It's Not What You Know, It's How You Use It: The Application of Country of Origin Information in Judicial Refugee Status Determination Decisions - A Case Study of Germany

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Existing research has emphasized the different forms of expert knowledge available to refugee status determination (RSD) decision makers, as well as the differing conditions under which it is produced. However, little work has been done to address how decision makers interpret, represent, and use such evidence in their written decisions. This study investigates how country of origin information (COI) is used in judicial RSD decisions, taking decisions of Germany's Higher Administrative Courts on Syrian draft evaders as a case study. The analysis shows that the courts draw different conclusions from the same evidence, utilizing interpretation, framing, and citation styles to amplify or dampen the persuasive force of COI in their reasoning. As such, legal reasoning dominates evidence, meaning that evidence is discursively highly malleable, frequently incidental to legal reasoning, and does not produce legal consensus. These findings raise concerns that decision makers use COI selectively to justify the positions they have adopted, rather than allowing their conclusions to be directed by COI. The article concludes by reflecting on what, if anything, should be done about these seemingly opaque and unaccountable textual and discursive forms of discretionary power.

Original languageEnglish
JournalInternational Journal of Refugee Law
Volume34
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)241-267
Number of pages27
ISSN0953-8186
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2022
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2022 The Author(s). Published by Oxford University Press.

    Research areas

  • Law

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Visualizations of projected rainfall change in the United Kingdom
  2. Governance approaches to address scale issues in biodiversity management – current situation and ways forward
  3. Comparison of different in vitro tests for biocompatibility screening of Mg alloys
  4. Siedlungsqualität, Wohnqualität
  5. Single photoproduction of η-mesons of hydrogen in the forward direction at 4 and 6 GeV
  6. Evaluation and sustaining factors of machidukuri groups organized in relation with the 'hope plan'
  7. Gender in die Bildung !
  8. The structure of contributing factors of human error in safety-critical industries
  9. Principles for knowledge co-production in sustainability research
  10. Ob man etwas tun kann oder nicht, ist eine rein mechanische oder materielle Frage
  11. Underestimation of personal carbon footprint inequality in four diverse countries
  12. Leuphana Semester: ESD professional development module on Responsibility and Sustainability, Germany
  13. Organizing Colour
  14. Theodor Fontane, das Fremde und die Juden
  15. DaZKom – Professional Competencies of Pre-Service Teachers for Secondary Education in the Field of German as a Second Language
  16. Geschlechtsspezifische Perspektiven auf das Unternehmertum
  17. Fostering inclusive teaching competences
  18. Three source-partitioning of CO2 fluxes based on a dual-isotope approach to investigate interactions between soil organic carbon, glucose and straw
  19. Network access charges, vertical integration, and property rights structure-experiences from the German electricity markets
  20. Realizing the full potential of behavioural science for climate change mitigation
  21. Adjustments of Wage-Tenure Profiles with Respect to Entry Age
  22. Academic self-concept and causal attributions for success and failure amongst elementary school children
  23. The Whiteness of Wealth Management
  24. Colour and Organization Studies
  25. Preparing Pre-service Teachers for Inclusive Education
  26. Situative bewegungssimulation des zweibeinigen, parallelkinematischen schreitroboters centaurob