Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision

Research output: Working paperWorking papers

Standard

Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision. / Gallier, Carlo; Goeschl, Timo; Kesternich, Martin et al.
Mannheim: ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH, 2017. (ZEW - Discussion Papers; Vol. 17-012).

Research output: Working paperWorking papers

Harvard

Gallier, C, Goeschl, T, Kesternich, M, Lohse, J, Reif, C & Römer, D 2017 'Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision' ZEW - Discussion Papers, vol. 17-012, ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH, Mannheim. <https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:180-madoc-421631>

APA

Gallier, C., Goeschl, T., Kesternich, M., Lohse, J., Reif, C., & Römer, D. (2017). Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision. (ZEW - Discussion Papers; Vol. 17-012). ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH. https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:180-madoc-421631

Vancouver

Gallier C, Goeschl T, Kesternich M, Lohse J, Reif C, Römer D. Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision. Mannheim: ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH. 2017 Feb 22. (ZEW - Discussion Papers).

Bibtex

@techreport{cd3c13f4015440d8877acfed02512e1b,
title = "Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision",
abstract = "Many public goods can be provided at different spatial levels. Evidence from socialidentity theory and in-group favoritism raises the possibility that where higher-level provision is more efficient, subjects{\textquoteright} narrow concern for local outcomes (parochialism) could harm efficiency. Building on the experimental paradigm of multi-level public good games and the {\textquoteleft}neighborhood attachment{\textquoteright} concept, we conduct an artefactual field experiment with 600 participants in a setting conducive to parochial behavior. In an inter-neighborhood intraregion design, subjects allocate an endowment between a personal account, a local, and a regional public good account. The between-subjects design varies across two dimensions: One informs subjects that the smaller local group consists of members from their own neighborhood ({\textquoteleft}neighbors{\textquoteright}). The other varies the relative productivity at the two public goods provision levels. We find evidence for parochialism, but contrary to our hypothesis, parochialism does not interfere with efficiency: The average subject responds to a change in relative productivities at the local and regional level in the same way, whether aware of their neighbors{\textquoteright} presence in the small group or not. The results even hold for subjects with above-median neighborhood attachment and subjects primed on neighborhood attachment.",
keywords = "Artefactual field experiment, Multi-level public goods, Parochialism, Social identity, Economics",
author = "Carlo Gallier and Timo Goeschl and Martin Kesternich and Johannes Lohse and Christiane Reif and Daniel R{\"o}mer",
note = "Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2019 Elsevier B.V.",
year = "2017",
month = feb,
day = "22",
language = "English",
series = "ZEW - Discussion Papers",
publisher = "ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH",
address = "Germany",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH",

}

RIS

TY - UNPB

T1 - Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision

AU - Gallier, Carlo

AU - Goeschl, Timo

AU - Kesternich, Martin

AU - Lohse, Johannes

AU - Reif, Christiane

AU - Römer, Daniel

N1 - Publisher Copyright: © 2019 Elsevier B.V.

PY - 2017/2/22

Y1 - 2017/2/22

N2 - Many public goods can be provided at different spatial levels. Evidence from socialidentity theory and in-group favoritism raises the possibility that where higher-level provision is more efficient, subjects’ narrow concern for local outcomes (parochialism) could harm efficiency. Building on the experimental paradigm of multi-level public good games and the ‘neighborhood attachment’ concept, we conduct an artefactual field experiment with 600 participants in a setting conducive to parochial behavior. In an inter-neighborhood intraregion design, subjects allocate an endowment between a personal account, a local, and a regional public good account. The between-subjects design varies across two dimensions: One informs subjects that the smaller local group consists of members from their own neighborhood (‘neighbors’). The other varies the relative productivity at the two public goods provision levels. We find evidence for parochialism, but contrary to our hypothesis, parochialism does not interfere with efficiency: The average subject responds to a change in relative productivities at the local and regional level in the same way, whether aware of their neighbors’ presence in the small group or not. The results even hold for subjects with above-median neighborhood attachment and subjects primed on neighborhood attachment.

