Antiandrogen or estradiol treatment or both during hormone therapy in transitioning transgender women

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • Claudia Haupt
  • Miriam Henke
  • Alexia Kutschmar
  • Birgit Hauser
  • Sandra Baldinger
  • Sarah Rafaela Saenz
  • Gerhard Schreiber

Background: Gender dysphoria is described as a mismatch between an individual's experienced or expressed gender and their assigned gender, based on primary or secondary sexual characteristics. Gender dysphoria can be associated with clinically significant psychological distress and may result in a desire to change sexual characteristics. The process of adapting a person's sexual characteristics to their desired sex is called ‘transition.'. Current guidelines suggest hormonal and, if needed, surgical intervention to aid transition in transgender women, i.e. persons who aim to transition from male to female. In adults, hormone therapy aims to reverse the body's male attributes and to support the development of female attributes. It usually includes estradiol, antiandrogens, or a combination of both. Many individuals first receive hormone therapy alone, without surgical interventions. However, this is not always sufficient to change such attributes as facial bone structure, breasts, and genitalia, as desired. For these transgender women, surgery may then be used to support transition. Objectives: We aimed to assess the efficacy and safety of hormone therapy with antiandrogens, estradiol, or both, compared to each other or placebo, in transgender women in transition. Search methods: We searched MEDLINE, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Embase, Biosis Preview, PsycINFO, and PSYNDEX. We carried out our final searches on 19 December 2019. Selection criteria: We aimed to include randomised controlled trials (RCTs), quasi-RCTs, and cohort studies that enrolled transgender women, age 16 years and over, in transition from male to female. Eligible studies investigated antiandrogen and estradiol hormone therapies alone or in combination, in comparison to another form of the active intervention, or placebo control. Data collection and analysis: We used standard methodological procedures expected by Cochrane to establish study eligibility. Main results: Our database searches identified 1057 references, and after removing duplicates we screened 787 of these. We checked 13 studies for eligibility at the full text screening stage. We excluded 12 studies and identified one as an ongoing study. We did not identify any completed studies that met our inclusion criteria. The single ongoing study is an RCT conducted in Thailand, comparing estradiol valerate plus cyproterone treatment with estradiol valerate plus spironolactone treatment. The primary outcome will be testosterone level at three month follow-up. Authors' conclusions: We found insufficient evidence to determine the efficacy or safety of hormonal treatment approaches for transgender women in transition. This lack of studies shows a gap between current clinical practice and clinical research. Robust RCTs and controlled cohort studies are needed to assess the benefits and harms of hormone therapy (used alone or in combination) for transgender women in transition. Studies should specifically focus on short-, medium-, and long-term adverse effects, quality of life, and participant satisfaction with the change in male to female body characteristics of antiandrogen and estradiol therapy alone, and in combination. They should also focus on the relative effects of these hormones when administered orally, transdermally, and intramuscularly. We will include non-controlled cohort studies in the next iteration of this review, as our review has shown that such studies provide the highest quality evidence currently available in the field. We will take into account methodological limitations when doing so.

