Debating accounting and sustainability: from incompatibility to rapprochement in the pursuit of corporate sustainability

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Purpose: This article explores and contrasts the views of two influential research projects within the social and environmental accounting space. Both projects advocate for sustainability. The first here referred to as the Critical Social and Environmental Accounting Project (CSEAP), was developed and championed by Rob Gray and calls for immediate radical structural change. The second one is called the Pragmatic Sustainability Management Accounting Project (PSMAP), championed by Stefan Schaltegger, and advocates for an entrepreneurial process of creating radical solutions in joint stakeholder collaboration over time. Design/methodology/approach: The paper is the culmination of a decade-long debate between Gray and Schaltegger as advocates of CSEAP and PSMAP, respectively. Specifically, the paper explores the differences and agreements between CSEAP and PSMAP on whether and how companies should pursue sustainability and the role of accounting in these efforts. The paper focusses on critical issues that exemplify the tension in their views: general goals, the role of structure and agency and how to creating change and transformation. Findings: The article contrasts CSEAP's uncompromising antagonising approach to accountability and fundamental systemic change with PSMAP's pragmatic approach to sustainability accounting with its management and entrepreneurship-orientated approach to change and unwavering support for transformative managers on the front lines. Despite their apparent differences, the paper also outlines areas of agreement between these two positions and how accounting and sustainability can move forward. Research limitations/implications: The debate tries to reconcile language and conceptional differences in the social and environmental accounting (SEA) and sustainability management accounting (SMA) communities to reduce confusion in the research space over what sustainability is for organisations and what role accounting plays in this. The authors hope that the tension between the different positions outlined in this paper generates new insights and positions on the topic. Practical implications: While the two views explored in this paper are primarily incompatible, each generates implications for practice, research and education. Debates like this are crucial to moving from discursive disagreement to creating a tolerant and robust foundation for moving forward and achieving much-needed sustainable transitions in the economy and society. Originality/value: The authors offer shared understandings, points of continuing disagreement and alternative views on the nature of sustainability. The debate forges a bridge of understanding where both sides can learn from each other.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAccounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal
Volume36
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)591-619
Number of pages29
ISSN0951-3574
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 27.03.2023

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2022, Emerald Publishing Limited.

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Marco Schauer

Publications

  1. Nonadherence in outpatient thrombosis prophylaxis with low molecular weight heparins after major orthopaedic surgery
  2. Introduction
  3. Die mythologische Differenz
  4. Vergütung, variable
  5. The Theatricality of Organizational Atmosphere
  6. Ressourcen- oder mitgliederbasiert?
  7. Bird Diversity and the Resilience of Southwestern Ethiopian Forests
  8. Lob des Berührens
  9. Yellow submarine
  10. Institutional entrepreneurship for responsible digital innovation
  11. Cybermobbing, Hatespeech, Sexting und Cybergrooming.
  12. Philosophy of Religion
  13. Power from the Desert
  14. Regulation of Access to Limited Resources in the Telecommunications Sector in Europe
  15. Effects of phosphorous, nitrogen, and carbon limitation on biomass composition in batch and continuous flow cultures of the heterotrophic dinoflagellate Crypthecodinium cohnii
  16. Crack propagation under bending in cast MglOGdxNd-T4 alloys
  17. Analysis of instantaneous thermal expansion coefficient curve during thermal cycling in short fiber reinforced AlSi12CuMgNi composites
  18. Ausgewählte Kapitel der Theoretischen Informatik
  19. § 19 Wechselseitig beteiligte Unternehmen
  20. Planetary carambolage
  21. Vatername Gottes IV. Neues Testament
  22. Governance to manage the complexity of nature’s contributions to people co-production
  23. Single-Item Screening for Agoraphobic Symptoms
  24. Global Consciousness Predicts Behavioral Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic
  25. Einführung in das Wirtschaftsvölkerrecht Teil I
  26. Die Zukunft des Englischunterrichts als Utopie
  27. Comparative children's literature
  28. Erhaltung virtueller Realitäten
  29. Sight or scent: lemur sensory reliance in detecting food quality varies with feeding ecology.
  30. Equilibrium of vegetation and climate at the European rear edge. A reference for climate change planning in mountainous Mediterranean regions
  31. Attraktive Arbeitgeber in der Pflege
  32. Click Here to Shop Now!
  33. Buchbesprechungen
  34. Family firm identity and capital structure decisions
  35. Brexit's implications for EU-NATO cooperation
  36. Konstellation städtischer Gruppen