TY - JOUR

T1 - Small-scale soil patterns drive sharp boundaries between succulent "dwarf" biomes (or habitats) in the arid Succulent Karoo, South Africa

AU - Schmiedel, Ute

AU - Kühne, N.

AU - Twerski, Alina

AU - Oldeland, J.

N1 - Research concept and design was developed by US and JO, data collected by NK and AT under the supervision of US, and data analysis by AT, NK, and JO. Text was largely drafted by US with input by all co-authors. The study was based on AT's and NK's BSc-theses at Hamburg University. We would like to express our gratitude to the permit office of CapeNature for issuing the research permit, the team of Mr. Adrian Fortuin at the Vanrhynsdorp Office of CapeNature for their invaluable support of the field work with logistics and accommodation. Anton Höfter provided a wonderful environment for US's writing retreat in Bad Tölz. Will Simonson checked the manuscript linguistically and Alastair Potts helped with the layout of Fig. 3 . The German Ministry for Education and Research (BMBF) sponsored the research activity, which forms part of task 159 of Southern African Science Service Centre for Climate Change and Adaptive Land Management (SASSCAL) (BMBF Reference no. 01 LG0905A ). The Deutsch Kakteen Gesellschaft (DKG) provided financial support for the field work in the Knersvlakte of AT and NK.

PY - 2015/11/1

Y1 - 2015/11/1

N2 - Quartz fields, which are densely covered by angular quartz gravel, represent edaphically special habitats in the Succulent Karoo, a winter rainfall desert in South Africa. They are home to an endemic flora and vegetation communities that show strong species turnover at their boundaries. We interpret the vegetation changes along these boundaries as analogous to biome boundaries: a functional shift is accompanied by a change in structure. Our study aims to identify which abiotic variables are associated with the abrupt shift in species and life form composition at the boundaries and whether these variables change as abruptly as the species composition.We studied 56 transects of 6 × 1 m2 plots across eight boundary types (6-9 replicate transects per type) between six different habitats (namely, two acidic quartz fields, two saline quartz fields, zonal habitat types and heuweltjies). For each plot, we sampled soil texture, soil pH, electrical conductivity, and the calcium carbonate content at the soil surface (0-2 cm), as well as soil depth, plant species composition and species richness. We tested for trends in the group means of the abiotic parameters across the different boundary types with a polynomial-contrast ANOVA. We also aggregated the three plots left (1-3) and right (4-6) of the observed vegetation boundary and tested for differences between the mean ranks of the abiotic parameters using a Wilcoxon rank sum test. Abiotic differences were compared to an indicator of the fidelity of species to the vegetation types, identified through an Indicator Species Analysis.All boundary types exhibited a strong trend in either soil pH and/or electrical conductivity. Only in a few cases did calcium carbonate and soil texture also vary across boundary types. The boundary types between the most acidic quartz fields and adjacent vegetation types showed the strongest level of fidelity of species to one of the two habitat types. Acidic quartz fields (pH < 5) were most species-poor and had only one species with a significant indicator value.We discuss the influence of parent material, microtopography, climatic aridity, size of plants, and properties of winter rainfall precipitation on the abrupt difference in soil properties and vegetation patterns. By comparing the soil patterns and plant responses on quartz fields to studies of other edaphically special habitats (e.g., gypsum, serpentine and saltmarsh soils), we argue that some of the morphological features of the dominant taxa (Aizoaceae lineages) may determine their success in these habitats.

AB - Quartz fields, which are densely covered by angular quartz gravel, represent edaphically special habitats in the Succulent Karoo, a winter rainfall desert in South Africa. They are home to an endemic flora and vegetation communities that show strong species turnover at their boundaries. We interpret the vegetation changes along these boundaries as analogous to biome boundaries: a functional shift is accompanied by a change in structure. Our study aims to identify which abiotic variables are associated with the abrupt shift in species and life form composition at the boundaries and whether these variables change as abruptly as the species composition.We studied 56 transects of 6 × 1 m2 plots across eight boundary types (6-9 replicate transects per type) between six different habitats (namely, two acidic quartz fields, two saline quartz fields, zonal habitat types and heuweltjies). For each plot, we sampled soil texture, soil pH, electrical conductivity, and the calcium carbonate content at the soil surface (0-2 cm), as well as soil depth, plant species composition and species richness. We tested for trends in the group means of the abiotic parameters across the different boundary types with a polynomial-contrast ANOVA. We also aggregated the three plots left (1-3) and right (4-6) of the observed vegetation boundary and tested for differences between the mean ranks of the abiotic parameters using a Wilcoxon rank sum test. Abiotic differences were compared to an indicator of the fidelity of species to the vegetation types, identified through an Indicator Species Analysis.All boundary types exhibited a strong trend in either soil pH and/or electrical conductivity. Only in a few cases did calcium carbonate and soil texture also vary across boundary types. The boundary types between the most acidic quartz fields and adjacent vegetation types showed the strongest level of fidelity of species to one of the two habitat types. Acidic quartz fields (pH < 5) were most species-poor and had only one species with a significant indicator value.We discuss the influence of parent material, microtopography, climatic aridity, size of plants, and properties of winter rainfall precipitation on the abrupt difference in soil properties and vegetation patterns. By comparing the soil patterns and plant responses on quartz fields to studies of other edaphically special habitats (e.g., gypsum, serpentine and saltmarsh soils), we argue that some of the morphological features of the dominant taxa (Aizoaceae lineages) may determine their success in these habitats.

KW - Acidic soil

KW - Dwarf plant

KW - Edaphic gradient

KW - Heuweltjies

KW - Knersvlakte

KW - Quartz field

KW - Saline soil

KW - Soil specialist

KW - Winter rainfall

KW - Ecosystems Research

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84961158053&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - https://www.mendeley.com/catalogue/ba0b4f17-1128-3ed1-8f90-9a81e9f6e762/

U2 - 10.1016/j.sajb.2015.05.001

DO - 10.1016/j.sajb.2015.05.001

M3 - Journal articles

AN - SCOPUS:84961158053

VL - 101

SP - 129

EP - 138

JO - South African Journal of Botany

JF - South African Journal of Botany

SN - 0254-6299

ER -