AB - Many public goods can be provided at different spatial levels. Evidence from socialidentity theory and in-group favoritism raises the possibility that where higher-level provision is more efficient, subjects’ narrow concern for local outcomes (parochialism) could harm efficiency. Building on the experimental paradigm of multi-level public good games and the ‘neighborhood attachment’ concept, we conduct an artefactual field experiment with 600 participants in a setting conducive to parochial behavior. In an inter-neighborhood intraregion design, subjects allocate an endowment between a personal account, a local, and a regional public good account. The between-subjects design varies across two dimensions: One informs subjects that the smaller local group consists of members from their own neighborhood (‘neighbors’). The other varies the relative productivity at the two public goods provision levels. We find evidence for parochialism, but contrary to our hypothesis, parochialism does not interfere with efficiency: The average subject responds to a change in relative productivities at the local and regional level in the same way, whether aware of their neighbors’ presence in the small group or not. The results even hold for subjects with above-median neighborhood attachment and subjects primed on neighborhood attachment.

KW - Artefactual field experiment

KW - Multi-level public goods

KW - Parochialism

KW - Social identity

KW - Economics

M3 - Working papers

T3 - ZEW - Discussion Papers

BT - Leveling up? An inter-neighborhood experiment on parochialism and the efficiency of multi-level public goods provision

PB - ZEW - Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research GmbH

CY - Mannheim

ER -

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Does participation benefit the environment? Insights from a meta analysis of 259 cases of public environmental decision-making
  2. Künstlerische Forschung an Hochschulen: Aushandlungen zwischen Theorie und Praxis und Modell einer performativen Wissenspraxis
  3. Workshop zur Konstituierung des Instituts für transdisziplinäre Sozialwissenschaft der Pädagogische Hochschule Karlsruhe -2013
  4. Wissens-und Forschungspolitiken in den Künsten –Die Institutionalisierung von künstlerischer Forschung im deutschsprachigen Raum
  5. Harnessing Competition, Protecting Solidarity: A Comparison of Health Care Markets in Germany, Great Britain, and the United States
  6. Critical Artistic Interventions in Urban Contexts – The Intrinsic Logic or Spirit of Cities and Its Influence on Critical Artists
  7. Von Kollektiven und Einzelkämpfer:innen – Zu den Auswirkungen der Ökonomisierung auf Akteur:innen stationärer Kinder- und Jugendhilfe
  8. “You wanna be on top?” – (Critical) Findings of a Transcultural Television Analysis of America's Next Top Model and Germany's next Topmodel
  9. Presentation of the paper entitled "Soft Optimal Computing to Identify Surface Roughness in Manufacturing using a Monotonic Regressor"
  10. „Laudatio für Richard Sennett“. am 3.7.2013, an der Leuphana Universität, anlässlich der Verleihung der Ehrendoktorwürde an Richard Sennett
  11. Academic Committee of the China’s Research Center for Economic Transition an der Beijing University of Technology (Externe Organisation)
  12. Markenkonzept Weserbergland Imageanalyse - Positionierung - Marketing- und Kommunikationsmittelanalyse - Aufgabenteilung und Organisation.
  13. Stretching, shrinking, shape-shifting: a processual and communication-centred perspective on the elasticity and boundedness of organization
  14. Developing Strategies Against the Risks of Severe Storm Surges: Opportunities for the Integration of Different Stakeholder Perspectives
  15. Genetic markers and climate niche models indicate glacial refugia for the flightless ground beetle Carabus sylvestris north of the Alps
  16. “Take Things Easy First” or “Get Straight to The Point”? The Order of Issue Packages in Negotiation and Its Effect on Dyadic Economic Outcomes.
  17. (Mündliche) Interaktion von Englischlernenden im Rahmen eines Englischsprachigen Escape Games (Jgst. 10): Eine triangulative Mixed-Method Studie.
  18. 'Regionale Bildungsnetzwerke' in 'Lernenden Regionen': Pädagogische Raummetaphorik in aktuellen Slogans der Bildungspolitik und Bildungsplanung

