The making of an intrinsic property: "Symmetry heuristics" in early particle physics

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

The making of an intrinsic property: "Symmetry heuristics" in early particle physics. / Borrelli, Arianna.
In: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science. Part A, Vol. 50, No. 1, 04.2015, p. 59-70.

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{eabfd60fe8e742d985b15ba6777da59f,
title = "The making of an intrinsic property: {"}Symmetry heuristics{"} in early particle physics",
abstract = "Mathematical invariances, usually referred to as {"}symmetries{"}, are today often regarded as providing a privileged heuristic guideline for understanding natural phenomena, especially those of micro-physics. The rise of symmetries in particle physics has often been portrayed by physicists and philosophers as the {"}application{"} of mathematical invariances to the ordering of particle phenomena, but no historical studies exist on whether and how mathematical invariances actually played a heuristic role in shaping microphysics. Moreover, speaking of an {"}application{"} of invariances conflates the formation of concepts of new intrinsic degrees of freedom of elementary particles with the formulation of models containing invariances with respect to those degrees of freedom. I shall present here a case study from early particle physics (ca. 1930-1954) focussed on the formation of one of the earliest concepts of a new degree of freedom, baryon number, and on the emergence of the invariance today associated to it. The results of the analysis show how concept formation and {"}application{"} of mathematical invariances were distinct components of a complex historical constellation in which, beside symmetries, two further elements were essential: the idea of physically conserved quantities and that of selection rules. I shall refer to the collection of different heuristic strategies involving selection rules, invariances and conserved quantities as the {"}SIC-triangle{"} and show how different authors made use of them to interpret the wealth of new experimental data. It was only a posteriori that the successes of this hybrid {"}symmetry heuristics{"} came to be attributed exclusively to mathematical invariances and group theory, forgetting the role of selection rules and of the notion of physically conserved quantity in the emergence of new degrees of freedom and new invariances. The results of the present investigation clearly indicate that opinions on the role of symmetries in fundamental physics need to be critically reviewed in the spirit of integrated history and philosophy of science.",
keywords = "Baryon number, Conserved quantity, Heuristics, High-energy-physics, Selection rules, Symmetry, Philosophy",
author = "Arianna Borrelli",
year = "2015",
month = apr,
doi = "10.1016/j.shpsa.2014.09.009",
language = "English",
volume = "50",
pages = "59--70",
journal = "Studies in History and Philosophy of Science. Part A",
issn = "0039-3681",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",
number = "1",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - The making of an intrinsic property

T2 - "Symmetry heuristics" in early particle physics

AU - Borrelli, Arianna

PY - 2015/4

Y1 - 2015/4

N2 - Mathematical invariances, usually referred to as "symmetries", are today often regarded as providing a privileged heuristic guideline for understanding natural phenomena, especially those of micro-physics. The rise of symmetries in particle physics has often been portrayed by physicists and philosophers as the "application" of mathematical invariances to the ordering of particle phenomena, but no historical studies exist on whether and how mathematical invariances actually played a heuristic role in shaping microphysics. Moreover, speaking of an "application" of invariances conflates the formation of concepts of new intrinsic degrees of freedom of elementary particles with the formulation of models containing invariances with respect to those degrees of freedom. I shall present here a case study from early particle physics (ca. 1930-1954) focussed on the formation of one of the earliest concepts of a new degree of freedom, baryon number, and on the emergence of the invariance today associated to it. The results of the analysis show how concept formation and "application" of mathematical invariances were distinct components of a complex historical constellation in which, beside symmetries, two further elements were essential: the idea of physically conserved quantities and that of selection rules. I shall refer to the collection of different heuristic strategies involving selection rules, invariances and conserved quantities as the "SIC-triangle" and show how different authors made use of them to interpret the wealth of new experimental data. It was only a posteriori that the successes of this hybrid "symmetry heuristics" came to be attributed exclusively to mathematical invariances and group theory, forgetting the role of selection rules and of the notion of physically conserved quantity in the emergence of new degrees of freedom and new invariances. The results of the present investigation clearly indicate that opinions on the role of symmetries in fundamental physics need to be critically reviewed in the spirit of integrated history and philosophy of science.

AB - Mathematical invariances, usually referred to as "symmetries", are today often regarded as providing a privileged heuristic guideline for understanding natural phenomena, especially those of micro-physics. The rise of symmetries in particle physics has often been portrayed by physicists and philosophers as the "application" of mathematical invariances to the ordering of particle phenomena, but no historical studies exist on whether and how mathematical invariances actually played a heuristic role in shaping microphysics. Moreover, speaking of an "application" of invariances conflates the formation of concepts of new intrinsic degrees of freedom of elementary particles with the formulation of models containing invariances with respect to those degrees of freedom. I shall present here a case study from early particle physics (ca. 1930-1954) focussed on the formation of one of the earliest concepts of a new degree of freedom, baryon number, and on the emergence of the invariance today associated to it. The results of the analysis show how concept formation and "application" of mathematical invariances were distinct components of a complex historical constellation in which, beside symmetries, two further elements were essential: the idea of physically conserved quantities and that of selection rules. I shall refer to the collection of different heuristic strategies involving selection rules, invariances and conserved quantities as the "SIC-triangle" and show how different authors made use of them to interpret the wealth of new experimental data. It was only a posteriori that the successes of this hybrid "symmetry heuristics" came to be attributed exclusively to mathematical invariances and group theory, forgetting the role of selection rules and of the notion of physically conserved quantity in the emergence of new degrees of freedom and new invariances. The results of the present investigation clearly indicate that opinions on the role of symmetries in fundamental physics need to be critically reviewed in the spirit of integrated history and philosophy of science.

KW - Baryon number

KW - Conserved quantity

KW - Heuristics

KW - High-energy-physics

KW - Selection rules

KW - Symmetry

KW - Philosophy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84932613653&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.shpsa.2014.09.009

DO - 10.1016/j.shpsa.2014.09.009

M3 - Journal articles

AN - SCOPUS:84932613653

VL - 50

SP - 59

EP - 70

JO - Studies in History and Philosophy of Science. Part A

JF - Studies in History and Philosophy of Science. Part A

SN - 0039-3681

IS - 1

ER -