The persistence of subsistence and the limits to development studies: The challenge of Tanzania

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

There are two general approaches to assessing what is known as 'development'. First, there are classical accounts focusing on Europe's development during the industrial revolution. They describe how urban areas expanded at the expense of the social and economic resources of the rural areas, disrupting an independent subsistence peasantry. A major consequence is that today all Europeans are dependent socially, politically, and economically on the modern capitalist system. The second (more common) approach to development focuses on the modern Third World. This approach assumes that, as with Europe, the entire Third World is dependent on the modern capitalist system. Development studies focus on the assessment of how Third World countries can most effectively engage world capitalism. Discussion is typically reduced to comparisons between world systems theory and neoclassical economics. The Tanzanian government has used standard policies grounded in neoclassical and world-system assumptions since independence. But both policies failed to produce the predicted economic growth. This article argues that both policies failed because the Tanzanian peasantry, like the early modern European peasantry, is not dependent on the operation of world capitalism for basic subsistence. In fact, as studies have shown, rural Tanzania is only weakly incorporated into the capitalist world system, and in consequence has not been an easy target for what world-system theorists call 'peripheral integration'. What makes Tanzania different is the fact that the rural peasantry do not use market mechanisms in the distribution of the 'means of production', especially arable land for swidden agriculture, or, for that matter, labour or cattle.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAfrica
Volume70
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)613-651
Number of pages39
ISSN0001-9720
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2000
Externally publishedYes

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Introduction to the Special Issue Section
  2. Biodiversity in space and time - towards a grid mapping for Mongolia
  3. An Integrated Case Study of the Concepts and Applications of SAP ERP HCM
  4. Monitoring fast-moving animals—Building a customized camera system and evaluation toolset
  5. Design and evaluation of learning processes in an international sustainability oriented study programme. In search of a new educational quality and assessment method
  6. Complementing AAI at the meso level
  7. Temporal Dynamics of Ecosystem Services
  8. Explicit references in chat-based CSCL
  9. Education and Communication as Prerequisites for and Components of Sustainable Development. Reflections for Policies, Conceptual Work, and Theory, Based on Previous Practises
  10. The dynamics of prioritizing
  11. Building trust
  12. Scope of the book wastewater reuse and current challenges
  13. Collaborative business in supply chains - a system dynamics approach
  14. Structure as Infrastructure: The Interrelation of Fiber and Construction
  15. The uses of isospin in early nuclear and particle physics
  16. Lexical markers of common grounds
  17. Tracking the fate of aluminium in the eu using the matrace model
  18. Evaluation of revitalization policies and redevelopment strategy for residential environment in coal mining areas
  19. Work in Progres Work on Progress
  20. Policy implementation through multi-level governance
  21. A flexible global warming index for use in an integrated approach to climate change assessment
  22. Integration of risk-oriented environmental management information systems and resource planning systems
  23. FragSAD: A database of diversity and species abundance distributions from habitat fragments
  24. Computer-mediated knowledge systems in consultancy firms: do they work?
  25. Determination of rutin in green tea infusions using square-wave voltammetry with a rigid carbon-polyurethane composite electrode
  26. Zapping-Fernbedienung
  27. Mit "gesunder" Mischung zu Stabilität und Integration?
  28. Ownership Patterns and Enterprise Groups in German Structural Business Statistics
  29. Cultural change in Asia and beyond
  30. § 36