Opportunities and limits to ecosystem services governance in developing countries and indigenous territories: The case of water supply in Southern Chile

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Laura Nahuelhual
  • Gonzalo Saavedra
  • F. Henríquez
  • Felipe Benra
  • X. Vergara
  • Carol Perugache
  • F. Hasen
Limited evidence exists on the a priori feasibility of implementing ecosystem services (ES) governance arrangements, to simultaneously ensure nature conservation, human wellbeing, and equity. Using a multiscale institutional approach, we explore rules, property rights, and stakeholders’ values and the extent to which such institutions may entail or prevent governance innovations around ES. We focus on water supply and a Southern municipality of Chile as an apt illustration. Results show that the concept of ES and ES mechanisms are exempt from formal norms (e.g., national laws). The formal institutional setting is generally weak with respect to nature conservation and a fragmented view prevails, where the management of land, water, forests and protected areas is separately handled by a myriad of agencies. The presence of highly concentrated water rights may impair benefits appropriability by ES beneficiaries, as long as any potential buyer can acquire water rights. Furthermore, incompatible values regarding nature create tensions across different stakeholders, particularly between hydroelectricity companies and indigenous communities. In this scenario of multiple rationalities, moving towards ES-based environmental governance seems problematic. In light of the evidence, it is clear that the ES approach does not necessarily fit in every local reality and seems to face obstacles, such as achieving equity and justice, particularly in contexts wherein local and indigenous knowledge systems have not been adequately considered by states within their institutional arrangements.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEnvironmental Science and Policy
Volume86
Pages (from-to)11-18
Number of pages8
ISSN1462-9011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.2018
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2018 Elsevier Ltd

    Research areas

  • Ecosystems Research - Collective action, Political ecology, Indigenous rights, Indigenous knowledge systems, Water

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Care leavers as helpers
  2. Skalierung und dimensionale Struktur des DaZKom-Testinstruments
  3. Democratization
  4. Lesen im Wandel
  5. The questions we ask matter: insights from place-based research on nature’s contributions to people
  6. Parteiensysteme in jungen Demokratien der Dritten Welt
  7. Product customization
  8. Stille, Geräusch, Rauschen
  9. Prediction of nanoparticle transport behavior from physicochemical properties
  10. Eternal Life
  11. Falling “fortresses”
  12. Finanzmarktorientiertes Umweltmanagement
  13. Predictors of Principals' Engagement in School Health Promotion
  14. Error Orientation Questionnaire (EOQ)
  15. Does cognitive behaviour therapy have an enduring effect that is superior to keeping patients on continuation pharmacotherapy?
  16. Investigation of geometrical features on mechanical properties of AA2198 refill friction stir spot welds
  17. Historical emissions of octachlorodibenzodioxin in a watershed in Queensland, Australia
  18. Common Commercial Policy and External Trade
  19. Effects of Gd solutes on hardness and yield strength of Mg alloys
  20. Demokratie und Differenz - Ein Beispiel, Demokratie zu gestalten
  21. RE/viewing Jerusalem
  22. Ideologie
  23. Gewerblicher Grundstückshandel (Kommentierung des BFH-Urteils vom 05.12.2002, IV R 57/01), Fach 3 EStG, § 15
  24. Musik in transkulturellen Kontexten
  25. The Relationship Between the Environmental and Economic Performance of Firms
  26. Abschied von gestern
  27. The digital disruption of strategic paths
  28. PharmCycle
  29. Beschleunigung als soziales Problem
  30. Empirical Identification of Corporate Environmental Strategies
  31. Sprechsport
  32. Islamophobia without Muslims? The "contact Hypothesis" as an Explanation for Anti-Muslim Attitudes - Eastern European Societies in a Comparative Perspective
  33. Naturschutzrecht
  34. Qualitätssicherung der Tätigkeit des unabhängigen Finanzexperten
  35. Ziele der Partizipation von Kindern und Jugendlichen
  36. Im Epochenlosen
  37. Self-organized learning in vocational education
  38. A never ending story - Entwicklungen in der Frauenhausarbeit
  39. Pantomimisches Lernen in der Grundschule
  40. Normative Begründung der Nachhaltigkeitsökonomie
  41. Parlamentarismus
  42. Thermal cycling and creep studies of AM50+Nd magnesium alloy based carbon fiber, SiC particulate and IN-SITU Mg2Si reinforced hybrid composites