environmental Accounting Project (CSEAP), was developed and championed by Rob Gray and calls for immediate radical structural change. The second one is called the Pragmatic Sustainability Management Accounting Project (PSMAP), championed by Stefan Schaltegger, and advocates for an entrepreneurial process of creating radical solutions in joint stakeholder collaboration over time. Design/methodology/approach: The paper is the culmination of a decade-long debate between Gray and Schaltegger as advocates of CSEAP and PSMAP, respectively. Specifically, the paper explores the differences and agreements between CSEAP and PSMAP on whether and how companies should pursue sustainability and the role of accounting in these efforts. The paper focusses on critical issues that exemplify the tension in their views: general goals, the role of structure and agency and how to creating change and transformation. Findings: The article contrasts CSEAP's uncompromising antagonising approach to accountability and fundamental systemic change with PSMAP's pragmatic approach to sustainability accounting with its management and entrepreneurship-orientated approach to change and unwavering support for transformative managers on the front lines. Despite their apparent differences, the paper also outlines areas of agreement between these two positions and how accounting and sustainability can move forward. Research limitations/implications: The debate tries to reconcile language and conceptional differences in the social and environmental accounting (SEA) and sustainability management accounting (SMA) communities to reduce confusion in the research space over what sustainability is for organisations and what role accounting plays in this. The authors hope that the tension between the different positions outlined in this paper generates new insights and positions on the topic. Practical implications: While the two views explored in this paper are primarily incompatible, each generates implications for practice, research and education. Debates like this are crucial to moving from discursive disagreement to creating a tolerant and robust foundation for moving forward and achieving much-needed sustainable transitions in the economy and society. Originality/value: The authors offer shared understandings, points of continuing disagreement and alternative views on the nature of sustainability. The debate forges a bridge of understanding where both sides can learn from each other.

OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftAccounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal
Jahrgang36
Ausgabenummer2
Seiten (von - bis)591-619
Anzahl der Seiten29
ISSN0951-3574
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 27.03.2023

Bibliographische Notiz

Funding Information:
Rob Gray has passed away.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2022, Emerald Publishing Limited.

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Tuition fees and funding - barriers for non-traditional students ?
  2. Erneuerungen in der Lehrerbildung
  3. 10 Jahre Forschungsinstitut Freie Berufe (FFB) der Universität Lüneburg
  4. ‚Places of Remembrance’: spaces for historical and political literacy
  5. Das Empire, der Nordwesten und der Rest der Welt
  6. Blinde Flecken in der Unternehmensführung
  7. Edith Meyer von Kamptz (1884-1969)
  8. The modernization of West German police
  9. Akzeptanz und Nutzung der FDS-Methoden durch die Fachkräfte
  10. Vom Dozieren zum Dialog
  11. Pierre Bourdieu: Die Kraft des Rechts
  12. Jugend und Nachhaltigkeit
  13. Phase-field modelling for fatigue crack growth under laser shock peening-induced residual stresses
  14. Objekttheater begegnet digitalen Welten
  15. Impact of green and blue-green light on the growth, pigment concentration, and fatty acid unsaturation in the microalga Monoraphidium braunii
  16. The rubber brick’s story
  17. Stefan Panhans
  18. Die Pflicht zur Information der Öffentlichkeit nach § 39 KrW-/AbfG - eine überflüssige Norm?
  19. Krisis und Invention
  20. Discursive Tropes of Aggression Against Queer-Sexuality in Nigerian Standup Comedy
  21. Action training for charismatic leadership
  22. National culture and business model change
  23. Worlds Apart: Does Perceptual Congruence Between Leaders and Older Employees Regarding Age-Friendly Organizational Climate, Management, and Work Design Matter?
  24. Editorial
  25. § 289 c Inhalt der nichtfinanziellen Erklärung
  26. Dynamics of the polycrisis
  27. Participation of Children and Young People in Alternative Care - Introduction
  28. Die Grundschul-Bibel
  29. Farmer Perceptions of the Ecosystem Services Provided by Scavengers
  30. Schadenfreude as social-functional dominance regulator
  31. Collaborative governance and personal relationships for sustainability transformation in the textile sector

Presse / Medien

  1. Queer, arabisch, lebensfroh