Unravelling the paradox of public participation: Beyond competing claims about effectiveness

Aktivität: Vorträge und GastvorlesungenKonferenzvorträgeForschung

Ed Challies - Ko-Autor*in

Various forms of public participation and stakeholder engagement have proliferated in Western democracies since the early 1990s as a result of both democratic demands from below, and tendencies to decentralisation and devolution from above. This tendency has been particularly notable in the realm of environmental governance, and has been driven by a widely-held belief that more participatory processes are ultimately more effective in producing decisions and policy outputs, as well as intermediate outcomes, conducive to environmental sustainability. As participatory governance has become more widespread, research and literature addressing this phenomenon has also flourished. Despite a now voluminous literature comprising thousands of case studies of public participation in environmental governance, attempts to systematically aggregate findings and consolidate knowledge on precisely how and under what conditions different forms of participatory governance work, remain rare. In this paper we present what have emerged as core hypotheses from the literature that address the relationship between (a) participation and the environmental standard of outputs, and (b) participation and the implementability of outputs. We disaggregate these hypotheses as far as possible, with the aim of isolating causal relations between important variables in the policy process. In addition, we take stock of contextual factors and boundary conditions with a bearing on different causal relations. We suggest that identification of the most important hypotheses on the relationship between participation and effectiveness is an important first step in generating and consolidating robust evidence on the ‘instrumental’ value of participatory modes of environmental governance. Such evidence should be of relevance to a wide range of researchers in the field of participatory governance, and of practical use to those that must balance environmental and democratic imperatives in designing and conducting participatory governance processes.
21.09.2013

Veranstaltung

3-Länder-Tagung Politikwissenschaft - 2013: Politik der Vielfalt

19.09.1321.09.13

Innsbruck, Deutschland

Veranstaltung: Konferenz

Zuletzt angesehen

Forschende

  1. Niklas Werthschulte

Publikationen

  1. 'YouTubers unite': collective action by YouTube content creators
  2. Development of a magnesium recycling alloy based on AM50
  3. University students’ experience of the Beirut port explosion
  4. Recent developments in microalgal conversion of organic-enriched waste streams
  5. Printing Utopia
  6. Synchronic and Diachronic Pragmatic Variability
  7. The persistent decline in unionization in Western and Eastern Germany, 1980-2004
  8. Funkprotokolle für mobile Anwendungen
  9. Rethinking gender: feminist perspectives on Sustainable Development Goals in the light of (re)productivity
  10. Theories of Development of Democracy
  11. The social productivity of anonymity
  12. Does public participation in environmental decisions lead to improved environmental quality ?
  13. Hold Back The River
  14. Cognition in High-Frequency Trading
  15. Residual stresses of the as-cast Mg-xCa alloys with hot sprues by neutron diffraction
  16. Multiple streams, leaked opportunities, and entrepreneurship in the EU agenda against tax avoidance
  17. Bereichsrezensionen
  18. Exploring Student Perceptions of the Hidden Curriculum in Responsible Management Education
  19. Consensus Vs. Dissensus
  20. Referenzmodellierung von rechnergestützten Logistikkennzahlensystemen
  21. Institutional Change of the German Higher Education System
  22. Modelling ammonia volatilisation following urea fertilisation in a winter wheat-maize rotation in China
  23. Digitalisierung – Arbeit – Bildung
  24. Schätzen – Aber wie?
  25. Zeit-los im Studio?
  26. Forschendes Lernen implementieren durch Design-Based-Research
  27. Exports and Profitability
  28. Fast Car
  29. § 63 Geheimhaltung und Datenschutz
  30. Financial Solutions for Innovation and Sustainable Development in the Energy Sector
  31. Happy
  32. When Killing is a Crime
  33. Housing in the Margins: Negotiating Urban Formalities in Berlin's Allotment Gardens
  34. Positive interactions between nitrogen-fixing legumes and four different neighbouring species in a biodiversity experiment
  35. Context and appropriateness