Measuring institutional overlap in global governance

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Over the past decade, an increasingly sophisticated literature has sought to capture the nature, sources, and consequences of a novel empirical phenomenon in world politics: the growing complexity of global governance. However, this literature has paid only limited attention to questions of measurement, which is a prerequisite for a more comprehensive understanding of global governance complexity across space and time. In taking a first step in this direction, we make two contributions in the article. First, we propose new quantitative measures that gauge the extent of complexity in global governance, which we conceptualize as the degree to which global governance institutions overlap. Dyadic, weighted, directed-dyadic, and monadic measures enable a multifaceted understanding of this important development in world politics. Second, we illustrate these measures by applying them to an updated version of the most comprehensive data set on the design of intergovernmental organizations (IGOs): the Measure of International Authority (MIA). This allows us to identify cross-sectional and temporal patterns in the extent to which important IGOs, which tend to form the core of sprawling regime complexes in many issue areas, overlap. We conclude by outlining notable implications for, and potential applications of, our measures for research on institutional design and evolution, legitimacy, and legitimation, as well as effectiveness and performance. This discussion underscores the utility of the proposed measures, as both dependent and independent variables, to researchers examining the sources and consequences of institutional overlap in global governance and beyond.

Original languageEnglish
JournalReview of International Organizations
Volume17
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)323-347
Number of pages25
ISSN1559-7431
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.04.2022

Bibliographical note

The order of authors is chosen alphabetically. Author contributions to writing and conceptual development: Y.H. (50%), T.L. (50%); measurement and empirical analysis: Y.H. (80%), T.L. (20%); theoretical implications: Y.H. (20%), T.L. (80%). Research for this article was generously supported by the Ministry of Science and Culture of Lower Saxony’s Research Cooperation Lower Saxony – Israel grant. We thank Mette Eilstrup-Sangiovanni, Benjamin Faude, Stephanie Hofmann, Oliver Westerwinter, Michael Zürn, the participants at a panel of the German Political Science Association International Relations Section conference, Freiburg, October 2020, and the anonymous reviewers for helpful comments and suggestions. A special thanks is due to Liesbet Hooghe who proposed the idea of writing a measurement article on institutional overlap. We also thank Dan Eran and Mona Saleh for valuable research assistance.

    Research areas

  • Global governance, International organizations, Overlap, Regime complexity
  • Politics

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The science-policy interface on ecosystems and people
  2. Piketty und die Rechtswissenschaft im 21. Jahrhundert
  3. Sekem – Humanistic Management in the Egyptian Dessert
  4. Plant invasions into mountains and alpine ecosystems
  5. Friedrich Kittler und der »Mißbrauch von Heeresgerät«
  6. The economic insurance value of ecosystem resilience
  7. Wissenschaftstheoretische und methodische Grundlagen
  8. How Participatory Should Environmental Governance Be?
  9. Praxisleitfaden Internationales Steuerrecht 2004/2005
  10. Gentelligent Factory Structures and Assembly Control
  11. European Yearbook of International Economic Law 2022
  12. The Theory and Processes of Citizen Entrepreneurship
  13. Arbeitszufriedenheit in Weiterbildungsorganisationen
  14. An advanced measure of moral sensitivity in business
  15. Transdisciplinary research in sustainability science
  16. Between political protest and tourism gentrification
  17. Why gender matters for addressing chemical pollution
  18. Praxisleitfaden Internationales Steuerrecht 2005/2006
  19. Wörter im Gebrauch lernen: Fachwortschatz Mathematik
  20. Microstructural investigations of the Mg-Sn-xCa system
  21. The economics of biodiversity and ecosystem services
  22. Bilderwanderungen. Umberto Boccionis memorialer Atlas
  23. Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung zum Thema „Wasser“
  24. Liberalism, postmaterialism, and the growth of freedom
  25. Südafrika: ein führender Rohstoffproduzent im Umbruch
  26. D2R2 2024: Linked Data-driven Resilience Research 2024
  27. Eigenschaften von Kunststoffen – ein Stationenbetrieb
  28. Prozessqualität oder pädagogische Beziehungsqualität
  29. Implications between education and familial policies
  30. Kompetenzentwicklung im Kontext von Ethik und Konsum
  31. European Yearbook of International Economic Law 2023