The (Un)intended Consequences of Legal Transplants: A Comparative Study of Standing in Collective Litigation in Five Jurisdictions

Research output: Journal contributionsConference article in journalResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Jasminka Kalajdzic
  • Axel Halfmeier
  • Bernard Murphy
  • Ianika Tzankova
  • Manuel A. Gómez
Deborah R. Hensler has long championed the comparative study of civil procedure in a way that considers the interplay between legal rules, redress mechanisms, legal institutions and the societies where they operate. More importantly, this approach has also revealed the intended and unintended consequences of legal transplantation, and illuminated the difference between the law in the books and the law in action. As Professor Hensler recently and succinctly wrote, “procedures that seem on the surface to be the same or very similar may in practice operate differently as they intersect with other aspects of the litigation regime – rules, cultural expectations, political contexts – in which they are inserted.” In a multi-year book project she led almost a decade ago, Hensler and her colleagues identified the cultural, economic and political forces that impact how a single procedural device – representative litigation – operates in any given jurisdiction. The studies that comprised the project were grounded in empirical data obtained through several research strategies, specially the case study method. National jurisdictions or specific cases within those jurisdictions were used as units of analysis, and as a basis for a broader cross-country comparison that helped identify points of convergence and also key differences.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Tort Law
Volume17
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)149-202
Number of pages54
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2025
EventConference in Honor of Deborah Hensler - Stanford Law School, Stanford, United States
Duration: 20.09.202420.09.2024
https://conferences.law.stanford.edu/conference-in-honor-of-deborah-hensler/

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2025 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.
Special Issue title: Complex and International Litigation and Empirical Litigation Studies: Festschrift in Honor of Professor Deborah Hensler

    Research areas

  • Law - legal transplants, Deborah R. Hensler, comparative study, collective litigation

    ASJC Scopus Subject Areas

  • Law

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Bildkompetenz
  2. Flexible transitions from work to retirement in Germany
  3. Editorial
  4. CITY:mobil : A Model for Integration in Sustainability Research
  5. Unreine Bilder
  6. Das Prinzip des Integrativen Gendering und Diversity - Ausgangspunkt und Entwicklungspfade
  7. “I think they are irresponsible”: Teaching Sustainability with (Counter)Narratives in the EFL Classroom
  8. Leben mit Bildern, Leben in Bildern
  9. Detection of up to 65% of precancerous lesions of the human colon and rectum by mutation analysis of APC, K-Ras, B-Raf and CTNNB1.
  10. Response to Turnhout et al.’s rethinking biodiversity: From goods and services to “living with”
  11. Seeing polycentrically
  12. On the effects of redistribution on growth and entrepreneurial risk-taking
  13. “First come, first served" or “the more, the merrier"?
  14. Concentration of ciprofloxacin in Brazilian hospital effluent and preliminary risk assessment
  15. The outcome of coaching and training for self-employment. A statistical evaluation of outside assistance support programs for unemployed business founders in Germany
  16. Nutzungskonflikte zwischen Freizeitnutzern
  17. Affective States and Risky Driving Behavior of Novice and Young Drivers
  18. Understanding relational values in cultural landscapes in Romania and Germany
  19. Multiple components of plant diversity loss determine herbivore phylogenetic diversity in a subtropical forest experiment
  20. Identifikation der Erfolgsrelevanz sozialer Themen
  21. Open participation network and school health programs - Review of the BLK experiment OPUS (1997-2000) for health promotion
  22. Die neue Datenschutzverbandsklage
  23. E-textile technology
  24. Das Driving Emotion Wheel
  25. Plant functional traits explain species abundance patterns and strategies shifts among saplings and adult trees in Araucaria forests
  26. Interdisziplinär und international