Encounter at Dynamic Eye Level: 15 Roles Adopted by Actors in Science-Practice Collaborations

Aktivität: Vorträge und GastvorlesungenKonferenzvorträgeForschung

Annaliesa Hilger - Ko-Autor*in

Michael Rose - Präsentator*in

Michael Rose - Ko-Autor*in

Sustainability transitions often require a deep partnership between science and practice. The idea of
such a collaborations is reflected in a growing amount of transdisciplinary and transformative
research processes and corresponding publications. Those processes require from all actors to do
more than simply participate in a workshop or carry out basic or applied research. Consequently, the
debate about the role of science (and research approaches) in society encompass questions on the
roles adopted by different actors within these processes.
Several works elaborate on the roles of researchers within transdisciplinary and transformative
processes; the specific roles for non-scientific partners tend to be neglected, though. This is critical,
as defined roles within these processes could provide the actors in the field with a “vocabulary”,
which facilitates orientation, transparency, and a reflective design of the collaboration.
Our contribution goes beyond the recent approaches of merely considering the perspective of non-
scientific actors or simply explaining the roles of researchers. Instead, we propose a change of
perspective towards considering all the roles potentially required for a fruitful collaborative process
in an integrative manner.
We conduct a systematic literature review to identify papers with precise descriptions of relevant
processes, which contain sufficient information on actors’ activities observed in real-world science-
practice interactions in the realm of sustainability. Following an understanding of roles “as a set of
recognizable activities and attitudes” (Wittmayer, 2016, p. 105), we code all activities observed in the
11 resulting studies (by applying 72 activity codes a total of 549 times). Subsequently, we employ a
hierarchical cluster analysis to help us identify co-occurring activities that can be aggregated into
coherent roles. Sub-clusters of activities are identified by means of a hierarchical cluster analysis,
which we then condensed into 15 roles.
The roles can be categorised in four realms: field, academia, knowledge co-production, and boundary
management. The roles of the Data Supplier, the Field Expert, and the Application Expert are adopted
by actors who are close to the field, whereas the roles of the Scientific Analyst and the Knowledge
Collector are primarily adopted by researchers. Furthermore, roles within the knowledge co-
production process are the Knowledge Co-Producer, the Troublemaker, and the Practice Expert. An
interesting result is the large number of roles within the realm of boundary management (e. g., the
Choreographer, the Communicator, the Facilitator, and the Intermediary), which are primarily, but
not by definition, adopted by researchers. The high number and diversity of roles, especially in the
realm of boundary management, reveals the importance of a comprehensive approach to
coordination, communication, and process design.
In sum, our work not only offers insights into the roles primarily adopted by non-scientific actors, but
also provides a more nuanced and complete picture of the roles played by all actors involved. These
15 roles identified in our work could be useful to consider and assign in td/tr interactions. The paper
thus contributes to clarity in research practice and thereby addresses the conference track on
methodological considerations.
05.10.202108.10.2021

Veranstaltung

12th International Sustainability Transitions Conference - IST 2021

05.10.2108.10.21

Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Baden-Württemberg, Deutschland

Veranstaltung: Konferenz

Zuletzt angesehen

Forschende

  1. Sebastiaan Stiller

Publikationen

  1. The effects of targeted political advertising on user privacy concerns and digital product acceptance
  2. Informal and formal lesson planning in school internships
  3. Transition von Schule zu Hochschule in der Mathematik
  4. Participation as a Mode of Conflict
  5. The Effects of Altruism and Social Background in an Online-Based, Pay-What-You-Want Situation
  6. Tree decline and the future of Australian farmland biodiversity
  7. Emergency Politics After Globalization
  8. Telling your own stories
  9. Determinants of international trade, production, and licensing - Results from econometric studies using firm level data from manufacturing industries in Lower Saxony, Germany
  10. Handwerksreform 2004
  11. Aufbau und Organisation von Entwicklungsprojekten
  12. Variational Pragmatics and World Englishes
  13. Self-Control Following Prior Exertion
  14. Fostering constructive debate: a reply to Chappell et al
  15. Measuring mathematics competence in international and national large scale assessments
  16. Aufbruch
  17. Stock price reactions to climate science information from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
  18. Bridging Restoration Science and Practice
  19. Corrosion behaviour of as-cast ZK40 with CaO and Y additions
  20. B7-H1 Selectively Controls TH17 Differentiation and Central Nervous System Autoimmunity via a Novel Non-PD-1-Mediated Pathway
  21. Phonographic work
  22. Building urban resilience through sustainability‑oriented small‑ and medium‑sized enterprises
  23. A feedback model combining individual and organizational determinants of small business innovation
  24. The efficiency of different online learning media - An empirical study
  25. Introduction to Music and the Politics of Memory
  26. Knowledge sharing for shared success in the decade on ecosystem restoration
  27. Unobtrusive Vital Sign Acquisition in the Domain of AAL
  28. Ecosystem services from forest and farmland