When one size does not fit all: A literature review on the modifications of the balanced scorecard

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

Robert Kaplan and David Norton emphasize that the four perspectives of their standard balanced scorecard (BSC) need to be adapted to the organizational context. Yet, we lack a coherent body of knowledge on these adaptations. 20 years after the implementation of the BSC, a literature review is warranted to investigate if and how the original BSC has been modified in practice. The authors conduct a systematic literature review of leading academic journals from 1992 to 2012 to identify and analyze the extant empirical evidence on the BSC. The authors find 117 empirical studies on the BSC, of which 27 deal with BSC-modifications. First, the authors conclude that the BSC-perspectives have been modified to match different industries, organizational levels, or functions (e.g., the public sector, information systems, supply chain management, corporate social responsibility, or incentive systems). Second, the authors use an established BSC classification, and argue that the BSC has also been modified in terms of its sophistication. This paper can only identify few examples where the BSC has become an incentive-relevant management system as imagined by Kaplan and Norton; many organizations stop at the level of a measurement system. On the one hand, this article demonstrates the versatility of the BSC and its perspectives as claimed by Kaplan and Norton. On the other hand, the lack of sophisticated implementations shed a critical light on the relevance of the BSC in practice.

Original languageEnglish
JournalProblems and Perspectives in Management (PPM)
Volume11
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)86-94
Number of pages9
ISSN1727-7051
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Balanced scorecard, Corporate social responsibility, Environment, Implementation, Incentives, Information systems, Literature review, Organizational design, Performance evaluation, Performance measurement system, Public sector, Supply chain management
  • Management studies

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Thomas Niemeyer

Publications

  1. Global decoupling of functional and phylogenetic diversity in plant communities
  2. Adapting and evolving-learning place cooperation in change
  3. Influence of 8-weeks of supervised static stretching or resistance training of pectoral major muscles on maximal strength, muscle thickness and range of motion
  4. Erratum
  5. Beyond Personalization and Anonymity:
  6. Incentives under hybrid activity-based costing systems
  7. Anticipating and transforming futures
  8. For the good of the people: establishing public value creation as an objective for sustainable entrepreneurship policy
  9. Anmerkung zu EuGH, Urt. v. 1.7.2010 (Fall Povse)
  10. The complementarity of single-species and ecosystem-oriented research in conservation research
  11. Geochemical Assessment of Sediment Quality Using Multivariate Statistical Analysis of Ennore Creek, North of Chennai, SE Coast of India.
  12. Towards a Relational Materialism
  13. If i may say so
  14. Does the Aarhus Convention Require an Association Action to Protect the Environment in German Private Law?
  15. Logistical futures the chinese dream, debordering labor, and migration
  16. Alleviating depression in the unemployed
  17. Freie Berufe im Mikrozensus II - Einkommen und Einkommensverteilung
  18. The Changing Public - Private-Mix in OECD Healthcare Systems
  19. Belief in Free Will Relates to Attributions of Intentionality and Judgments of Responsibility
  20. Happy just because. A cross-cultural study on subjective wellbeing in three Indigenous societies
  21. Selbstbestimmung und Classroom-Management
  22. Logistik-Controlling
  23. Field measurement of ammonia emissions after nitrogen fertilization-A comparison between micrometeorological and chamber methods
  24. Mathematical Chemistry and Chemoinformatics