Original languageEnglish
Article numberCD013138
JournalCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
Volume2020
Issue number11
Number of pages22
ISSN1361-6137
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 28.11.2020
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2020 The Cochrane Collaboration. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Valuing beaches for beauty and recreation only? Uncovering perception bias through a hashtag analysis
  2. Schooling, Identity, and Nationhood: Karen Mother-Tongue-Based Education in the Thai–Burmese Border Region
  3. MICSIM: Concept, Developments, and Applications of a PC Microsimulation Model for Research and Teaching
  4. Internationales Projektmanagement in der interkulturellen Forschung – am Beispiel des Projektes iGOES
  5. From a problem to a business opportunity-design of pharmaceuticals for environmental biodegradability
  6. Das religionspädagogische Leitbild der Kinder- und Jugendtheologie in kontingenzsensibler Perspektive
  7. Unternehmerisches Biodiversitätsmanagement - Sicherung der Vielfalt und des wirtschaftlichen Erfolgs
  8. Trading many goods with many countries: Exporters and importers from German manufacturing industries
  9. Reconciling Intragenerational and intergenerational environmental justice in Philippine agriculture
  10. Michael Hoffmann. 2017. Stil und Text. Eine Einführung (Narr Studienbücher). Tübingen: Narr/Francke/Attempto
  11. Intelligent Diagnostics of Radial Internal Clearance in Ball Bearings with Machine Learning Methods
  12. Funktionsbedingungen der neuen Beschäftigungsverhältnisse - eine verhaltenswissenschaftliche Analyse?
  13. Environmental drivers interactively affect individual tree growth across temperate European forests
  14. Entwicklung eines deutschsprachigen Fragebogens zur Erfassung des Glaubens an den freien Willen (WiF)
  15. Embracing conflicts for interpersonal competence development in project-based sustainability courses
  16. Wer möchte im Ruhestand weiterarbeiten?: Muster von Weiterbeschäftigungsneigungen bei 55- 70-Jährigen
  17. The feeling thinking talking intervention with teachers advances young children's emotion knowledge
  18. The COVID-19 pandemic as an disruptive event in school health promotion. Survey results from Germany
  19. Quantum chemical calculation of the vapor pressure of volatile and semi volatile organic compounds
  20. On the granularity of the German economy - first evidence from the top 100 companies panel database
  21. Nachhaltigen Konsum fördern durch partizipative Interventionsentwicklung in Bildungseinrichtungen
  22. Marginal Calluna populations are more resistant to climate change, but not under high-nitrogen loads
  23. Dynamic adjustment of dispatching rule parameters in flow shops with sequence-dependent set-up times
  24. Corporate Climate Reporting of European Banks: Are these institutions compliant with climate issues?
  25. Bleibt alles anders!? Sozialformen, Unterrichtsphasen und echte Lernzeit im kaufmännischen Unterricht
  26. Bernd Schorb/Helga Theunert (Hrsg.):"Ein bisschen wählen dürfen..." Jugend - Politik - Fernsehen. - München, 2000
  27. A framework for disentangling ecological mechanisms underlying the island species–area relationship
  28. A feedback model combining individual and organizational determinants of small business innovation
  29. A community of shared values? Dimensions and dynamics of cultural integration in the European Union
  30. »Was wäre, wenn?« Zum Nutzen kontrafaktischer Analyse in der (historischen) Soziologie am Beispiel 1989
  31. Was Naturwissenschaftsdidaktiken und Religionspädagogik voneinander über Inklusion lernen können
  32. Verknüpfungen, Zielkonflikte und Synergien der Nachhaltigkeitsziele für die Lehre fruchtbar machen
  33. Transformation products in the water cycle and the unsolved problem of their proactive assessment
  34. Teaching personal initiative beats traditional training in boosting small business in West Africa
  35. Some model properties to control a permanent magnet machine using a controlled invariant subspace
  36. Ruins of Excess
  37. Nom Kommentar zur Bildkritik. Goethes Erzählung «Die guten Frauen, als Gegenbilder der bösen Weiber»
  38. Mathematische Leistungssteigerung und Förderung berufsbezogener Motivation über die Sommerferien
  39. Kunstkammer, Ostasiatische Weltkunst, Expressionistische Avantgarde neben Rokoko und Bauhaus-Moderne.
  40. Is ecotourism a panacea? Political ecology perspectives from the Sundarban Biosphere Reserve, India
  41. Incremental contribution of pollination and other ecosystem services to agricultural productivity
  42. How perfect is (too) perfect? Illuminating why the perfectionism-performance-relationship is (non-)linear
  43. "Der siebente Brunnen". Fred Wanders Versuch einer anderen Darstellung der Shoah in der DDR-Literatur
  44. Concluding remarks: Meet the future—with International Business Administration and Entrepreneurship
  45. Automated Invoice Processing: Machine Learning-Based Information Extraction for Long Tail Suppliers
  46. Application of Adaptive Element-Free Galerkin Method to Simulate Friction Stir Welding of Aluminum