Scientific priorities and shepherds' perceptions of ungulate's contributions to people in rewilding landscapes

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Nature's contributions to people (NCP) are all the contributions of living nature, both beneficial and detrimental, to the societies' life's quality. Ungulates play this dual role of providers of beneficial and detrimental NCP, as they are responsible of the supply of benefits (e.g. extractive experiences, habitat maintenance) and detriments (e.g. crops damage, traffic collisions). Our aim was to analyze the NCP provided by wild ungulates through examining the scientific priorities and the shepherds' perceptions in peninsular Spain. We reviewed scientific articles of NCP provided by ungulates in Spain and conducted questionnaires regarding NCP to shepherds in farming systems where domestic and wild ungulates cohabit. Then, we compared whether the scientific priorities match with those perceived by shepherds. Both stakeholders highlight more detrimental than beneficial NCP, although there are some mismatches between scientific priorities and shepherds' perceptions. Regarding detrimental NCP, soil alteration, silvicultural damage, human safety or traffic collision were included in scientific literature but not mentioned by shepherds. Contrarywise, shepherds mainly considered grazing competence and damage to animals (i.e. game species and livestock) as important detrimental NCP. Concerning beneficial NCP, whilst hunting was prominent in the publications, shepherds did not conceived it as an important beneficial contribution and considered the regulation of organisms (i.e. scavenging alternative prey) important benefits. These results can have twofold implications. The emphasis on detrimental NCP (studied and perceived) can reinforce the idea that ungulates can threaten humans rather than contribute to societies' wellbeing. The fact that research does not address the interests of shepherds can affect the social tolerance towards ungulates as the damages experienced or perceived by shepherds are not studied. Our results show the relevance of considering local knowledge held by shepherds and their perceptions, something highlighted by the NCP approach.

Original languageEnglish
Article number135876
JournalScience of the Total Environment
Volume705
Number of pages11
ISSN0048-9697
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 25.02.2020

    Research areas

  • Bovidae, Cervidae, Conflicts, Ecosystem services, Human-ungulates relations, Suidae
  • Sustainability Science

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Anwalt, Mandant und Internet
  2. "Green-ness" Can Be Measured
  3. Ecological assessment of forest management approaches to develop resilient forests in the face of global change in Central Europe
  4. Agro-ecosystem services and dis-services in almond orchards are differentially influenced by the surrounding landscape
  5. Kurze Pässe, lange Pässe
  6. Lüneburger Versicherungsgespräche (I)
  7. Friction stir lap weld-brazing of AA7050 aluminium alloy to Ti6Al4V titanium alloy – Limitations in dissimilar metal joining
  8. Digitized planning processes in the revitalization of buildings by a inderdisciplinary project study
  9. Skizzen zeichnen zu Modellierungsaufgaben
  10. From attitudes to self-efficacy
  11. Stories of favourite Places in public spaces
  12. Straw amendment and nitrification inhibitor controlling N losses and immobilization in a soil cooling-warming experiment
  13. Notting Hill Gate 6 Basic
  14. Finanzberater in der Zange
  15. Agriculturally productive yet biodiverse
  16. DON’T ASK, DO TELL
  17. Via - communis Europa
  18. Erdgeschichte schreiben
  19. Contributions of place-based social-ecological research to address global sustainability challenges
  20. Friction stir welding of the dissimilar materials AA6082 and AISI316 for marine applications
  21. Game-supported Learning
  22. From ruins and rubble: promised and suspended futures in Kenya (and beyond)
  23. Using the three horizons approach to explore pathways towards positive futures for agricultural landscapes with rich biodiversity
  24. Digital Health Literacy of Children and Adolescents and Its Association With Sociodemographic Factors
  25. Great ape communication as contextual social inference
  26. Response distortion in personality measurement
  27. Reichsstadt Frankfurt am Main
  28. One-third codetermination at company supervisory boards and firm performance in German manufacturing industries
  29. Die Reformkonzepte Heinrich Roths - verdrängt oder vergessen?
  30. Teacher Education for Sustainable Development