Evolutionary Precursors of Negation in Non-Human Reasoning

Research output: Contributions to collected editions/worksChapter

Authors

Logical reasoning has been argued to crucially depend on linguistic or symbolic representations. This suggests that animals are incapable of negation. Nevertheless, animals have been found to behave in ways that suggest reasoning by negation. This chapter discusses the findings from the animal cognition literature in light of theoretical accounts of negation based on propositional and non-propositional thought. Instead of engaging in negation proper, animals might engage in proto-negation, that is reasoning based on contrary pairs instead of negated propositions. While most of the current findings might be explained in terms of proto-negation, an accumulation of evidence might eventually render negation proper a more parsimonious explanation of the evidence. The chapter concludes with suggestions for future avenues of research and a discussion of the role of negation in the evolution of human reasoning.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Oxford Handbook of Negation
EditorsViviane Deprez, M. Teresa Espinal
Number of pages12
PublisherOxford University Press
Publication date07.05.2020
Pages577-588
ISBN (print)9780198830528
ISBN (electronic)9780191868719
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 07.05.2020
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Psychology - negation, propositional thought, evolution, animal cognition, metacognition, social cognition, communication

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Krieg in der Zivilgesellschaft
  2. Business ethics and management development
  3. Proserpina
  4. Country-level and individual-level predictors of men's support for gender equality in 42 countries
  5. Kulturell geprägte Konventionen des Sprachgebrauchs
  6. External Influences on Regionalism
  7. Smart Metering und die Liberalisierung des Messwesens
  8. Gute Arbeit im Mittelstand
  9. Buchenwälder und Klimawandel
  10. Von der Theorie zur Erfahrung
  11. Trends Towards Pure Leisure
  12. Ethik
  13. Castability of magnesium alloys
  14. Ontologiebasierte Repräsentation von Integrationsprofilen
  15. In situ air-water and particle-water partitioning of perfluorocarboxylic acids, perfluorosulfonic acids and perfluorooctyl sulfonamide at a wastewater treatment plant
  16. Cultural Heritage and the Rejuvenation of Spa Towns
  17. Spiele(n) mit geringsten Mitteln
  18. Social-Ecological Functional Types
  19. Fremdsprachendidaktiker im Furioso
  20. Entrepreneurial Investing
  21. Was bewirken sprachliche Variationen von Aufgabenkontexten für das Schreiben von argumentativen Schülertexten?
  22. Indicated Prevention
  23. Kompositionseffekte bei der Notenvergabe in Mathematik auf der 4. Schulstufe der österreichischen Volksschule
  24. Zwei Welten
  25. When Matter Becomes an Active Agent
  26. Law and Gospel
  27. Sozialer Dialog in der Krise - Social dialogue in crisis?
  28. Artful and sensory sustainability science: Exploring novel methodological perspectives
  29. Die Rohstoff-Expedition
  30. Seeds of good anthropocenes: developing sustainability scenarios for Northern Europe
  31. Die Farbbeutel-Rede Joschka Fischers
  32. Training zur erhöhung der Eigeninitiative bei Arbeitslosen
  33. Wer? Wie? Was? Analyse didaktischer Materialien für Popmusik in der Grundschule
  34. Schriftspracherwerb empirisch
  35. Plant communities of the summits of the Dund Saykhan mountain range (Southern Mongolia)
  36. Katja Siekmann (Hrsg.) Theorie, Empirie und Praxis effektiver Rechtschreibdiagnostik
  37. "Soziale und ethnische Mischung" - zur Persistenz eines wohnungspolitischen Leitbildes