Greene’s dual-process moral psychology and the modularity of mind

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Joshua Greene has famously argued for two distinct processes of how humans make moral judgments. Despite a lively controversy around potential normative implications of this view, less attention has been paid to those philosophical assumptions that are fundamental to Greene’s dual-process theory itself. In this paper, I argue that Greene’s dual-process theory hinges on a modular account of cognition and the brain, and I critically discuss the plausibility of Greene’s view in light of increasing popularity of dynamical systems accounts in cognitive science. If we reject modularity and adopt a dynamical systems perspective instead, we can still hope to find relative differences in the functional specialization of dynamic brain networks within one interconnected system, but Greene’s original theory in terms of two asymmetrically independent processes will no longer be tenable. This imposes constraints on the kind of explanations that we can expect from an empirically informed ethics in that only non-exclusive dual-process theories would be compatible with a dynamical systems account. Ultimately, however, the controversy around the modularity of mind should not be misconceived as a purely empirical question, but rather as a matter of conflicting epistemic standards as to what qualifies as a good explanation in cognitive science.

Original languageEnglish
JournalPhilosophical Psychology
Number of pages24
ISSN0951-5089
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.

    Research areas

  • brain networks, Dual-process, dynamical systems theory, empirical ethics, modularity, moral judgment
  • Psychology

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. On the problematics between Eastern Germany and Western Germany
  2. Optimal dynamic scale and structure of a multi-pollution economy
  3. Measurement of ammonia emissions in multi-plot field experiments
  4. Support from the Internet for Individuals with Mental Disorders
  5. Castability of some magnesium alloys in a novel castability die
  6. One-Man Think Tank. Herman Kahn, oder wie man das Undenkbare denkt
  7. Heike Kahlert, Claudia Lenz (Hrsg.): Neubestimmungen des Politischen
  8. Entwicklung der Zeitwertbilanzierung im Handels- und Steuerrecht
  9. Strategisches Modellieren durch heuristische Lösungsbeispiele :
  10. Temporal changes in vertebrates during landscape transformation
  11. Wissenschaft und Öffentlichkeit im Zeichen der Digitalisierung
  12. Key aspects of a sustainable health insurance system in Germany
  13. Öffentliche Kommunikation überKlimawandel und Sturmflutrisiken
  14. Kultura, technika, kulturni technika: Proti diskursivizaci kultury
  15. Schuhhaus Görtz: Blended Learning für die Modetrends von morgen
  16. Leveraging LLMs in Scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering
  17. The influence of Reputation on Travel Decisions in the Internet
  18. Kombinierte Firmenpaneldaten: Datenangebot und Analysepotenziale
  19. Uncertainty, Pluralism, and the Knowledge-based Theory of the Firm
  20. Environmental commitments and rhetoric over the Pandemic crisis
  21. Phasing-out Coal in Germany – Not Only, But Also a Legal Challenge
  22. Steuerliche Rahmenbedingungen für Private Equity in Deutschland
  23. Low Resource Question Answering: An Amharic Benchmarking Dataset
  24. Symbolische und pikturale Wirksamkeit bei Lévi-Strauss und Lacan
  25. Green chemistry and its contribution to industrial biotechnology
  26. Tracking the fate of aluminium in the eu using the matrace model