The lens of polycentricity: Identifying polycentric governance systems illustrated through examples from the field of water governance

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Nadine Jenny Shirin Schröder

This paper discusses definitions that have been developed and used in the study of polycentric governance. It offers conceptual refinements with the aim of reducing fuzziness, showing challenges of operationalization and application to an empirical setting—in other words, analyzing governance arrangements through the polycentricity lens. One defining element of polycentricity is the presence of “multiple decision-making centers.” This paper shows that this multiplicity is specific to the good/problem in focus, the center's tasks/responsibilities, the level in focus and analytical system boundaries. Functional overlapping among those centers is required to consider centers forming one system in relation to a good. These specificities should be examined for comparisons on polycentricity influencing the functioning of systems. The paper applies those conceptual refinements to the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive in Berlin and Hamburg. It characterizes the two cases in terms of their polycentricity. It compares their functioning so far and how the latter relates to interactions and social interrelations. The polycentricity lens illuminates important features and differences: given an overall multiplicity of centers and a similar rule setting in both cities, the differences in the distribution of responsibilities and social interrelations led to a faster but less integrated implementation in Hamburg than in Berlin. The application of the proposed refinements yields insights into further work to be done in favor of theory-building on the functioning of polycentric governance systems.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEnvironmental Policy and Governance
Volume28
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)236-251
Number of pages16
ISSN1756-932X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.07.2018

    Research areas

  • EU Water Framework Directive, Germany, performance, polycentricity, veto-player-theory, water governance
  • Sustainability Governance

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Lukas Stolz

Publications

  1. Evaluating a hybrid web-based training program for panic disorder and agoraphobia
  2. Conceptualizing protected area research in a transdisciplinary
  3. Investigation of the sulfur speciation in petroleum products by capillary gas chromatography with ICP-collision cell-MS detection
  4. Mapping Urban Information as an Interdisciplinary Method for Geography, Art and Architecture Representations
  5. Material system analysis
  6. Software and Web-Based Tools for Sustainability Management in Micro-, Small- and Medium-Sized Enterprises
  7. Collisions in space
  8. A Process Perspective on Organizational Failure
  9. Social group membership does not modulate automatic imitation in a contrastive multi-agent paradigm
  10. Intelligence assessment with computer simulations
  11. Capitalizing on natural language processing (NLP) to automate the evaluation of coach implementation fidelity in guided digital cognitive-behavioral therapy (GdCBT)
  12. Rapid Prototyping of a Mechatronic Engine Valve Controller for IC Engines
  13. Constitutions, Democratic Self-Determination and the Institutional Empowerment of Future Generations: Mitigating an Aporia
  14. Ticio Escobar
  15. Resolving conflicts between people and over time in the transformation toward sustainability
  16. Lyapunov stability analysis to set up a saturating PI controller with anti-windup for a mass flow system
  17. U-model-based dynamic inversion control for quadrotor UAV systems
  18. Systematic risk behavior in cyclical industries
  19. Bridging scenario planning and backcasting
  20. On the Existence of Digital Objects
  21. Release of monomers from four different composite materials after halogen and LED curing
  22. System and action theory
  23. Audio-Hacks
  24. Internet: Impact and Potential for Learning and Instruction
  25. Modeling and Simulation of Electrochemical Cells under Applied Voltage
  26. Controlling a Bank Model Economy by Sliding Mode Control with Help of Kalman Filter