Setting the agenda for climate assemblies. Trade-offs and guiding principles

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Janosch Pfeffer

Citizens’ assemblies on climate change are increasingly popular to support democratic decision-making. Such Climate Assemblies (CAs) convene representative groups of citizens formulating policy proposals after hearing experts and deliberating intensely. CAs may help addressing climate policy issues more effectively partly because their members need not worry about re-election. CAs’ effectiveness depends on their design such as the issues chosen (or not chosen) for deliberation. Agenda-setters exert substantial power by selecting certain issues and by choosing framings that benefit some solutions over others. In this paper I ask: What characterizes agendas that are suitable and legitimate for deliberation in CAs? The aim is to support practitioners in making informed agenda choices for CAs by providing a list of ten widely accepted guiding principles based on expert interviews, policy documents, and information gathered from the Knowledge Network on Climate Assemblies (KNOCA). The paper systematically discusses trade-offs of various agenda choices in the light of different CA rationales. Results show that those with system-supporting rationales tend to favour narrower agendas tailored to political demands aiming to increase immediate policy impact; those with system-disrupting rationales prefer more open agendas allowing citizens to challenge existing political practices and worldviews. Results support earlier arguments that distinctions of entire deliberative processes in either top-down or bottom-up are too simplistic and that a tool-box approach is more useful. Insights appear relevant for debates of deliberative minipublics more generally. Future research should investigate whom to involve in setting CA agendas and with how much power.

Original languageEnglish
JournalClimate Policy
Volume24
Issue number6
Pages (from-to)843-858
Number of pages16
ISSN1469-3062
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 06.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.

    Research areas

  • agenda-setting, climate change, Deliberative minipublics, design, impact, participation
  • Sustainability Governance

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Facultative Mixity and the European Union’s Trade and Investment Agreements
  2. Die Weiterbildung zum "Zertifikat Waldpädagogik" in Sachsen-Anhalt 2007 - 2008
  3. Does it Pay to Be Eco-Efficient in the European Electricity Supply Industry?
  4. Recht und Finanzierung von Erneuerbaren Energien: Bürgerbeteiligungsmodelle
  5. 20 years of performance measurement in sustainable supply chain management
  6. Geschichten und Geschichte, Isebel als literarische und historische Gestalt
  7. Dücker, Uwe von (Hg.): Straßenkids, neu lernen in der Freiburger "StrassenSchule"
  8. Issuers’ credit risk and pricing of warrants in the recent financial crisis
  9. Determinants of the export behaviour of German business services companies
  10. Do claim factors predict health care utilization after transport accidents?
  11. Der Seiteneinstieg – Neue Lehrkräfte bei der Eignungsabklärung unterstützen
  12. Vertrag über die Europäische Union (EUV) : Artikel 27c [Antrag und Information]
  13. Vertrag über die Europäische Union (EUV) : Artikel 27e [Antrag und Genehmigung]
  14. Do environmental preferences in wealthy nations persist in times of crisis?
  15. Emotionale Zustände des Fahrers und die Auswirkungen auf das Fahrverhalten
  16. Optimized neural networks for modeling of loudspeaker directivity diagrams
  17. THE SOVIET CRACKDOWN ON LITHUANIAN PARTISAN MOVEMENTS (1946–1956) – A GENOCIDE?
  18. Social and economic value in emerging decentralized energy business models
  19. Thomas Hoffmann: TERRA. Globale Herausforderungen1: Die Zukunft, die wir wollen.
  20. The coronavirus pandemic as an analogy for future sustainability challenges
  21. Über die notwendige Unmöglichkeit einer allgemeinen Erziehungswissenschaft
  22. The Stability of Factor Sensitivities of German Stock Market Sector Indices
  23. Regional differences in soil pH niche among dry grassland plants in Eurasia
  24. Vasodilatierende Substanzen in Kläranlagenabläufen und Oberflächengewässern
  25. Entity Extraction from Portuguese Legal Documents Using Distant Supervision