The lens of polycentricity: Identifying polycentric governance systems illustrated through examples from the field of water governance

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Nadine Jenny Shirin Schröder

This paper discusses definitions that have been developed and used in the study of polycentric governance. It offers conceptual refinements with the aim of reducing fuzziness, showing challenges of operationalization and application to an empirical setting—in other words, analyzing governance arrangements through the polycentricity lens. One defining element of polycentricity is the presence of “multiple decision-making centers.” This paper shows that this multiplicity is specific to the good/problem in focus, the center's tasks/responsibilities, the level in focus and analytical system boundaries. Functional overlapping among those centers is required to consider centers forming one system in relation to a good. These specificities should be examined for comparisons on polycentricity influencing the functioning of systems. The paper applies those conceptual refinements to the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive in Berlin and Hamburg. It characterizes the two cases in terms of their polycentricity. It compares their functioning so far and how the latter relates to interactions and social interrelations. The polycentricity lens illuminates important features and differences: given an overall multiplicity of centers and a similar rule setting in both cities, the differences in the distribution of responsibilities and social interrelations led to a faster but less integrated implementation in Hamburg than in Berlin. The application of the proposed refinements yields insights into further work to be done in favor of theory-building on the functioning of polycentric governance systems.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEnvironmental Policy and Governance
Volume28
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)236-251
Number of pages16
ISSN1756-932X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.07.2018

    Research areas

  • EU Water Framework Directive, Germany, performance, polycentricity, veto-player-theory, water governance
  • Sustainability Governance

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Peter Leonhard

Publications

  1. Sensorimotor Control and Proprioception in Neurorehabilitation
  2. Shifts in plant functional trait dynamics in relation to soil microbiome in modern and wild barley
  3. Revegetation in agricultural areas: the development of structural complexity and floristic diversity
  4. Vibration Converter with Passive Energy Management for Battery‐Less Wireless Sensor Nodes in Predictive Maintenance
  5. Searching for New Languages, Searching for Minor Voices in the Archive
  6. Injection of CO2 for the inhibition of scaling in ATES systems
  7. How Founders Harness Tensions in Hybrid Venture Development
  8. Editorial: Courts in Context. An Empirical Re-Evaluation of Categorization in the Asylum Regime
  9. Microstructure and hardness evolution of laser metal deposited AA5087 wall-structures
  10. Soziale Netzwerkanalyse
  11. Public Value
  12. Utilizing international networks for accelerating research and learning in transformational sustainability science
  13. Biodiversity and Resilience of Ecosystem Functions
  14. Schulleitungsmonitor Schweiz 2022
  15. Internet-Based Guided Self-Help for Vaginal Penetration Difficulties
  16. The Boundary Objects Concept: Theorizing Film and Media.
  17. Knowledge Production in Consulting Teams
  18. The Weinberg-Salam Model of Electroweak Interactions
  19. Spatial scaling of extinction rates
  20. A Glue from Snail Slime?!
  21. A call for statistical editors in ecology
  22. Variational Pragmatics
  23. Heat and light
  24. (Inhibiting) Factors for (Un)Sustainable Behaviour in Relation to the Effects of Education for Sustainable Development
  25. Science, policy and implementation gaps: An exploration of groundwater management in Hungary
  26. Der gegenwärtige Jazzdiskurs in Deutschland
  27. Fixed-term contracts and employment adjustment
  28. Wende überall?
  29. The mimicry of dialogue
  30. Günstigkeitsprinzip
  31. How Organizations Manage the Future
  32. Versuch, Vollendung, Beendigung und Verjährung
  33. Finance is Society!