Publications

  1. Produktive Funktionen von Kollaps und Zerstörung für gesellschaftliche Transformationsprozesse in Richtung Nachhaltigkeit
  2. Towards sustainable land uses within the Elbe river biosphere reserve in Lower Saxony, Germany by means of TerraSAR-X images
  3. Handlungsmöglichkeiten zur Minderung des Eintrags von Humanarzneimitteln und ihren Rückständen in das Roh- und Trinkwasser
  4. Impulsando estrategias colectivas ciencia-gestión-sociedad para conservar el hábitat de Ziziphus lotus (Hábitat Prioritario 5220)
  5. Zusammenhänge und Kinetik biotischer und abiotischer Eisenoxidation bei der Brunnenverockerung und Ansätze zur Modellierung
  6. Der Einfluss der Zweitsprache auf den Fremdensprachenerwerb am Beispiel des Russischen bei weißrussischen Deutschlernenden
  7. Untersuchungen zur Bewertung des Adsorptionsverhaltens heterocyclischer PAK auf Aktivkohle in teeölbelasteten Grundwässern
  8. Handbuch interkulturelle Kommunikation und Kooperation, Bd. 1, Grundlagen und Praxisfelder, mit 14 Tabellen, Alexander Thomas ... (Hg.)
  9. Human–learning–machines: introduction to a special section on how cybernetics and constructivism inspired new forms of learning
  10. The Video Game Industry: Formation, Present State, and Future, Peter Zackariasson and Timothy Wilson (eds) (2012) New York: Routledge
  11. Use of design methods, team leaders' goal orientation, and team effectiveness: A follow-up study in software development projects
  12. Fostering preservice teachers’ noticing with structured video feedback: Results of an online- and video-based intervention study
  13. Mediatisierte Politikgestaltung? Medien, Expertise und politische Entscheidungsprozesse in wissenschaftsbasierten Themenfeldern
  14. Die Rolle von Unternehmensdialogen im gesellschaftlichen Diskurs über umstrittene Technikentwicklungen: Der „InfoDialog Fracking“
  15. Lernaufgaben zum Interkulturellen Lernen im Spanischunterricht: der deutsch-kolumbianische Film ‚Dr. Alemán’ in der Sekundarstufe II
  16. Integrative Bewertung der Auswirkungen touristischer Nutzungen auf die Bereitstellung der Ecosystem Services auf der Insel Sylt
  17. Optimal regulation for dynamic hybrid systems based on dynamic programming in the case of an intelligent vehicle drive assistant
  18. Subjektive Theorien und biographische Erfahrungen im Professionalisierungsprozess von Lehrkräften – am Beispiel von Umweltbildung
  19. Reducing the peaking phenomenon in Luenberger observers in presence of quasi-static disturbances for linear time invariant systems
  20. Dialogorientierte Nachhaltigkeitsberichterstattung von Hochschulen : eine Untersuchung am Beispiel der Leuphana-Universität Lüneburg
  21. Videobasierte Professionalisierung von angehenden Lehrkräften für die Gestaltung inklusiven naturwissenschaftlichen Sachunterrichts
  22. What influences environmental entrepreneurship? A multilevel analysis of the determinants of entrepreneurs’ environmental orientation
  23. Orientierende Untersuchungen von NSO-Heterocyclen in niedersächsischen Oberflächengewässern – Betrachtung von Sediment und Wasserphase
  24. Patrick Glockner-Pilz und Patrick S. Föhl (Hrsg.): Handbuch Kulturpublikum. Forschungsfragen und Befunde. Wiesbaden (Springer) 2016, 655 Seiten.
  25. Partitioning Behavior of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Compounds between Pore Water and Sediment in Two Sediment Cores from Tokyo Bay, Japan
  26. Voyeurism? Autobiographies by Children of the Perpetrators. Niklas Frank's: Der Vater. Eine Abrechnung (1987), and Meine deutsche Mutter (2005)
  27. Photo-degradation of the antimicrobial ciprofloxacin at high pH: identification and biodegradability assessment of the primary by-products
  28. Permeable Reactive Barriers (PRBs) for Ground Water Remediation at Contaminated Former Manufactured Gasworks Plants (MGPs) and Related Sites
  29. Effekte unterschiedlicher Kollaborationsskripte in chatbasiertem Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning am Beispiel von Lernprotokollen