Accuracy and bias of methods used for root length measurements in functional root research

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Functional root traits are becoming a key measure in plant ecology, and root length measurements are needed for the calculation of root traits. Several methods are used to estimate the total root length (TRL) of washed root samples [e.g. modified line intersect (LI) method, WinRHIZOTM and IJ_Rhizo], but no standardized comparison of methods exists. We used a set of digital images of unstained root samples to compare measurements given by the LI method and automated methods provided by WinRHIZOTM and IJ_Rhizo. Linear regression models were used to detect bias. Both linear regression models and the Bland-Altmans` method of differences were used to evaluate the accuracy of eight methods (1 manual, 2 semi-automated and 5 automated) in comparison with a reference method that avoided root detection errors. Length measurements were highly correlated, but did not exactly agree with each other in 11 of 12 method comparisons. All tested methods tended to underestimate the TRL of unstained root samples. The accuracy of WinRHIZOTM was influenced by the thresholding method and the root length density (RLD) in the pictures. For the other methods, no linear relationship was found between accuracy and RLD. With WinRHIZOTM (global thresholding + pixel reclassification; RLD = 1 cm cm-2), the Regent's method and the Tennant's method underestimated the TRL by 7·0 ± 6·2% and 4·7 ± 7·9%, respectively. The LI method gave satisfactory results on average (underestimation: 4·2 ± 6·0%), but our results suggest that it can lead to inaccurate estimations for single images. In IJ_Rhizo, the Kimura method was the best and underestimated the TRL by 5·4 ± 6·1%. Our results showed that care must be taken when comparing measurements acquired with different methods because they can lead to different results. When acquiring root images, we advise to (i) increase the contrast between fine roots and background by staining the roots, and (ii) avoid overlapping roots by not exceeding a RLD of 1 cm cm-2. Under these conditions, good length estimates can be obtained with WinRHIZOTM (global thresholding + pixel reclassification). The Kimura method in IJ_Rhizo can be an alternative to WinRHIZOTM.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftMethods in Ecology and Evolution
Jahrgang8
Ausgabenummer11
Seiten (von - bis)1594-1606
Anzahl der Seiten13
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 11.2017

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Forschende

  1. Felix Westermann

Publikationen

  1. Does board composition have an impact on CSR reporting?
  2. Nitrate Pollution of Groundwater Long Exceeding Trigger Value
  3. Relativity in Social Cognition: Basic processes and novel applications of social comparisons
  4. Making an impression with open strategy
  5. An analysis of the requirements for DSS on integrated river basin management
  6. An Unusual Encounter with Oneself
  7. A review on the use of calcium chloride in applied thermal engineering
  8. The performatization of space
  9. Effects of Soil Properties, Temperature and Disturbance on Diversity and Functional Composition of Plant Communities Along a Steep Elevational Gradient on Tenerife
  10. Schreiben in der Sekundarstufe II
  11. Can management-sponsored non-binding remuneration votes shape the executive compensation structure?
  12. Public value performance
  13. Ownership Patterns and Enterprise Groups in German Structural Business Statistics
  14. Political discourse as mediated and public discourse
  15. Towards a Sustainable Use of Phosphorus
  16. What is the threshold for a clinically relvent effect?
  17. Organization
  18. Where do the data live?
  19. Leveraging LLMs in Scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering
  20. Facing Up to Third Party Liability for Space Activities
  21. Legislating for Outer Space
  22. Computer Support for Environmental Management Accounting
  23. Taking Responsibility for Others and Use of Mental Contrasting
  24. Emotional reactivity and interoceptive sensitivity
  25. Geometrical Accuracy in Two-Stage Incremental Sheet Forming with Active Medium
  26. Evaluation of revitalization policies and redevelopment strategy for residential environment in coal mining areas
  27. Logik
  28. Modeling Turning Points In Global Equity Market
  29. Practices and Policies from Spaces of Possibilities to Institutional Innovations
  30. Fallstudie
  31. Synthesis and future research directions linking tree diversity to growth, survival, and damage in a global network of tree diversity experiments